2015 ATRD Archive Thread

[warfelg]

One more quick rule question.

Does the 7 player limit for 90s+ players include these 5 free agents?

Yea. There's a limit to 7 total roster spots from 90's and 2000's to today groupings.

[homestarunner93]

I was ok with the explanation. I didn't agree with your explanation based on the wording of the rules but as I said in my very first response I would adapt. I understand first time players in any game are at a disadvantage and that I would be almost surely going to be making rookie mistakes, but you came across strong in your stance that I am right and several newcomers are wrong.

For me the reasonable response would of been something along these lines.

This is how we have been playing the game for years (or however long you guys have been playing). Even though its clear to me and veteran owners I can understand how the wording could be misconstrued for first time players, but its too late in the draft to change as some people drafted based on experience playing the game, and others drafted based on the written rules. In this case of making the best of a bad situation I think the correct path is too play according to past practice. In the off season I will look to make some corrections to the rules to better avoid this happening again.

LOL

I did admit that I saw how it could be confusing to first-time players. I did say it was too late to change anything.

[homestarunner93]

One more quick rule question.

Does the 7 player limit for 90s+ players include these 5 free agents?

Yes. 7 players total per team for those decades.

[Plague]

Yes. 7 players total per team for those decades.

Thanks

[unleashthebeast]

TE Riley Odoms with my 24th rounder. 25th rounder coming shortly

[unleashthebeast]

HOF Tony Canadeo with the other pick

[homestarunner93]

Rich "Tombstone" Jackson

[The Jokemaker]

Harold Carmichael

[Wrench]

Fred Arbanas, TE

[StriveGreatness]

Coy Bacon - Raiders

[StriveGreatness]

Sean Taylor

[warfelg]

Steve Jordan TE

[warfelg]

Where can we put dropped players.

[homestarunner93]

Where can we put dropped players.

The FA thread. Just say that you drop them.

[warfelg]

The FA thread. Just say that you drop them.

Sweet thanks.

[BDawk4Prez]

Charlie Trippi

[Ebbs]

Pete Retzlaff TE

[TDjacksonville]

Don burroughs

[Plague]

What is the benefit of dropping a player?

[Plague]

Don burroughs

Taken by Pottsville in the 16th round.

[Plague]

Canton takes DT/NT Bob Baumhower

[TDjacksonville]

Dave brown

[warfelg]

What is the benefit of dropping a player?

Options. Especially in the 90's-2000's group. Since that slot has a cap, if you feel you might improve and Cavan get someone else you do.

[The Jokemaker]

Tom Jackson, LB

[The Long Shot]

WR-Jim Benton.

[homestarunner93]

John Henry Johnson

[Ebbs]

Mike Curtis

[unleashthebeast]

Jerome ****ing Brown please :drool:

[Plague]

Canton takes WR-Stanley Morgan

[BDawk4Prez]

Gary Clark - WR

[rawz]

jimmy hill cowboys

[Wrench]

Canton takes WR-Stanley Morgan

I already took him in the draft.


Leroy Kelly, RB

[rawz]

well, updated clubhouse. not sure if ill make the cut. was a fun game, not a fan of the restrictions though, but new the rules and agreed, and I know im in the minority. thanks for including me. was a learning experience

[Wrench]

Yea if you went over the max of 7 total players from the 90s-00s then your going to have to drop guys to get under.

[BDawk4Prez]

So, when we do the write ups (assuming you are playoff bound) are we only indicating starters and operating from a base package or what?

I know this has been discussed elsewhere but I don't remember the point of reference.

[homestarunner93]

well, updated clubhouse. not sure if ill make the cut. was a fun game, not a fan of the restrictions though, but new the rules and agreed, and I know im in the minority. thanks for including me. was a learning experience

Thanks for playing.


So, when we do the write ups (assuming you are playoff bound) are we only indicating starters and operating from a base package or what?

I know this has been discussed elsewhere but I don't remember the point of reference.

No, the starters are just supposed to be your primary players. Like, take my roster for example. I don't want someone to start Mark Bavaro at TE to fill a decade requirement and then say, "Jimmy Graham will be as much/more than Bavaro at TE." Rather, Bavaro is my starter, and Graham will be a RZ/match-up guy from time-to-time. Not a full-time or near-full-time player at TE.

[homestarunner93]

I already took him in the draft.


Leroy Kelly, RB

Also taken already lol

[BDawk4Prez]

Thanks for playing.



No, the starters are just supposed to be your primary players. Like, take my roster for example. I don't want someone to start Mark Bavaro at TE to fill a decade requirement and then say, "Jimmy Graham will be as much/more than Bavaro at TE." Rather, Bavaro is my starter, and Graham will be a RZ/match-up guy from time-to-time. Not a full-time or near-full-time player at TE.

Got it.

[BDawk4Prez]

Also taken already lol

I would like Joe Montana please.

Steal!

[Wrench]

Also taken already lol

Oh really? Hahaha welp.

Floyd Little, RB? At work and forgot to update my list.

[The Jokemaker]

Bart Starr, QB

[warfelg]

Ty Law CB

[TDjacksonville]

Henry ellard

[homestarunner93]

BDawk requests Chuck Foreman

[homestarunner93]

And I will take Michael Dean Perry

[Wrench]

Reggie Wayne is on the block. Had to put him on the bench due to decade requirements, looking for WR (80's), S (50's) or DT (80's) mostly but will talk any kind of trade.

Will not give him away, but figured someone might get better use.

[The Jokemaker]

Clarke Hinkle, FB/LB

[Plague]

Is there a end date to free agent rounds? I am trying to gauge how long I have to pick the remainder of my players.

Unless its already written any chance the last 24 hours of free agency you can lift the 6 hour rule?

[Plague]

Both Chuck Foreman and Ty Law was taken in the draft.

Hard to believe no one drafted Bart Starr.

[homestarunner93]

Clarke Hinkle, FB/LB

He was taken as well. LOL.

[TDjacksonville]

Sonny jurgenson

[Plague]

Canton will take WR-Gene Washington.

[warfelg]

My B. Ty Law was taken, his name was too short to work in a search.

[warfelg]

Dale Dodrill LB

[warfelg]

Dropping Keith Brooking like it's hot.

[Wrench]

Richie Petitbon, S

[BDawk4Prez]

Ray childress

[Plague]

Canton will take T-Ed Healey from the 1920's

[BDawk4Prez]

Replacing Foreman with neal Anderson

[homestarunner93]

Charlie Waters

[warfelg]

Chris Dishman, CB

[homestarunner93]

My last one will be: Gary Clark

[The Long Shot]

Vikings will drop SS-Darren Woodson and add our new slot CB in Antoine Winfield.

[Plague]

Canton will take S-Jerry Norton

[Wrench]

Len Dawson, QB for my backup.

[BDawk4Prez]

My last one will be: Gary Clark

I already took him FA.

[BCB mwat15]

My fault, I thought we were only going 22 Rds without specialists. I think I have 3 to make up. To the best of my knowledge none of these players were picked here or in the FA thread.

RB Mercury Morris

CB Troy Vincent

WR Lionel Taylor

[Plague]

Canton will take clay matthews sr

[Ebbs]

Goose Gonsoulin S

[TDjacksonville]

Drop Adrian Wilson.

Pickup Darren woodson

[TDjacksonville]

Drop steve Wisniewski.

Pickup Steve Hutchinson.

[warfelg]

I think we need to hit the rankings period at this point. I would say put out a 48 hour FA notice PM, and give a week to get rankings in. Time to get this thing onto the next stage.

[homestarunner93]

I think we need to hit the rankings period at this point. I would say put out a 48 hour FA notice PM, and give a week to get rankings in. Time to get this thing onto the next stage.

Yep. I'm going to put some stuff in announcements now.

[homestarunner93]

FA will close at 12:00 AM Monday (8/17). You'll have until 12:00 AM Wednesday (8/19) to get your clubhouse in order. Then balloting will start.

[Ramon Nivar]

90. Baltimore Colts (via Wolverines) - Marion Motley, FB/LB

One day Motley will get respect on here. I still think he's a top 50 pick.

Speaking of great picks
121. Philadelphia Eagles - Leo Nomellini, DT
159. Dayton Triangles - Andy Robustelli, DE
196. Buffalo All-Americans - Rickey Jackson, LB
280. Minnesota Vikings - Gary Zimmerman, OT
322. Philadelphia Eagles - Tommy Nobis, LB
360. Phil-Pitt Steagles - Mark Gastineau, DE
401. Minnesota Vikings - Sid Luckman, QB

These all stuck out to me. I don't know how the game went and quickly went through the board, but all of these seem darn nice at where they went. Kudos to y'all.

[homestarunner93]

90. Baltimore Colts (via Wolverines) - Marion Motley, FB/LB

One day Motley will get respect on here. I still think he's a top 50 pick.

