How much success can a team that is 10 deep with productive players, young with potential, chemistry, great coaching and great defense go?

Is it possible for that type of team to compete with a team of 2 or 3 super stars but secondary players every where else?

If you owned a team would you rather have a team of 2 or 3 superstars and not too much else or a young exciting team that is able to throw good to very good but not great player after player after you?

Last thing I want to say is this topic is not aimed at any team intentionally or unintentionally this is just a topic I think is discussion worthy and contrary to the super team idea and topics.

Thanks for input and debate.