
Originally Posted by
Kinkotheclown
Absolutely top 5 for both names I mentioned.
Jordan
Russel
Then some order of
Bron-Kareem-Magic-Larry-Kobe
QB is tougher because of the extremely beneficial rules to the offense and QB protection. The difference between 1/2 a step and hit to 1.5 steps to hit, to 2-3 steps to hit is a massive predictor of longevity and health. It cannot be understated and cannot be ignored. Brady is absolutely top 5. I just don't think he has anywhere close to his numbers without the 7 yard press coverage, changed to 5 yards and more importantly, the QB protection
Montana
Unitas
Elway
Marino
Manning
Brady
Are all legit top 5 arguments
I hated him but I would probably put Montana 1, Elway 2, Brady 3, Unitas 4, Manning 5