Speaking of great picks
121. Philadelphia Eagles - Leo Nomellini, DT
159. Dayton Triangles - Andy Robustelli, DE
196. Buffalo All-Americans - Rickey Jackson, LB
280. Minnesota Vikings - Gary Zimmerman, OT
322. Philadelphia Eagles - Tommy Nobis, LB
360. Phil-Pitt Steagles - Mark Gastineau, DE
401. Minnesota Vikings - Sid Luckman, QB

These all stuck out to me. I don't know how the game went and quickly went through the board, but all of these seem darn nice at where they went. Kudos to y'all.

Wish you could have been in this year. We missed you and SC.

[Ramon Nivar]

Wish you could have been in this year. We missed you and SC.

Hopefully next year. This one was always my favorite. :(

[warfelg]

Yep. I'm going to put some stuff in announcements now.

Coolio, just thought I would bring it up since the FA thread died.

[Ebbs]

Everyone thinks they have the best team but if you want to do a deadline blockbuster hit me up.

[Plague]

Canton drops Dan Dierdorf

[TDjacksonville]

Drop steve hutchinson.
Pickup dan dierdorf

[WildWesty]

Drop Joe Thomas :(

Add Steve Wisniewski

[WildWesty]

Dave Dalby

[WildWesty]

And George Andrie

[WildWesty]

Actually let's cut Darby and add Duane Putnam

[WildWesty]

And if they are still there I want Raymond Clayborn as my nickel CB & Jay Novacek as my TE2

[StriveGreatness]

lavern torgeson

[homestarunner93]

For voting:

Just rank every team that has a clubhouse. PM ballots to me. I'll work out ineligibility as I get ballots. I think we'll do 12 playoff teams, so the top four will have byes. The first two rounds will be in here, then the Final 4 and Championship in the main forum.


I won't put a hard due date on it yet, but let's say 12 AM next Monday tentatively. Hopefully we'll have plenty so that we can get rolling on voting then.

[homestarunner93]

Still waiting on a few ballots. PLEASE send them within the next couple of days.

[homestarunner93]

I will post what I have on Friday. If you want to be in the playoffs and have not sent a ballot, do so immediately

[warfelg]

Any ETA on rankings and match ups?

[Norm]

Any ETA on rankings and match ups?

We won. It's over.

[warfelg]

Lewisbery PA repping USA in LLWS. Just 80 miles from me.

[homestarunner93]

Got caught up last night. Sorry. Adding up the scores now.

[homestarunner93]

Triangles 1 5 2 1 1 4 2 1 5 1 = 23
Eskimos 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 9 3 2 = 24
Maroons 3 10 5 5 14 8 6 13 5 3 = 72
Eagles 4 7 7 6 10 12 7 12 11 6 = 82
Dolphins 5 11 9 5 2 7 3 4 2 1 = 49
Steagles 6 4 6 11 7 6 13 9 6 8 12 = DQ no ballot
Jets 7 16 9 12 5 6 13 2 4 11 = 85
Wolverines 8 12 3 4 8 8 10 11 9 8 = 81
Bulldogs 9 11 10 13 10 12 8 3 14 9 = 99
Staleys 10 13 15 3 6 9 11 4 8 16 13 = DQ no ballot
Raiders 11 6 10 15 4 9 5 12 15 7 = 94
Colts 12 9 13 8 9 3 3 14 10 13 5 = 99
Cowboys 13 15 12 12 14 15 16 15 15 12 14 = DQ no ballot
All-Americans 14 2 14 16 15 11 15 16 11 10 = 124
Steam Rollers 15 3 8 14 3 2 5 10 7 7 15 = DQ no ballot
Titans 16 14 16 13 16 16 14 16 14 10 16 = DQ no ballot
Vikings 8 4 7 11 13 4 7 1 6 4 = 65


Just decided to let everyone who voted in the playoffs. Here is the bracket:

http://challonge.com/tournaments/bracket_generator?ref=ySnzVwbmfr

Jets/Raiders, Maroons/AAs, Eagles/Colts, Wolverines/Bulldogs will play the first round. I think we might just do all of our voting in the main forum, doubt we'll have much here if we do it here. Pointless to have match-ups that are all like 4-3 if we can help it. Anyways, I would like to post those match-ups soon. Monday night would be good. No need to send write-ups. Just duke it out in the thread.

[warfelg]

Wow that voting was....wow. Just really up and down. Lots of variance. Many teams having a 10-12 place swing between the highest and lowest voted spot. Just interesting.

Just out of curiosity, id the first number next to each teams name all the same ballot and on and on?

[BDawk4Prez]

Triangles 1 5 2 1 1 4 2 1 5 1 = 23
Eskimos 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 9 3 2 = 24
Maroons 3 10 5 5 14 8 6 13 5 3 = 72
Eagles 4 7 7 6 10 12 7 12 11 6 = 82
Dolphins 5 11 9 5 2 7 3 4 2 1 = 49
Steagles 6 4 6 11 7 6 13 9 6 8 12 = DQ no ballot
Jets 7 16 9 12 5 6 13 2 4 11 = 85
Wolverines 8 12 3 4 8 8 10 11 9 8 = 81
Bulldogs 9 11 10 13 10 12 8 3 14 9 = 99
Staleys 10 13 15 3 6 9 11 4 8 16 13 = DQ no ballot
Raiders 11 6 10 15 4 9 5 12 15 7 = 94
Colts 12 9 13 8 9 3 3 14 10 13 5 = 99
Cowboys 13 15 12 12 14 15 16 15 15 12 14 = DQ no ballot
All-Americans 14 2 14 16 15 11 15 16 11 10 = 124
Steam Rollers 15 3 8 14 3 2 5 10 7 7 15 = DQ no ballot
Titans 16 14 16 13 16 16 14 16 14 10 16 = DQ no ballot
Vikings 8 4 7 11 13 4 7 1 6 4 = 65


Just decided to let everyone who voted in the playoffs. Here is the bracket:

http://challonge.com/tournaments/bracket_generator?ref=bBcOswUMEN

Raiders/Colts, Jets/Bulldogs, and Wolverines/AAs will play the first round. I think we might just do all of our voting in the main forum, doubt we'll have much here if we do it here. Pointless to have match-ups that are all like 4-3 if we can help it. Anyways, I would like to post those match-ups soon. Monday night would be good. No need to send write-ups. Just duke it out in the thread.

Wait, I didn't make the playoffs?

[homestarunner93]

Wait, I didn't make the playoffs?

Nah, you obviously made it. I just left you out on accident. First post is updated with the correct bracket and match-ups.

[The Long Shot]

Christ. I freaked out for a second because I was worried you hadn't received my ballot, until I saw my name at the very end. I'm surprised I got 4th seed because only four people voted me 4th or higher (virtual high-five to the guy that voted me #1, whoever you are).

[homestarunner93]

Wow that voting was....wow. Just really up and down. Lots of variance. Many teams having a 10-12 place swing between the highest and lowest voted spot. Just interesting.

Just out of curiosity, id the first number next to each teams name all the same ballot and on and on?

Yes, those should match up if you go down the column

[warfelg]

I hate to question things....but when I type these up I get 6 teams with an extra vote.
1st place - 11
2nd place - 11
3rd place - 11
4th - 11
5th - 10
6th - 11
7th - 10
8th - 11
9th - 10
10th - 10
11th - 10
12th - 10
13th - 9
14th - 10
15th - 11
16th - 11
Just saying....that's kinda off.

[homestarunner93]

I hate to question things....but when I type these up I get 6 teams with an extra vote.
1st place - 11
2nd place - 11
3rd place - 11
4th - 11
5th - 10
6th - 11
7th - 10
8th - 11
9th - 10
10th - 10
11th - 10
12th - 10
13th - 9
14th - 10
15th - 11
16th - 11
Just saying....that's kinda off.

I don't mind you asking questions, but you should check your math before you do. I searched every single one of those that you said came out less than 11 times, and they all came out 11 times. Yes, 6 teams have more votes than everyone else. If you'd take care to look, you'd see those are the teams that didn't sent ballots. That's why they are automatically disqualified.

Your team is the 5th seed. That is all there is to it.

[BDawk4Prez]

I don't mind you asking questions, but you should check your math before you do. I searched every single one of those that you said came out less than 11 times, and they all came out 11 times. Yes, 6 teams have more votes than everyone else. If you'd take care to look, you'd see those are the teams that didn't sent ballots. That's why they are automatically disqualified.

Your team is the 5th seed. That is all there is to it.

#Lawyered

[warfelg]

#Lawyered

It wasn't about my seeding. I'll admit I miscounted. It was more I had come curiosity as to when a team with mostly 10-15 votes gets a 2/3 vote, who fell on that ballot. Curiosity got the better of me with that.

