PDA

View Full Version : NBA 2K19 Overrated/Underrated Players



Bruins2012
08-20-2018, 09:38 PM
With the game coming out letís talk about who has a rating that doesnít match their skill in the NBA.

First Iíd have to go with Kemba. Always underrated and should be at least an 87-88. Has been stuck on a mediocre team his entire career with a bunch of guys who arenít reliable scorers.

Draymond Green. Overrated. Love the intangibles he brings to a team but he has no offensive game and should be an 85-86.

Who else?





Also feel like Jimmy Butler at SF should be an 88-89, and Wiggins should be the SG on the Wolves.

Rubio should be at least and 80 also. As a pure PG he has been very good and only looked better in Utah.

And Luka Doncic should be the highest rated rookie by a few points.

Feel like Melo will need a boost across the board with his shooting and a minus on the defensive side of the ball. He should do well with the Rockets. Could see him back around an 84-85 overall.

Rudy Gay - Overrated. With DeMar coming aboard and Bertans eating into his minutes this year, Gay should be around an 80. Maybe even a 79.

A lot of players should be lower. Should be more seperation.

LeBron should be a 99. Generational talent and easily in the top 3-5ever, maybe 1-2.

No one else should be above 96.....maybe Durant, but he is a bit of a ***** cat.

cmellofan15
08-20-2018, 09:58 PM
Hereís a list of confirmed ratings so far for those who havenít seen it

http://www.2kratings.com/confirmed-player-ratings

Bruins2012
08-20-2018, 10:51 PM
Hereís a list of confirmed ratings so far for those who havenít seen it

http://www.2kratings.com/confirmed-player-ratings


Weird there arenít any 88s. I would put PG and DeMar as 88s. Drummond is too high. Should be around 85-86.

Not sure about Towns. Iím sure his defense will need to be lowered since he doesnít play any.

Jeffy25
08-20-2018, 10:51 PM
Weird there arenít any 88s. I would put PG and DeMar as 88s. Drummond is too high. Should be around 85-86.

Not sure about Towns. Iím sure his defense will need to be lowered since he doesnít play any.

Only 28 guys confirmed

tp13baby
08-21-2018, 11:45 AM
Edit I will wait til the confirmations come out. Towns is not 91 though

IndyRealist
08-21-2018, 12:27 PM
In what world is Melo better than Rudy Gay?

Tg11
08-21-2018, 06:35 PM
What be the ratings for Lonzo, Tatum, Fultz, Simmons, Mitchell, etc but how bout the players from this year draft class?

Tg11
08-21-2018, 06:53 PM
I don't see ratings for Harden, Kyrie, Hayward, Paul, Porzingis, Whiteside, Lowry, Wall, Beal, Jokic, etc

Bruins2012
08-21-2018, 07:21 PM
In what world is Melo better than Rudy Gay?


Iím not sure.

Bruins2012
08-21-2018, 07:22 PM
What about guys like Reggie Jackson and Tobias Harris?

JordansBulls
08-21-2018, 07:27 PM
Lebron is wayy too high. Should be about a 93.

Bruins2012
08-21-2018, 09:31 PM
Avery Bradley should be a little lower too.

Cal827
08-21-2018, 10:54 PM
Kawhi, Towns, Demar all could lose 1 or two to their overalls. Maybe Tatum too (I'd probably have both him and Brown at 85ish). Kuzma and Blake could probably be a bit higher.

I would expect that Steph/Durant would be 95ish

Maybe a Laker fan can tell me a bit more about Hart? I've heard a fair bit about him from summer league but haven't seen much of his game. Is his rating justified or is it more of a summer league overhype which occasionally happens?

GREATNESS ONE
08-22-2018, 12:08 AM
In what world is Melo better than Rudy Gay?

not yours? check Basketball reference!

GREATNESS ONE
08-22-2018, 12:09 AM
Lebron is wayy too high. Should be about a 93.

lmfao stop, sit down, smoke a joint, it will be ok. More like 99... and I can't stand him, growing to like him as a person. Great player.

Bruins2012
08-22-2018, 01:26 AM
Yeah, I didnít really think that one through. I assume Melo will go up by being on Houston and only having to stand and shoot. Figured Gay would go down with DeMar and Bertans eating into his minutes.

Bruins2012
08-22-2018, 01:28 AM
What be the ratings for Lonzo, Tatum, Fultz, Simmons, Mitchell, etc but how bout the players from this year draft class?

Luka is the most NBA ready and should have the highest rating. Tatum should be above Simmons too.

Bruins2012
08-22-2018, 01:31 AM
Kawhi, Towns, Demar all could lose 1 or two to their overalls. Maybe Tatum too (I'd probably have both him and Brown at 85ish). Kuzma and Blake could probably be a bit higher.

I would expect that Steph/Durant would be 95ish

Maybe a Laker fan can tell me a bit more about Hart? I've heard a fair bit about him from summer league but haven't seen much of his game. Is his rating justified or is it more of a summer league overhype which occasionally happens?


I feel like most of the 1st and 2nd year players should be a little lower, so they all donít get too good too soon. Then youíre left with a bunch of average young players with ratings too high (80 and above) not reflective of where some of them stand on their own teams.

IndyRealist
08-22-2018, 08:48 AM
not yours? check Basketball reference!

I did. If you think Melo was better than Gay last year, I don't know what to tell you.