I want Harbaugh over all three !!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrei00
Printable View
I want Harbaugh over all three !!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrei00
Agree. Just saying I’m not worried about a retread so long as the new GM has a clear plan and true authority in hiring.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrei00
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I wouldn't mind Harbaugh for sure, but it's still Pederson for me. He's a good offensive playcaller, has experience building some type of effective schemes even around questionable personnel. He helped pioneer what is now a bit of a 4th down revolution league-wide, showed he can work with analytics, and his RPO scheme could help salvage DJ.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brooklyndave
I know there's no chance in hell this will happen, because why should we be allowed to have nice things, but there is nobody I can think of I would rather have. But hey, that's just me.
Harbaugh probably was only going to be an option if he hired Hortiz. Would have loved the guy but doubt it now.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
IT IS JOE SCHOEN as the new GM .
And the search for a HC begins in earnest now
I like Schoen. He was my top choice with the 49ers guy #2
Solid hire. By all accounts a guy who can run the entire organization from analytics to pro personnel and draft / scouting.
He’s going to need time to clean up the remnants of the Gettleman disaster left behind. 2022 is basically dead on arrival given the cap situation so this coming year is about clearing cap space, drafting well to rebuild the roster and creating the foundation for the next few.
Big questions he’s gonna face right away.
Who will he hire as HC/OC? What’s the plan at QB?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The Giants are expected to interview two of their HC candidates — #Bills OC Brian Daboll and DC Leslie Frazier — this weekend in Buffalo, source said. Their new GM Joe Schoen is still in town, so this all makes sense. Both should happen tomorrow.
Giants have also requested interviews with Brian Flores and Dan Quinn
Sent from my SM-G981U using Tapatalk
Wink Martindale is leaving Baltimore. Curious timing. Gotta wonder if Schoen has reached out to him already for a DC position - especially if Dabbols gets the HC gig.
Would also love for them to snag Vic Fangio as DC once they have a HC.
Interesting times.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
If it is Flores then Graham probably stays but I would like Fangio .Quote:
Originally Posted by GottaBelieve
Daboll, Frazier, Leftwich and Bieniemy could all turn out to be excellent HCs but the present state of The Giants warrants someone who has head coaching experience. That said, I guess the choice should be among Pederson, Flores, Quinn or Caldwell, ( I don't think that Harbaugh is realistically in the mix ) . I think that Frazier might have had a very limited HC experience .
The last 3 coaches had no head coaching experience. I also think that all the assistants should have NFL experience
P.S. Doesn't Brian Dobell look like Toby on This Is Us ?
I don’t think they have to hire a person with HC experience - though I’m not against it either.
The last 3 HCs were all done in by the Giants lack of a process and lack of commitment to rebuild. Not saying any of them were great but it’s hard to judge people fairly when the organization was so dysfunctional.
By all accounts now the Giants are finally doing this right. So I’m ready to be patient for a few years with whoever they hire to rebuild this thing right.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don’t see why it has to be someone with HC experience some of the best minds in the nfl are in their first HC job and in the playoffs like mcvay,lafluer, McDermott, shanahan, vrabel and Taylor. That’s 6/8 remaining teams being ran by a first time head coach. Just need to get the right guy.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brooklyndave
Shurmur was a failed HC with the browns before we had him here.
Frazier had 1 winning season in 3 years with minny btw.
The other experienced guys have had some success for sure but also flaws exposed that resulted in their eventual ousting. Could they learn from their experience and grow as coaches? Absolutely. I would personally rather take a chance on new blood but wouldn’t complain about Flores or even Pederson too much.
That all said Daboll seems like a slam dunk to be the guy. Plenty of reports that he come in tandem with Schoen and then he was interviewed the same day Schoen was hired. He’s the landslide favorite imo but I’m sure they with host 4-5 interviews for optics/due diligence.
It’s a blessing for Schoen to not have to engage in a long drawn out HC search as he has plenty of work to do on the roster and in draft preparation.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
If it weren't for the fact that they are both 74 years young, I would lobby for either of the big boys for DC, Romeo or Wade. Fangio would be a fine hire as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by GottaBelieve
It wouldn't surprise me if Graham stays as DC unless he gets an HC opportunity elsewhere.
It’s going to depend on what style of defense the HC wants to play and if graham is capable of adjusting to that preference. If it’s Flores it’s a slam dunk he stays. Not so sure otherwise.Quote:
Originally Posted by eeek78
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Apparently Giants will also interview Patrick Graham for the job
Sent from my ONEPLUS A6013 using Tapatalk