[homestarunner93]

It wasn't about my seeding. I'll admit I miscounted. It was more I had come curiosity as to when a team with mostly 10-15 votes gets a 2/3 vote, who fell on that ballot. Curiosity got the better of me with that.

Sometimes people just have an outlier opinion on a team. Honestly I thought the Colts were way better than the range most people put them in, for example.

[warfelg]

Sometimes people just have an outlier opinion on a team. Honestly I thought the Colts were way better than the range most people put them in, for example.

That's all I was curious about, cuz I honestly was surprised you put the place rankings. So curiosity got the better of me and I was wondering, like the AA's (who have 2 starting QBs listed) got a 2, who on that ballot got bumped down. Not such a big deal I want you going out of your way, but it just caught my interest.

[Plague]

The AA had 2 QB's listed as starting and 12 players listed as starters. I figured they just made a error.

I personally penalized teams for playing players out of position. I however did not penalize the AA for the error of 2 QB's.

[Ebbs]

So all in the main forum what day to they start?

[warfelg]

So all in the main forum what day to they start?

He projected putting them up last night so :shrug:

Looking forward to having to convince random trolls that will vote against you just because.

[TDjacksonville]

The AA had 2 QB's listed as starting and 12 players listed as starters. I figured they just made a error.

I personally penalized teams for playing players out of position. I however did not penalize the AA for the error of 2 QB's.
I believe that was an oversight by me on the qb but it's obvious peyton is the starter.

You really docked for a tackle playing guard?

[homestarunner93]

He projected putting them up last night so :shrug:

Looking forward to having to convince random trolls that will vote against you just because.

They're going up right now. Sorry, but I think the alternative is going to have match-ups that end 2-3 in this forum. That's pointless.

[warfelg]

They're going up right now. Sorry, but I think the alternative is going to have match-ups that end 2-3 in this forum. That's pointless.

I didn't disagree with that part. I just know there are some of us that participated in this that will get voted against by some posters in main just because of who we are.

[Plague]

I believe that was an oversight by me on the qb but it's obvious peyton is the starter.

You really docked for a tackle playing guard?

In your case I docked you 1 spot for playing Dierdorf at Guard.

I stayed within the guidelines of positions I expect everyone else to do the same. I could of drafted a DE or CB to play OLB and ignore positional guidelines, but I think in the spirit of the game we should pick players to play positions that actually played the positions in the NFL.

[TDjacksonville]

In your case I docked you 1 spot for playing Dierdorf at Guard.

I stayed within the guidelines of positions I expect everyone else to do the same. I could of drafted a DE or CB to play OLB and ignore positional guidelines, but I think in the spirit of the game we should pick players to play positions that actually played the positions in the NFL.
Olinemen are olinemen. Offensive tackles have shown they can be good guards later in their careers but don't make good centers. Guards don't make good centers or tackles. Centers can usually transition between center and guard but don't traditionally make good tackles.

Also fwiw pro-football reference list Dan as t-g-c so he's shown to able to play any of the 3;)

[Plague]

Olinemen are olinemen. Offensive tackles have shown they can be good guards later in their careers but don't make good centers. Guards don't make good centers or tackles. Centers can usually transition between center and guard but don't traditionally make good tackles.

Also fwiw pro-football reference list Dan as t-g-c so he's shown to able to play any of the 3;)

Regardless what Pro Football reference lists for Dan Dierdorf I doubt Dan Dierdorf ever started a NFL game at Guard.

I am sure many players could of played other positions, but I am grading players by the positions they played not what they could of played.. Dan Dierdorf played tackle during the bulk of his career not guard.

[TDjacksonville]

Regardless what Pro Football reference lists for Dan Dierdorf I doubt Dan Dierdorf ever started a NFL game at Guard.

I am sure many players could of played other positions, but I am grading players by the positions they played not what they could of played.. Dan Dierdorf played tackle during the bulk of his career not guard.
Is the profootball hall of fame valid enough?

There write-up on him says he started his career as a guard and tackle before sticking at rt. He later played center because of a personnel emergency and played well there despite never playing the position before.

[Plague]

Is the profootball hall of fame valid enough?

There write-up on him says he started his career as a guard and tackle before sticking at rt. He later played center because of a personnel emergency and played well there despite never playing the position before.

I am giving you credit how he played at Guard in his career. You want me to judge Dierdorf how he played at Tackle then play him at Tackle. You however are playing him at Guard and that is how I am judging him, I am judging Dierdorf on how he played at Guard in his NFL career.

P.S. In comparison to other owners I ranked your team fairly well. I had a tough decision between you and another owners team and for me it came down to you playing Dierdorf out of position as the tie breaker. I was a lot harsher on another owner who was playing many players out of position.

[Plague]

In the voting section I saw someone vote gm. What does that mean

[Wrench]

In the voting section I saw someone vote gm. What does that mean

They are the GMs of one of the teams, in your match up you should be clicking that.

[Plague]

They are the GMs of one of the teams, in your match up you should be clicking that.

Thanks.

I voted for myself to win. If anyone can remove that vote and move it to GM that would be great as long as the Wolverines also did not vote for themselves. I never noticed anything that said we couldn't vote for ourselves. So far only 1 of the 8 owners playing voted GM so I am wondering if other owners may of done the same thing.

[The Long Shot]

Thanks.

I voted for myself to win. If anyone can remove that vote and move it to GM that would be great as long as the Wolverines also did not vote for themselves. I never noticed anything that said we couldn't vote for ourselves. So far only 1 of the 8 owners playing voted GM so I am wondering if other owners may of done the same thing.

No other owner voted for their own team that I know of. It's not explicitly stated in the rules that you can't vote for your own team, but it should be implied.

[Plague]

No other owner voted for their own team that I know of. It's not explicitly stated in the rules that you can't vote for your own team, but it should be implied.

Thats fine, I don't have a problem with it. I just didn't know. I was just asking if someone with the ability could correct it for me or in the end subtract a vote for my team, I just want to make sure if Wolverine also voted for himself that is corrected too..

So far only 2 of the 8 owners playing voted GM, so either they are not paying attention to their own games or they voted for themselves.

In the Maroons/All Americans game both owners of those teams have posted in that thread but only 1 of those owners voted GM. I think its likely 1 of those 2 owners voted for themselves.

[Andrei00]

As high as #2 and as low as #16. Interesting. Thanks to whoever voted me #2, I honestly didn't expect to be voted top 3 at all.

[warfelg]

Thats fine, I don't have a problem with it. I just didn't know. I was just asking if someone with the ability could correct it for me or in the end subtract a vote for my team, I just want to make sure if Wolverine also voted for himself that is corrected too..

So far only 2 of the 8 owners playing voted GM, so either they are not paying attention to their own games or they voted for themselves.

In the Maroons/All Americans game both owners of those teams have posted in that thread but only 1 of those owners voted GM. I think its likely 1 of those 2 owners voted for themselves.

You do know the poll is public and you can see who voted for what team right?

[Plague]

You do know the poll is public and you can see who voted for what team right?

I did not know that. I juae see votes and I had t vote to see who voted. If there is another way to view the votes I am unaware.

[warfelg]

I did not know that. I juae see votes and I had t vote to see who voted. If there is another way to view the votes I am unaware.

Click on the number of votes and you can see who voted where.

[Wrench]

I did not know that. I juae see votes and I had t vote to see who voted. If there is another way to view the votes I am unaware.

You have to vote to see the votes, thats why Vote GM is listed so the GMs can see who is winning.

[Plague]

Click on the number of votes and you can see who voted where.

Hard to believe I have been on PSD for what seems like forever and I never knew that.

Out of the 4 games that are played the only game I cannot see who voted is my game.

[homestarunner93]

Hard to believe I have been on PSD for what seems like forever and I never knew that.

Out of the 4 games that are played the only game I cannot see who voted is my game.

Sorry. I forgot to click the option for your match-up for public votes. It's easy to miss.

[Plague]

Sorry. I forgot to click the option for your match-up for public votes. It's easy to miss.

No worries. Until a couple of days ago I didn't even know I could look at the votes.

[warfelg]

Well can't say I'm not disappointed when two of the voters for the winning side was a guy with 3 posts at the time of his vote and a guy with a handful of NFL main posts in his time on PSD.

[The Long Shot]

Well can't say I'm not disappointed when two of the voters for the winning side was a guy with 3 posts at the time of his vote and a guy with a handful of NFL main posts in his time on PSD.

Not that it matters...I don't expect to win against homestar and I don't anticipate you would have won, either.

[warfelg]

Not that it matters...I don't expect to win against homestar and I don't anticipate you would have won, either.

It's more disappointing that those two votes mattered that much. I'm not even 100% upset about losing.

