
Originally Posted by
NYKalltheway
There's no Grant Hill.
There's no Tracy McGrady.
There's no Dominique Wilkins.
There's no Elgin Baylor.
There's no Penny Hardaway.
There wasn't even a mention for Michael Ray Richardson.
Half of the players are either too high or plain shouldn't be part of the top 25.
A few are underrated within the Top 25, but at least they're present.
The top 5 should be an affair between Michael Jordan, Shaquille O'Neal, Larry Bird, Magic Johnson and Hakeem Olajuwon, with guys like Wilt Chamberlain, Charles Barkley, Kareem Abdul Jabbar, Tim Duncan and perhaps one of Grant Hill, David Robinson and Kevin Durant completing the top 10. It kinda gets debatable of course, and that's the idea of this, but the guys wtih the truly high peak were ignored just because their career didn't match it.
So yeah, just another PSD meritless popularity contest.
The idea of "peak" was wrong from the get go. It has been yet another "which superstar do you like the most" for the most part and then a classic discussion between only 2 players that 2 members chose to back as if everyone else ceased existing...