Trade Ideas Thread III

[LechWalesa]

If you're trading Kirk, you need to be getting a legit stud back. No lottery tickets.

[wamco]

I don’t like Pablo lopez with only 2
Years control for Kirk. Jansen, sure

[hanton]

Kirk isn't going anywhere, he's essentially 2 star players.

#1 catcher and a clean-up hitter

[pebloemer]

Kirk isn't going anywhere, he's essentially 2 star players.

#1 catcher and a clean-up hitter

Not sure he is a cleanup hitter. Incredibly valuable though

[ChongInc.]

Not sure he is a cleanup hitter. Incredibly valuable though

I feel the same, but I bet he has a couple hot seasons where he is worthy of the role.

[R. Johnson#3]

I wonder if Moreno + a mid level prospect would be good enough to get Montgomery and Nootbar.

[wamco]

Trade evaluator says stl would have to throw in more for Moreno alone (52-42)

[Robbie]

I wonder if Moreno + a mid level prospect would be good enough to get Montgomery and Nootbar.

I don't know players on other teams that well to judge a trade. But sucks to give up Moreno.

[Robbie]

Going to be interesting what Yanks do if Judge does sign in San Fran? They will go after big name. Will affect many teams. Correa or Bogaerts i imagine.

[town123]

One of the saner Cards posters suggested Jansen for RP Hicks and Nootbar

[mike_noodles]

Going to be interesting what Yanks do if Judge does sign in San Fran? They will go after big name. Will affect many teams. Correa or Bogaerts i imagine.

I think one of those two end up on the Dodgers.

[wamco]

Sd made an offer to judge as well. Me think my wish of rodon isn’t. Going to happen with SD and SF having money to throw around now.
Before the off-season, I thought he’d get a berrios-ish contract. That surely has gone up quite a bit.

As Chong suggested, maybe the time to get the ace is at the deadline at these prices. Go cheap-ish at SP4 for now.

Why is Kirk always mentioned as getting a bill of dh ab but not Jansen? Could be on par for hitting and Jansen can run on the bases

[ChongInc.]

Sd made an offer to judge as well. Me think my wish of rodon isn’t. Going to happen with SD and SF having money to throw around now.
Before the off-season, I thought he’d get a berrios-ish contract. That surely has gone up quite a bit.

As Chong suggested, maybe the time to get the ace is at the deadline at these prices. Go cheap-ish at SP4 for now.

Why is Kirk always mentioned as getting a bill of dh ab but not Jansen? Could be on par for hitting and Jansen can run on the bases

I think most of us don’t think Jansens bat will be consistent. He is probably peak value right now so it’s the time to strike if you don’t think he is a part of the long term.

[ChongInc.]

The asterisk to my idea of focusing on a torp at the deadline is going all in on building the best offence you can. If our lineup is the same or worse than last season then having a worse pitching staff is not a step in the right direction.

[wamco]

I’m liking the teo trade less today than the time or trade as prices rise.