But to vote without any posts in main, and not explaining the vote rubbed me wrong.

[The Long Shot]

It's more disappointing that those two votes mattered that much. I'm not even 100% upset about losing.

But to vote without any posts in main, and not explaining the vote rubbed me wrong.

Yeah, it's a shame that more people (more importantly, people with credibility) aren't voting. I only counted six people from the game itself that voted in any of the matchups.

[warfelg]

Yeah, it's a shame that more people (more importantly, people with credibility) aren't voting. I only counted six people from the game itself that voted in any of the matchups.

Yea. That's where I'm disappointed. To lose and not know why bothers me. Not the losing part.

[Wrench]

So we never finished this :(

[homestarunner93]

So we never finished this :(

Yeah we did. I won.

[Wrench]

Yeah we did. I won.

Whoops haha didn't even notice the Super Bowl thread, my bad. Welp another 2nd place finish. :(

[Norm]

Yeah we did. I won.

I won.

[The Long Shot]

I won.

I didn't

[killthesux]

Anyone interested in this? Ill run it

[Wrench]

Always, I think the rules need a little tweak on the decade requirements IMO.

I know the last few games with these rules guys just load up on old OL to fill the requirements. Maybe a few tweaks could make it better, maybe just limit 90's+ guys or maybe 80's+ and let guys pick the best guys.

[The Jokemaker]

I'm down for doing this again.

[homestarunner93]

I will definitely play. Don't think I would have time to run it. I will help with tweaking the rules though. We can adjust the decades thing. I still think we need some sort of limit on 90s+ players at the very least because guys just load up on them and go further in voting than they should if you don't put some sort of limit.

[SteelCurtain]

Wish you could have been in this year. We missed you and SC.

Thanks homie! I'm in this year if you guys will have me.....

[The Long Shot]

I can help with running it this year if y'all want.

[Wrench]

I will definitely play. Don't think I would have time to run it. I will help with tweaking the rules though. We can adjust the decades thing. I still think we need some sort of limit on 90s+ players at the very least because guys just load up on them and go further in voting than they should if you don't put some sort of limit.

I'd say we just put big limit on those say like 6 guys total from the 90's+ (90's-00's-10's) and let guys build from there.

[SteelCurtain]

I'd propose no 2 GM teams unless we get 24 teams minimum. Fewer teams makes it so hard to distinguish great, great, great teams from just great, great teams. Only exception, IMO, should be noobs teaming with a vet GM.

[TDjacksonville]

I'd say we just put big limit on those say like 6 guys total from the 90's+ (90's-00's-10's) and let guys build from there.
That's a little extreme.

Old rule was 7 from 90s on. I'd say 7 is fine. 7 is 24.1% of the roster since rosters are 29 players from what i gathered on the clubhouses.

[StriveGreatness]

I'm in. Love the all-time

[homestarunner93]

Thanks homie! I'm in this year if you guys will have me.....

Only issue I have with it is you are a major threat to me defending my title. :D

[Norm]

I'd propose no 2 GM teams unless we get 24 teams minimum. Fewer teams makes it so hard to distinguish great, great, great teams from just great, great teams. Only exception, IMO, should be noobs teaming with a vet GM.
Booooo. I hate doing these alone. I don't think we're getting anywhere near 24 these days SC. This place is dead

[Norm]

Get sign ups going doe

[SteelCurtain]

Booooo. I hate doing these alone. I don't think we're getting anywhere near 24 these days SC. This place is dead
Couldn't we post info on it a lil earlier and try to entice some more ppl? I know the whole reason i became a member on this site was to join the first All Time RD.....

[SteelCurtain]

Only issue I have with it is you are a major threat to me defending my title. :D
That was a helluva team bub...

[Norm]

Couldn't we post info on it a lil earlier and try to entice some more ppl? I know the whole reason i became a member on this site was to join the first All Time RD.....
I'm up for trying anything. I just don't have much faith is all

[The Jokemaker]

Probably with the high player count too is you may get guys who aren't active and kills the activity in the whole thing.

[The Jokemaker]

And we better get more votes in our matchups. In my last game last year, the entire matchup had TWO votes total. That's ludicrous.

Our teams deserved better.

[killthesux]

Ill propose this, switch the decades a little instead of it being 90-00 make it 95-04 for example

1915-1944 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1945-1954 Minimum of 3 Players (No Max)
1955-1964 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1965-1974 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1975-1984 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 5)
1985-1994 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
1995-2004 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
2005-2014 Minimum of 2 Players (Max of 2)

I would also like to add in drafting a HC to see how it would affect the voting and when teams would prioritize drafting a coach, obviously the coach wont count towards a decade.

Thoughts?

[TDjacksonville]

Ill propose this, switch the decades a little instead of it being 90-00 make it 95-04 for example

1915-1944 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1945-1954 Minimum of 3 Players (No Max)
1955-1964 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1965-1974 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1975-1984 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 5)
1985-1994 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
1995-2004 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
2005-2014 Minimum of 2 Players (Max of 2)

I would also like to add in drafting a HC to see how it would affect the voting and when teams would prioritize drafting a coach, obviously the coach wont count towards a decade.

Thoughts?take the max 5 off and it looks better. No need to limit them.

[The Long Shot]

Requiring people to draft irrelevant players from the 20's and 30's is hogwash. Put some reasonable limitations on the 90's and 00's guys and let people have at it from there.

[The Long Shot]

The idea of drafting a head coach is interesting, though my question is: would it force people to conform to that coach's particular scheme as well? Like, if I draft Don Coryell late, do I have to conform my offense to an Air Coryell?

[The Jokemaker]

Idk how I feel about coaches. On the one hand it would be cool as coaches are part of the game. On the other it could just make things more complicated and bring more of the scheme fit arguments into play.

[Ebbs]

I'd like to add coaches, adds another element.

That said not sure this will have enough people to be worth while anyway.

[Wrench]

Ill propose this, switch the decades a little instead of it being 90-00 make it 95-04 for example

1915-1944 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1945-1954 Minimum of 3 Players (No Max)
1955-1964 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1965-1974 Minimum of 3 Players (No max)
1975-1984 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 5)
1985-1994 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
1995-2004 Minimum of 3 Players (Max of 4)
2005-2014 Minimum of 2 Players (Max of 2)

I would also like to add in drafting a HC to see how it would affect the voting and when teams would prioritize drafting a coach, obviously the coach wont count towards a decade.

Thoughts?

No x1000

If we keep the decades then keep them.

I still think it's better if we just limit 90's+, even if we break those up to 90's-00's-10's and do 4-2-2 max or in that range.

[SteelCurtain]

Not in favor of coaches either

[TDjacksonville]

No x1000

If we keep the decades then keep them.

I still think it's better if we just limit 90's+, even if we break those up to 90's-00's-10's and do 4-2-2 max or in that range.
What about just a max amount for the whole grouping?

[Wrench]

In truth I'd say do a max of 6-7 players for the 90-00's decades and ban all 2010's players.

[killthesux]

Having only 10 people who have signed up is a little depressing

[Wrench]

It has only been up for 2 days.

[TDjacksonville]

It has only been up for 2 days.im not signing up till all the details are done like when, Whats the decade rules going to be etc....

[homestarunner93]

In truth I'd say do a max of 6-7 players for the 90-00's decades and ban all 2010's players.

I'd be okay with this. I'm not sure that changing the decade range necessarily makes sense. May as well just leave it the way it is if you are going to do that.

[The Jokemaker]

On the page I'm not even listed as having signed up... when I did.

anybody know folks from other forums or from reddit who may be interested? May need to recruit elsewhere.

[SteelCurtain]

I msgd several of the old school GMs, but dontwknow that we'll get any of them. MT, WW, WB36, dbronc, jayeff, AP....

[Wrench]

I'd be okay with this. I'm not sure that changing the decade range necessarily makes sense. May as well just leave it the way it is if you are going to do that.

I was suggesting those be the only limits, letting guys have as many players from other decades as they want.

Lets say 7 guys max from 90-00's and no guys from the 2010 decade. Or split them 90's (4) 00's (3) 10's (2)?

[The Jokemaker]

I was suggesting those be the only limits, letting guys have as many players from other decades as they want.

Lets say 7 guys max from 90-00's and no guys from the 2010 decade. Or split them 90's (4) 00's (3) 10's (2)?

I'd be cool with that. Limit the 90s-00s-10s (if we do the 10s) but the rest is however many you want.

If we did away with the 2010 decade, we could still draft players that retired in that time but played more in the 00s right?

I think a max of 7 is generous and fine. Gives the potential to have about a fourth of your roster with those guys.

[The Long Shot]

I see no reason to eliminate the 2010's. Just keep a 7-8 person max for 90's/00's/10's.

