PDA

View Full Version : Which player do you take here in each comparison and why?



JordansBulls
09-21-2016, 07:39 PM
Which player do you take here and why?

Derrick Rose 2011 or Steve Nash 2005

Jason Kidd 2002 or Allen Iverson 2001

Stephen Curry 2016 or Magic Johnson 1990

Wilt 1967 or Shaq 2000

Russell 1965 or Hakeem 1994

Wade 2006 or Kobe 2009

Lebron 2012 or Duncan 1999 (lockout season's)

2004 Garnett or 2006 Dirk

2005 Tmac or 1984 Bernard King

2014 Kevin Durant or 1981 Julius Erving

YAALREADYKNO
09-21-2016, 10:41 PM
Kg about to retire too. That HOF Class with Kobe, Duncan, and Garnett is probably gonna be the best class ever

FlashBolt
09-21-2016, 11:10 PM
Kg about to retire too. That HOF Class with Kobe, Duncan, and Garnett is probably gonna be the best class ever

Yeah, it was a brutal year. Two top ten players and one top 15-20. KG actually retired a few years ago unofficially, though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

YAALREADYKNO
09-23-2016, 08:18 AM
Yeah, it was a brutal year. Two top ten players and one top 15-20. KG actually retired a few years ago unofficially, though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah man the guys from the 90's will all soon be gone within a year or two

KnicksorBust
09-23-2016, 10:30 AM
Which player do you take here and why?

Derrick Rose 2011 or Steve Nash 2005

Jason Kidd 2002 or Allen Iverson 2001

Stephen Curry 2016 or Magic Johnson 1990

Wilt 1967 or Shaq 2000

Russell 1965 or Hakeem 1994

Wade 2006 or Kobe 2009

Lebron 2012 or Duncan 1999 (lockout season's)

2004 Garnett or 2006 Dirk

2005 Tmac or 1984 Bernard King

2014 Kevin Durant or 1981 Julius Erving

I went with the player I believe did a better job making their teammates better or dominated offensively.

valade16
09-23-2016, 04:22 PM
I went with the player I believe did a better job making their teammates better or dominated offensively.

Very surprised at Magic's 90 over Curry's 16. Was that the year the Lakers beat the Blazers in the WCF when they were underdogs?

Chronz
09-23-2016, 05:55 PM
I went with the player I believe did a better job making their teammates better or dominated offensively.

Tmac ran the Rox, without him they were lottery bound, with him they were FAR greater than King's Nets or Knicks or whatever Leastern team he led.

JAZZNC
09-24-2016, 08:36 AM
Tmac ran the Rox, without him they were lottery bound, with him they were FAR greater than King's Nets or Knicks or whatever Leastern team he led.

You just can't handle any sort of T-Mac criticism can you? Does is physically hurt you?

Chronz
09-24-2016, 09:59 PM
You just can't handle any sort of T-Mac criticism can you? Does is physically hurt you?

I piss blood bro but it doesn't hurt

Raps18-19 Champ
09-25-2016, 01:13 AM
Which player do you take here and why?

Derrick Rose 2011 or Steve Nash 2005

Jason Kidd 2002 or Allen Iverson 2001

Stephen Curry 2016 or Magic Johnson 1990

Wilt 1967 or Shaq 2000

Russell 1965 or Hakeem 1994

Wade 2006 or Kobe 2009

Lebron 2012 or Duncan 1999 (lockout season's)

2004 Garnett or 2006 Dirk

2005 Tmac or 1984 Bernard King

2014 Kevin Durant or 1981 Julius Erving

:win:

Raps18-19 Champ
09-25-2016, 01:13 AM
Kg about to retire too. That HOF Class with Kobe, Duncan, and Garnett is probably gonna be the best class ever

What about Jordan, D-Rob and Stockton in 2009?

europagnpilgrim
09-25-2016, 02:28 AM
Which player do you take here and why?

Derrick Rose 2011 or Steve Nash 2005

Jason Kidd 2002 or Allen Iverson 2001

Stephen Curry 2016 or Magic Johnson 1990

Wilt 1967 or Shaq 2000

Russell 1965 or Hakeem 1994

Wade 2006 or Kobe 2009

Lebron 2012 or Duncan 1999 (lockout season's)

2004 Garnett or 2006 Dirk

2005 Tmac or 1984 Bernard King

2014 Kevin Durant or 1981 Julius Erving

Remix version

Rose 2011
The Answer 1999&2000&2001
Magic 1987
Dipper 1962&1963(most dominant solo act ever by a wide gap, has his own tier)
Russell 8peat seasons
Wade 2006&2009
Lebron 2007&2009&2010&2012
KG - 2000-03&2004&2008
TMac - 2001-05
Erving ABA&NBA version

I know I didn't stick to the original script, I just added my 2 cents to it for fun

this would also make a hell of an Olympic team

JAZZNC
09-25-2016, 05:55 PM
I piss blood bro but it doesn't hurt
Good, I was starting to worry!

Sanjay
01-20-2017, 12:50 AM
Which player do you take here and why?

Derrick Rose 2011 or Steve Nash 2005

Jason Kidd 2002 or Allen Iverson 2001

Stephen Curry 2016 or Magic Johnson 1990

Wilt 1967 or Shaq 2000

Russell 1965 or Hakeem 1994

Wade 2006 or Kobe 2009

Lebron 2012 or Duncan 1999 (lockout season's)

2004 Garnett or 2006 Dirk

2005 Tmac or 1984 Bernard King

2014 Kevin Durant or 1981 Julius Erving

Nash - Better ability to make everybody else better
Iverson - Can't beat the crossover
Magic - Same as Nash
Chamberlain
Olajuwon
Kobe
LeBron
Garnett - Better all-round game
McGrady
Erving