I’ll be honest, I don’t even scout QBs. I don’t consider myself qualified. The position is so nuanced in terms of the mental side of the game, isolating what the QB messed up vs someone else, judging whether a throw will translate vs NFL coverage, etc.
For instance, Mac Jones seems to have the mental side down. But NFL defensive schemes are way more advanced. What I’d want to do is find the instances where clearly he was confused by the other team. How did he handle that play? How did he adjust in the future for what he saw? And then as far as physically throwing the ball, I’d want to really analyze the windows he threw into. Will NFL defenders close them? Does he throw with anticipation or does he wait for guys to get open and then throw? (The latter is a deathwish in the NFL IMO.)
It’s just too complex a scouting job for me to even try, TBH. So I won’t comment on if we should trade up for someone in the “top 5” or if the Trask/Mond/Mills/Newman tier is legit after them. I’ll just keep it generic and say that “if BB thinks he sees a viable starter he better go get him wherever that range is and he better be right about who is or isn’t the guy”. Drafting a QB position I’m going to try to “grade” or share an opinion on.