[homestarunner93]

I was suggesting those be the only limits, letting guys have as many players from other decades as they want.

Lets say 7 guys max from 90-00's and no guys from the 2010 decade. Or split them 90's (4) 00's (3) 10's (2)?

Yeah, I know. I was saying either go with your scheme, or leave it the way it was last year.

[The Jokemaker]

Well if TDJ signs up we have 16 peeps. I think we ran this once with 18?

[TDjacksonville]

Well if TDJ signs up we have 16 peeps. I think we ran this once with 18?
I'm running a b-a-t on another forum for basketball currently

[SteelCurtain]

I've also got Simpson, another throwback GM, potentially ready to join. I talked to him about it today!

[The Jokemaker]

I've also got Simpson, another throwback GM, potentially ready to join. I talked to him about it today!

Good job!

:clap:

[Norm]

And we better get more votes in our matchups. In my last game last year, the entire matchup had TWO votes total. That's ludicrous.

Our teams deserved better.
I wish I had a solution for this. It's tough.

[Norm]

Requiring people to draft irrelevant players from the 20's and 30's is hogwash. Put some reasonable limitations on the 90's and 00's guys and let people have at it from there.

You're disqualified for this post. Lol

[Norm]

The idea of drafting a head coach is interesting, though my question is: would it force people to conform to that coach's particular scheme as well? Like, if I draft Don Coryell late, do I have to conform my offense to an Air Coryell?

We did this for the all time college redraft. It was pretty neat and people followed mostly the style and it didn't have any overwhelming effect either.

[Norm]

On the page I'm not even listed as having signed up... when I did.

anybody know folks from other forums or from reddit who may be interested? May need to recruit elsewhere.

I'd recruit elsewhere but it would be tricky to ask without pmimg everyone.

[Norm]

I see no reason to eliminate the 2010's. Just keep a 7-8 person max for 90's/00's/10's.

I would legit love it this way. Modern guys very way too much pull.

[The Long Shot]

You're disqualified for this post. Lol

Lol, in fairness, I'm not saying all of those guys are irrelevant. But that talent pool is ridiculously small, way too much so to require everybody to pull 2-3 players from it; that is, if we want to ensure that this is a "greatest players of all-time" draft.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Norm]

Lol, in fairness, I'm not saying all of those guys are irrelevant. But that talent pool is ridiculously small, way too much so to require everybody to pull 2-3 players from it; that is, if we want to ensure that this is a "greatest players of all-time" draft.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
49 and before should be one group.

[SteelCurtain]

Agree Norm

[Wrench]

If we need more teams I'll draft for two if need be haha

[SteelCurtain]

We're up to 16!

[Norm]

We're up to 16!

What's our goal? Have we decided? Anyone check what we had last year? 20 seems more than fine to me honestly. I'd rather get started soon, then again, August is my busiest month but that hardly matters.

[Norm]

If we need more teams I'll draft for two if need be haha

Wrench has some secret cheating plan already planned guys.

[Wrench]

Na, I would try hard on both and wouldn't trade with anyone to make it fair. Go 4-3 on one 3-4 on the other haha

[Norm]

Na, I would try hard on both and wouldn't trade with anyone to make it fair. Go 4-3 on one 3-4 on the other haha

I don't think just an extra team is necessary. Probably would bother some people for whatever damn reasons

[killthesux]

Id like to get to 20 as well before we start

[Wrench]

I don't think just an extra team is necessary. Probably would bother some people for whatever damn reasons

Oh I'm sure :/


UTB would play but gone till the 12th on vacation, although at this rate we can start when he returns.

[Norm]

Oh I'm sure :/


UTB would play but gone till the 12th on vacation, although at this rate we can start when he returns.

haha no joke.

I get the impression we're playing with what we have.

The next thing to try is to spam a link to all the team forums with a short message inviting people. Lots of people don't check the main or even notice that announcement I bet.

I've done that before and it's gotten people for games.

[The Jokemaker]

haha no joke.

I get the impression we're playing with what we have.

The next thing to try is to spam a link to all the team forums with a short message inviting people. Lots of people don't check the main or even notice that announcement I bet.

I've done that before and it's gotten people for games.

This is a good idea. I think some are just too scared off by it too which is crazy.

We've got a solid start with 16 people so far and could have a good league with that. I think 20 is a reasonable goal if we could squeeze some more people in this.

[richiesaurus310]

Why not just make the rosters a little bigger if we do only end up playing with 16? Kinda like fantasy football

[The Jokemaker]

I think we should consider starting this soon. Signups have been up for over a week and we could have our draft lotto reveal with a start time in like a day or so after that. If someone else signs up before official start of the draft, they can be added to the back end.

[killthesux]

Your team name must be named after current or a historical NFL/AFL franchise

1. Killthesux- Tennessee Titans
2. Norm/Super- Los Angeles Dons
3. Steel Curtain/dbroncos- Pittsburgh Steelers
4. StriveGreatness- Baltimore Colts
5. Homestarunner
6. Bdawk4Prez- Philadelphia Eagles
7. The Long Shot- Minnesota Vikings
8. CardinalRed24- LA Rams
9. Andrei- Washington Senators
10. Richiesaruas- San Francisco 49ers
11. The Jokemaker- Duluth Eskimos
12. Wrench- Canton Bulldogs
13. Ebbs- Detroit Wolverines
14. QB Eagles- Kenosha Maroons
15. Cubbybear- Decatur Staleys
16. Simpson- St. Louis Rams
17. TDjacksonville- St. Louis All Stars
18. Nckrey- Houston Oilers?

[StriveGreatness]

Baltimore Colts

[SteelCurtain]

Pittsburgh Steelers

[Norm]

Yeah we're not getting multiple additions. Might as well start.

[Norm]

Why not just make the rosters a little bigger if we do only end up playing with 16? Kinda like fantasy football
Adding additional players doesn't help the issue at hand though. The issue is with two few teams all the teams get too top heavy essentially. Well heavy all the way through. They're all better so it's harder to vote. More teams helps thin the herd some. More players on each team doesn't help that imo

[Norm]

Hey butthole. Can I use old aafc team names? The answer is yes. Thank you


Los Angeles Dons

[The Long Shot]

Minnesota Vikings


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[The Jokemaker]

Duluth Eskimos


Edit: I reserve the right to change my name and take another name that has yet to be spoken for.

[The Jokemaker]

Man it's a shame we can't use franchises that tried to become franchises.

[Wrench]

Canton Bulldogs

[Wrench]

So have we figured out the decades yet? I want to start working on a list of guys and need to know that before I start.

[Wrench]

Round 1- 6 Hours

1. Canton Bulldogs- Jerry Rice, WR
2. STL All Stars (via Duluth Eskimos)- Lawrence Taylor, LB
3. Minnesota Vikings- Sammy Baugh, QB
4. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Duluth Eskimos via St Louis All Stars)- Jim Brown, RB
5. Tennessee Titans - Joe Montana, QB
6. Los Angeles Dons- Reggie White, DE
7. Duluth Eskimoes (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Dan Marino, QB
8. Kenosha Maroons- Randy Moss, WR
9. SKIP
10. St Louis Rams- Walter Payron, RB
11. San Francisco 49ers- Bruce Smith, DE
12. Chicago Cardinals- Deion Sanders, CB
13. Detroit Wolverines- Barry Sanders, RB
14. Houston Oilers- Night Train Lane, CB
15. Philadelphia Eagles- Mean Joe Greene, DT
16. Decatur Staleys - Marshall Faulk, RB
17. Washington Senators- Deacon Jones, DE
18. Baltimore Colts- Tom Brady, QB

Round 2 - 6 Hours

19. Baltimore Colts - Don Hutson, WR
20. Washington Senators- Dick Butkus, LB
21. Decatur Staleys- Jim Kelly, QB
22. Philadelphia Eagles- Anthony Munoz, OT
23. Houston Oilers- Ronnie Lott, S
24. Detroit Wolverines- Johnny Unitas, QB
25. Chicago Cardinals- Rod Woodson, CB
26. San Francisco 49ers- Terrell Owens, WR
27. St Louis Rams- Ray Lewis, LB
28. SKIP
29. Kenosha Maroons- Alan Page, DT
30. Duluth Eskimoes via Pittsburgh Steelers- Mel Blount, CB
31. Los Angeles Dons- Brett Favre, QB
32. Tennessee Titans- Jack Lambert, LB
33. St Louis All Stars- Derrick Thomas, LB
34. Minnesota Vikings- Merlin Olson, DT
35. Pittsburgh Steelers via Duluth Eskimos- Peyton Manning, QB
36. Canton Bulldogs- John Randle, DT

