Like us on Facebook


Follow us on Twitter





Search:

Type: Posts; User: NYKalltheway

Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: But the issue here is not bashing modern players...

    But the issue here is not bashing modern players but assuming that previous generations wouldn't be able to do stuff just because they weren't in the rules back then! I'm not bashing modern players...
  2. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: All this started because you refuse to have a...

    All this started because you refuse to have a conversation about why you seem to judge players based on "the modern era". You have repeatedly stated that directly and indirectly. You keep ignoring...
  3. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: It's a list, not a random question. If I...

    It's a list, not a random question.

    If I participate after that awful #2 pick it means I consider that this is a legit list of any sort. I just cannot take this seriously and cannot participate...
  4. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: What do you mean "his idea of peak". If it's his...

    What do you mean "his idea of peak". If it's his idea, then there's no need for a poll. He just makes his list based on that.

    This is "everyone's" idea of peak. And it's appalling really
  5. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: What's to pretend? You are clearly...

    What's to pretend?
    You are clearly discriminating against players that you haven't seen, do not know their characteristics, assume that they'd not be good in this cupcake era and then have an...
  6. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: Nope, people are genuinely dismissing older...

    Nope, people are genuinely dismissing older players because they imagine that they wouldn't be able to play now without shooting threes or whatever.

    How about taking Curry or even Durant back in...
  7. Replies
    49
    Views
    1,153

    Poll: I asked again. Why so much emphasis on the modern...

    I asked again. Why so much emphasis on the modern era? Why does it get to define how basketball greatness is measured?
  8. Replies
    53
    Views
    1,228

    Poll: Why do you adjust this comparison for the modern...

    Why do you adjust this comparison for the modern game?
  9. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    I said the Regular Season sucks. And it does. ...

    I said the Regular Season sucks. And it does.

    Limited defensive game, too many threes, too much me-basketball (some teams have been slowly reduce that and moved to proper team basketball and...
  10. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    I don't watch day to day anymore. I catch an...

    I don't watch day to day anymore. I catch an occasional game and watch several playoff series.

    I do have more access to games these days but it just doesn't drive me to spend 3.5 hours at morning...
  11. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    That is very inaccurate. Apart from Lebron not...

    That is very inaccurate. Apart from Lebron not being that good. That is true. Lebron is "not that good" when you claim he's GOAT or anywhere near the top 5. That's fact. He's the best player of the...
  12. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    Ok Valade, please stop talking to me about stats...

    Ok Valade, please stop talking to me about stats and talk to this guy now.

    When you decide what your "faction" believes in, you can return to trying to argue against what you think I believe in,...
  13. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    But you refuse the eye test. At least be...

    But you refuse the eye test.

    At least be consistent. I never said that stats are completely irrelevant as you think I am some guy who never uses them. I've said many times that I probably use...
  14. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    You are allowed to talk about him. If you...

    You are allowed to talk about him.

    If you want to rate him and compare him with more recent players then at least have the decency to watch at least 30 games of this player throughout his career...
  15. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    Feels more like numbers are in front of the...

    Feels more like numbers are in front of the picture for most of these guys and it's all they see to the extent that they think that's the actual picture.
  16. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: Wonder what you have to say about Lebron at #2.

    Wonder what you have to say about Lebron at #2.
  17. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    And you have access to them? Have you ever...

    And you have access to them?

    Have you ever used this in an argument on PSD? Like an exact argument of how Kobe or Lebron would behave with different teammates? I've never seen you do that....
  18. Replies
    213
    Views
    8,607

    What makes the "numbers" even stupider is the...

    What makes the "numbers" even stupider is the fact that any player would have had different stats playing for another team or under a different system or with different teammates. They take it as...
  19. Replies
    191
    Views
    10,086

    Great news

    Great news
  20. Replies
    30
    Views
    1,207

    Finally a real coach. Now all that's left is a...

    Finally a real coach. Now all that's left is a roster that's willing to be part of a team.
  21. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: Why not? It's a a team sport. Why is it...

    Why not? It's a a team sport. Why is it inconceivable that the best player may not be a part of the best team?
  22. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: Is his opinion valid when it matches yours?

    Is his opinion valid when it matches yours?
  23. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: Oscar Robertson claims that Elgin Baylor is the...

    Oscar Robertson claims that Elgin Baylor is the greatest ever.
    Just saying.
  24. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: It's peak. Oscar was great but what was great...

    It's peak. Oscar was great but what was great about him was consistency. You really don't seem to grasp the idea of PEAK, given that you started all this, do you? :D

    The only recent player that...
  25. Replies
    87
    Views
    2,675

    Poll: Should be a question between Baylor, Erving,...

    Should be a question between Baylor, Erving, Walton, Tmac and Barkley... Yet everyone focuses on the past 5 seasons lol
Results 1 to 25 of 200
Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4