Round 3 - 6 Hours

37. Canton Bulldogs- Darrell Green, CB
38. Houston Oilers via Duluth Eskimoes- Bob Lilly, DT
39. Minnesota Vikings- Cris Carter, WR
40. St Louis All Stars- Ed Reed, S
41. Tennessee Titans- Tony Gonzalez, TE
42. Kenosha Maroons (via Los Angeles Dons)- Jack Ham, LB
43. Pittsburgh Steelers- Gino Marchetti, DE
44. Los Angeles Dons (via Kenosha Maroons)- Gale Sayers, RB
45. SKIP
46. St Louis Rams- Champ Bailey, CB
47. San Francisco 49ers- John Elway, QB
48. Chicago Cardinals- JJ Watt, DE
49. Detroit Wolverines- John Hannah, OG
50. Duluth Eskimoes (via Houston Oilers)- Lance Alworth, WR
51. Philadelphia Eagles- Earl Campbell, RB
52. Decatur Staleys- Howie Long, DE
53. Washington Senators- Mike Haynes, CB
54. Baltimore Colts- Mike Singletary, LB

Round 4 - 6 Hours

55. Baltimore Colts- Eric Dickerson, RB
56. Washington Senators- Randy White, DT
57. Decatur Staleys- Junior Seau, LB
58. Philadelphia Eagles- Chuck Bednarik, LB
59. Houston Oilers- Steve Young, QB
60. Detroit Wolverines- Michael Irvin, WR
61. Chicago Cardinals-Troy Polamalu, S
62. San Francisco 49ers- Calvin Johnson, WR
63. St Louis Rams- Roger Staubach, QB
64. SKIP
65. Los Angeles Dons (via Kenosha Maroons)- Ray Nitschke, LB
66. Pittsburgh Steelers- Willie Lanier, LB
67. Kenosha Maroons (via Los Angeles Dons)- Darrelle Revis, CB
68. Tennessee Titans- Steve Largent, WR
69. St Louis All Stars- Tim Brown, WR
70. Minnesota Vikings- Carl Eller, DE
71. Duluth Eskimoes- Kellen Winslow Sr, TE
72. Canton Bulldogs- Jack Youngblood, DE

Round 5 - 5 Hours

73. Canton Bulldogs- Paul Krause, FS
74. Duluth Eskimoes- Bobby Bell, LB
75. Minnesota Vikings- Derrick Brooks, LB
76. St Louis All Stars- Willie Brown, CB
77. Tennessee Titans- LaDainian Tomlinson, RB
78. Los Angeles Dons- Charles Woodson, S
79. Pittsburgh Steelers- Marvin Harrison, WR
80. Kenosha Maroons- Richard Dent, DE
81. SKIP
82. St Louis Rams- Bruce Matthews, OG
83. San Francisco 49ers- Lee Roy Selmon, DE
84. Chicago Cardinals- Isaac Bruce, WR
85. Detroit Wolverines- Larry Allen, OG
86. Houston Oilers- OJ Simpson, RB
87. Philadelphia Eagles- Rob Gronkowski, TE
88. Decatur Staleys- Curley Culp, NT
89. Washington Senators- Paul Warfield, WR
90. Baltimore Colts- John Mackey, TE

Round 6 - 5 Hours

91. Baltimore Colts- Ken Houston, FS
92. Washington Senators- Lem Barney, CB
93. Decatur Staleys - Art Monk, WR
94. Philadelphia Eagles - Michael Strahan, DE
95. Duluth Eskimoes (via Houston Oilers)- Emmitt Smith, RB
96. Detroit Wolverines- Jim Parker, OG
97. Chicago Cardinals- Kurt Warner, QB
98. San Francisco 49ers- Herb Adderley, CB
99. St Louis Rams- Warren Sapp, DT
100. SKIP
101. Kenosha Maroons- Marion Motley, FB
102. Pittsburgh Steelers- Mike Ditka, TE
103. Los Angeles Dons- Buck Buchanon, DT
104. Tennessee Titans- Forrest Gregg, OT
105. St Louis All Stars- Lester Hayes, CB
106. Minnesota Vikings- Dick LeBeau, CB
107. Houston Oilers (via Duluth Eskimoes)- Brian Urlacher, LB
108. Canton Bulldogs- Ted Hendricks, LB

Round 7 - 5 Hours

109. Canton Bulldogs- Ozzie Newsome, TE
110. Duluth Eskimoes- Leo Nomenelli, DT/OT
111. Minnesota Vikings- Adrian Peterson, RB
112. St Louis All Stars- Dan Hampton, DE
113. Tennessee Titans- Ty Law, CB
114. Los Angeles Dons- Willie Davis, DE
115. Pittsburgh Steelers- Bronko Nagurski, FB/LB
116. Kenosha Maroons- Mel Renfro, CB
117. SKIP
118. St Louis Rams- Kevin Greene, LB
119. San Francisco 49ers- Emlen Tunnel, DB
120. Chicago Cardinals- Jerome Brown, DT
121. Detroit Wolverines- Larry Wilson, FS
122. Houston Oilers- Raymond Berry, WR
123. Philadelphia Eagles- Cortez Kennedy, DT
124. Decatur Staleys- Charles Haley, LB
125. Washington Senators- Doug Atkins, DE
126. Baltimore Colts- Antonio Gates, TE

Round 8 - 5 Hours

127. Baltimore Colts- Gene Upshaw, OG
128. Washington Senators- James Lofton, WR
129. Decatur Staleys- Rickey Jackson, LB
130. Philadelphia Eagles- Mike Webster, C
131. Duluth Eskimoes (via Houston Oilers)- Jason Taylor, DE
132. Detroit Wolverines- Chris Doleman, DE
133. Chicago Cardinals- Harry Carson, LB
134. San Francisco 49ers- Shannon Sharpe, TE
135. St Louis Rams- Roger Wehrli, CB
136. SKIP
137. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Kenosha Maroons)- Jimmy Johnson, CB
138. Pittsburgh Steelers- Jonathan Ogden, OT
139. Los Angeles Dons- Elroy Hirsch, WR
140. Tennessee Titans- Julius Peppers, DE
141. St Louis All Stars- Lyle Alzado, DE
142. Minnesota Vikings- Dave Casper, TE
143. Duluth Eskimoes- Aeneas Williams, CB
144. Canton Bulldogs- Jack Butler, CB

Round 9 - 5 Hours

145. Canton Bulldogs- Joe Schmidt, LB
146. Duluth Eskimoes- Brian Dawkins, FS
147. Minnesota Vikings- Bill George, LB
148. St Louis All Stars- Patrick Willis, LB
149. Tennessee Titans- Lesile O'Neal, DE
150. Los Angeles Dons- Kenny Easley, S
151. San Francisco 49ers (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Emmitt Thomas, CB
152. Kenosha Maroons- Sam Huff, LB
153. SKIP
154. St Louis Rams- Larry Fitzgerald, WR
155. San Francisco 49ers- DeMarcus Ware, LB
156. Chicago Cardinals- Don Maynard, WR
157. Detroit Wolverines- Jim Otto, C
158. Houston Oilers- Steve Atwater, FS
159. Philadelphia Eagles- Deron Cherry, S
160. Decatur Staleys- Lynn Swann, WR
161. Washington Senators- Tony Dorsett, RB
162. Baltimore Colts- Walter Jones, LT

Round 10 - 4 Hours

163. Baltimore Colts- Sterling Sharpe, WR
164. Washington Senators- Willie Wood, S
165. Decatur Staleys- Yale Lary, S
166. Philadelphia Eagles- Ernie Stautner, DT
167. Houston Oilers- Fred Dean, DE
168. Detroit Wolverines- Zach Thomas, LB
169. Chicago Cardinals- Marcus Allen, RB
170. Pittsburgh Steelers (via San Francisco 49ers)- Art Shell, LT
171. St Louis Rams- Randall McDaniel, OG
172. SKIP
173. Kenosha Maroons- Mel Hein, C
174. Kenosha Maroons (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Jason Witten, TE
175. Los Angeles Dons- Fred Biletnikoff, WR
176. Tennessee Titans- John Lynch, S
177. St Louis All Stars- Jack Christiansen, S
178. Minnesota Vikings- John Stallworth, WR
179. Houston Oilers (via Duluth Eskimoes)- Andre Reed, WR
180. Canton Bulldogs- Torry Holt, WR

[Wrench]

Round 11 - 4 Hours

181. Canton Bulldogs- Andre Johnson, WR
182. Duluth Eskimoes- Clyde “Bulldog” Turner, C/LB
183. Minnesota Vikings- Bill Belichick, Coach
184. St Louis All Stars- Jackie Smith, TE
185. Tennessee Titans- Charlie JOINER, WR
186. Los Angeles Dons- Bob "Bullet" Hayes, WR
187. Pittsburgh Steelers- Dave Wilcox, LB
188. Kenosha Maroons- Joe Gibbs, HC
189. SKIP
190. Tennessee Titans (via St Louis Rams)- Dwight Stephenson, OC
191. San Francisco 49ers- Andre Tippett, LB
192. Chicago Cardinals- Len Ford, DE
193. Detroit Wolverines- La'Roi Glover, DT
194. Houston Oilers- Charlie Sanders, TE
195. Philadelphia Eagles- Rosey Brown, OT
196. Decatur Staleys- Rayfield Wright, OT
197. Washington Senators- Chris Hanburger, LB
198. Baltimore Colts- Robert Brazile, LB

Round 12 - 4 Hours

199. Baltimore Colts- Andrew Gradishar, LB
200. Washington Senators- Art Donovan, DT
201. Decatur Staleys- Willie Roaf, OT
202. Philadelphia Eagles- Chuck Howley, LB
203. Houston Oilers- Orlando Pace, T
204. Detroit Wolverines- Ron Yary, OT
205. Chicago Cardinals- Dave Robinson, LB
206. San Francisco 49ers- Dan Dierdorf, OT
207. Kenosha Maroons (via St Louis Rams)- Pete Pihos, E
208. SKIP
209. Los Angeles Dons (via Kenosha Maroons)- Jim Taylor, RB
210. Kenosha Maroons (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Jackie Slater, RT
211. Kenosha Maroons (via Los Angeles Dons)- Henry Jordan, DT
212. Tennessee Titans- Bill Walsh, HC
213. St Louis All Stars- Frank Gifford, OW
214. Minnesota Vikings- Joe Thomas, OT
215. Duluth Eskimoes- Charley Taylor, OW
216. Canton Bulldogs- Ron Mix, OT

Round 13 - 4 Hours

217. Canton Bulldogs- Mike Munchak, OG
218. Duluth Eskimoes- Nick Buoniconti, LB
219. Minnesota Vikings- Jared Allen, DE
220. St Louis All Stars- Jim Thorpe, S
221. Tennessee Titans- Henry Ellard, WR
222. Los Angeles Dons- Tony Boselli, OT
223. Pittsburgh Steelers- Andy Robustelli, DE
224. Kenosha Maroons- Jim Tyrer, OT
225. SKIP
226. St Louis Rams- Jim Langer, C
227. Pittsburgh Steelers (via San Francisco 49ers)- Bill Willis, MG
228. Chicago Cardinals- Jerry Smith, TE
229. Detroit Wolverines- Lemar Parrish, CB
230. Canton Bulldogs (via Houston Oilers)- Thurman Thomas, RB
231. Philadelphia Eagles- Aaron Rogers, QB
232. Decatur Staleys- Joe DeLamielleure, OG
233. Washington Senators- Wilbur "Pete" Henry, T
234. Baltimore Colts- Bob St. Clair, OT

Round 14 - 4 Hours

235. Baltimore Colts- Will Shields, OG
236. Washington Senators- George Connor, T/LB
237. Decatur Staleys- Larry Csonka, FB
238. Philadelphia Eagles- Reggie Wayne, WR
239. Houston Oilers- Jim Ringo, C
240. Detroit Wolverines- Louis Wright, CB
241. Chicago Cardinals- Gene Hickerson, OG
242. San Francisco 49ers- Lou Creekmur, OT
243. St Louis Rams- Elvin Bethea, DE
244. SKIP
245. St Louis Rams (via Kenosha Maroons)- Todd Christensen, TE
246. Pittsburgh Steelers- Dermontti Dawson, OC
247. Los Angeles Dons- Jack Tatum, S
248. St Louis Rams (via Tennessee Titans)- Vince Lombardi, HC
249. St Louis All Stars- Tom Jackson, LB
250. Minnesota Vikings- Gary Zimmerman, OT
251. Duluth Eskimoes- Bob Brown, OT
252. Canton Bulldogs- Mike McCormack, OT

Round 15 - 3 Hours

253. Canton Bulldogs- Mick Tingelhoff, OC
254. Duluth Eskimoes- Donnie Shell, SS
255. Minnesota Vikings- Ken Riley, CB
256. St Louis All Stars- Franco Harris, RB
257. Tennessee Titans- Stan Jones, OG
258. Los Angeles Dons- Richard Sherman, CB
259. San Francisco 49ers (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Dick Stanfel, OG
260. Houston Oilers (via Pittsburgh Steelers) (via Kenosha Maroons)- Russ Grimm, OG
261. SKIP
262. St Louis Rams- Arnie Weinmeister, DT
263. San Francisco 49ers- Tom Mack, OG
264. Chicago Cardinals- Bobby Boyd, CB
265. Detroit Wolverines- Mark Gastineau, DE
266. Canton Bulldogs (via Houston Oilers)- Claude Humphrey,DE
267. Philadelphia Eagles- Larry Little, OG
268. Decatur Staleys- Dave Grayson, CB
269. Washington Senators- Jerry Kramer, G
270. Baltimore Colts- Hanford Dixon, CB

Round 16 - 3 Hours

271. Baltimore Colts- Frank Minnifield, CB
272. Washington Senators- Ronde Barber, CB
273. Decatur Staleys- Richard Seymour, DE/DT
274. Philadelphia Eagles- Bobby Mitchell, WR
275. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Houston Oilers)- Billy Shaw, OG
276. Detroit Wolverines- Karl Mecklenburg, LB
277. Chicago Cardinals- Cornelius Bennett, LB
278. San Francisco 49ers- John Riggins, RB
279. St Louis Rams- Maxie Baughan, LB
280. SKIP
281. Kenosha Maroons- Ed Meador, DB
282. Pittsburgh Steelers- Johnny Robinson, FS
283. Los Angeles Dons- Isiah Robertson, LB
284. St Louis Rams (via Tennessee Titans)- Cal Hubbard, OT
285. St Louis All Stars- Lou Groza, OT
286. Minnesota Vikings- Joe Klecko, DT
287. Duluth Eskimoes- Dan Fortmann, OG
288. Canton Bulldogs- Walt Sweeney, OG

Round 17 - 3 Hours

289. Canton Bulldogs- Fran Tarkenton, QB
290. Duluth Eskimoes- Bill Fralic, OG
291. Chicago Cardinals (via Minnesota Vikings)- Larry Grantham, LB
292. St Louis All Stars- LC Greenwood, DE
293. Tennessee Titans- Dave Brown, CB
294. Los Angeles Dons- Harold Carmichael, TE
295. Pittsburgh Steelers- Alan Faneca, OG
296. Kenosha Maroons- Steve Wisniewski, OG
297. SKIP
298. St Louis Rams- Steve Van Buren, RB
299. San Francisco 49ers- Tommy McDonald, WR
300. Chicago Cardinals-SKIPPED
301. Detroit Wolverines- Dez Bryant, WR
302. St Louis All Stars (via Houston Oilers)- Lenny Moore, OW
303. Philadelphia Eagles- Cliff Harris, FS
304. Decatur Staleys- Tom Fears, WR
305. Washington Senators- Sam Mills, LB
306. Baltimore Colts- Paul Brown, HC

Round 18 - 3 Hours

307. Baltimore Colts- Vince Wilfork, NT
308. Washington Senators- Drew Brees, QB
309. Decatur Staleys- Mike Stratton, LB
310. Philadelphia Eagles- Neil Smith, DE
311. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Houston Oilers)- Everson Walls, CB
312. Detroit Wolverines- Alex Karras, DT
313. Chicago Cardinals- SKIPPED
314. San Francisco 49ers- Nolan Cromwell, DB
315. St Louis Rams- Link Lyman, OT
316. SKIP
317. Kenosha Maroons- Joey Browner, SS
318. Houston Oilers (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Joe Jacoby, T
319. Los Angeles Dons- Kevin Mawae, OC
320. Tennessee Titans- Ernie Nevers, FB
321. Houston Oilers (via St Louis All Stars)- Steve Smith, WR
322. Minnesota Vikings- Frank Gatski, C
323. Duluth Eskimoes- Hines Ward, WR
324. Houston Oilers (via Canton Bulldogs)- Dwight Freeney, DE

Round 19 - 2 Hours

325. Canton Bulldogs- Wilber Marshall, LB
326. St Louis All Stars (via Duluth Eskimoes)- Don Shula, HC
327. Minnesota Vikings- Bill Hewitt, E
328. St Louis All Stars- Steve Hutchinson, OG
329. Tennessee Titans- Mike Curtis, LB
330. Los Angeles Dons- Albert "Turk" Edwards, OL
331. Pittsburgh Steelers- Greg Lloyd, LB
332. Kenosha Maroons- Harvey Martin, DE
333. SKIP
334. St Louis Rams- Gary Clark, WR
335. San Francisco 49ers- Les Richter, LB
336. Chicago Cardinals- SKIPPED
337. Detroit Wolverines- Red Grange, TB
338. Houston Oilers- Drew Pearson, WR
339. Philadelphia Eagles- Ox "Grover" Emerson, OG
340. Decatur Staleys- Bob Jeter, CB
341. Washington Senators- LeRoy Butler, SS
342. Baltimore Colts- George Trafton, C

Round 20 - 2 Hours

343. Baltimore Colts- Roger Craig, RB
344. Washington Senators- Erik Williams, LT
345. Decatur Staleys- Alex Wojciechowicz, OC
346. Philadelphia Eagles- Jimmy Patton, CB
347. Houston Oilers- Eric Allen, CB
348. Detroit Wolverines- SKIPPED
349. Chicago Cardinals- SKIPPED
350. San Francisco 49ers- Levon Kirkland, LB
351. St Louis Rams- Andy Russell, LB
352. SKIP
353. St Louis Rams (via Kenosha Maroons)- Mark Clayton, WR
354. Duluth Eskimoes (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Tom Landry, HC
355. Los Angeles Dons- Mark Bavaro, TE
356. Tennessee Titans- Jay Hilgenberg, OG
357. St Louis All Stars (via Duluth Eskimoes) (via St Louis All Stars)- Ralph Neely, OT
358. Kenosha Maroons (via Minnesota Vikings)- Cliff Branch, WR
359. Duluth Eskimoes- Jerome “The Bus” Bettis, RB
360. Canton Bulldogs- Chuck Noll, HC

[Wrench]

Round 21 - 2 Hours

361. Canton Bulldogs- Wes Welker, WR
362. Duluth Eskimoes- Keith Millard, DT
363. Kenosha Maroons (via Minnesota Vikings)- Earl Thomas, S
364. St Louis All Stars- Sonny Jurgensen, QB
365. St Louis Rams (via Tennessee Titans)- Goose Gonsoulin, S
366. Los Angeles Dons- Lance Briggs, LB
367. Pittsburgh Steelers- Fred Smerlas, DT
368. St Louis Rams (via Kenosha Maroons)- George Saimes, S
369. SKIP
370. St Louis Rams- Butch Byrd, CB
371. San Francisco 49ers- Michael Carter, NT
372. Chicago Cardinals - SKIPPED
373. Detroit Wolverines- SKIPPED
374. Houston Oilers- John Madden, HC
375. Philadelphia Eagles- Cornell Green, DB
376. Decatur Staleys- Ricky Watters, RB
377. Washington Senators- Ben Coates, TE
378. Baltimore Colts- Pat Swilling, LB

Round 22 - 2 Hours

379. Baltimore Colts- Art Powell, WR
380. Washington Senators- Chad Johnson, WR
381. Decatur Staleys- Marv Levy, HC
382. Philadelphia Eagles- Bob Keuchenberg, OG
383. Houston Oilers- Joe Fortunato, LB
384. Detroit Wolverines- SKIPPED
385. Chicago Cardinals- SKIPPED
386. San Francisco 49ers- Gary Green, CB
387. Tennessee Titans (via St Louis Rams)- William Perry, DT
388. SKIP
389. Kenosha Maroons- Erich Barnes, CB
390. Pittsburgh Steelers- Dick Anderson, S
391. Los Angeles Dons- Darren Woodson, S
392. Tennessee Titans- Dave Whitsell, OG
393. Duluth Eskimos (via St Louis All Stars)- Pat Fischer, CB
394. Minnesota Vikings- Kent Hill, OT
395. Duluth Eskimoes- Billy Joe Dupree, E
396. Canton Bulldogs- Steve McMichael, DT

Round 23 - 1 Hour

397. Canton Bulldogs- Dennis Smith, SS
398. Duluth Eskimoes- Dante Lavelli, E
399. Minnesota Vikings- Dick Barwegan, OG
400. St Louis All Stars- Jay Novacek, TE
401. Tennessee Titans- Bob Talamini, OG
402. Los Angeles Dons- Bobby Dillon, DB
403. Pittsburgh Steelers- Mark Duper, WR
404. Kenosha Maroons- Harold Jackson, WR
405. SKIP
406. St Louis Rams- Steve Jordan, TE
407. Pittsburgh Steelers (via San Francisco 49ers)- Jimmy Johnson, HC
408. Chicago Cardinals- SKIPPED
409. Detroit Wolverines- SKIPPED
410. Houston Oilers- Jake Scott, S
411. Philadelphia Eagles- Bo Jackson, RB
412. Decatur Staleys- Rodney Harrison, SS
413. Washington Senators- Jack Rudnay, C
414. Baltimore Colts- SKIPPED

Round 24 - 1 Hour

415. Baltimore Colts- SKIPPED
416. Washington Senators-Riley Odoms, TE
417. Decatur Staleys- Ed Budde, OG
418. Philadelphia Eagles- Warren Moon, QB
419. Houston Oilers- Walt Kiesling, OG
420. Detroit Wolverines- SKIPPED
421. Chicago Cardinals- SIPPED
422. San Francisco 49ers- Raymond Chester, TE
423. Kenosha Maroons (via St Louis Rams)- Chris Hinton, OL
424. SKIP
425. Minnesota Vikings (via Kenosha Maroons)- John Henry Johnson, FB
426. San Francisco 49ers (via Pittsburgh Steelers)- Bruce Bosley
427. Los Angeles Dons- Randy Cross, OG
428. Tennessee Titans- Gary Fencik, FS
429. St Louis All Stars- Howard Mudd, OG
430. Minnesota Vikings- Rich Caster, TE
431. Duluth Eskimoes- Tom Rathman, FB
432. Canton Bulldogs- Joe Perry, FB

Round 25 - 1 Hour

433. Canton Bulldogs- Miller Farr, CB
434. Pittsburgh Steelers (via Duluth Eskimoes)- Carl Lee, CB
435. Minnesota Vikings- John Jefferson, WR
436. St Louis All Stars- Jeff Bostic, C
437. Tennessee Titans- Mike Cofer, LB
438. Los Angeles Dons- Conrad Dobler, OG
439. Pittsburgh Steelers- Pete Rezlaff, TE
440. Kenosha Maroons- Seth Joyner, OLB
441. SKIP
442. Tennessee Titans via St Louis Rams- Jumpy Geathers, DT
443. San Francisco 49ers- Ottis Anderson, RB
444. Chicago Cardinals
445. Detroit Wolverines
446. Houston Oilers- Christian Okoye, FB
447. Philadelphia Eagles- Bill Bergey, LB
448. Decatur Staleys
449. Washington Senators- George Halas, HC
450. Baltimore Colts

Round 26 - FA

451. Baltimore Colts
452. Washington Senators- Leroy Kelly, RB
453. Decatur Staleys
454. Philadelphia Eagles- Mac Speedie, OW
455. Houston Oilers- Herwitt Dixon, TE
456. Detroit Wolverines
457. Chicago Cardinals
458. San Francisco 49ers- George Siefert, HC
459. Kenosha Maroons (via St Louis Rams)- Cookie Gilchrist, RB
460. SKIP
461. Kenosha Maroons- Randall Cunningham, QB
462. Pittsburgh Steelers
463. Los Angeles Dons- Bill Parcells, HC
464. Tennessee Titans- Russ Francis, TE
465. St Louis All Stars- Ted Washington, DT
466. Minnesota Vikings
467. STL All Stars (via Duluth Eskimoes)- Haloti Ngata, DT
468. Canton Bulldogs- Keith Byars, TE/RB

[Wrench]

Please PM the next GM inline. (VM if you wish but PM works better with people on the PSD app)

Canton Bulldogs - Wrench (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?65039-Wrench)

Duluth Eskimoes - Jokemaker (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?25134-Jokemaker)

Minnesota Vikings - The Long Shot (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?255139-The-Long-Shot)

St Louis All Stars - TDjacksonville (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?222977-
TDjacksonville)

Tennessee Titans - killthesux (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?91895-killthesux)

Los Angeles Dons - Norm (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?44691-Norm) - Super (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?28128-Super)

Pittsburgh Steelers - SteelCurtain (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?32216-SteelCurtain) - dbroncos78087 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?4792-dbroncos78087)

Kenosha Maroons - QB_Eagles (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?256721-QB_Eagles)

Disqualified

St Louis Rams - Simpson4Heisman (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?32881-Simpson4Heisman)

San Francisco 49ers - richiesaurus310 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?31385-richiesaurus310)

Chicago Cardinals - CardinalRed24 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?291876-CardinalRed24)

Detroit Wolverines - Ebbs (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?55042-Ebbs)

Houston Oilers - valade16 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?25547-valade16)

Philadelphia Eagles - BDawk4Prez (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?12097-BDawk4Prez)

Decatur Staleys - cubbybear2290 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?31236-cubbybear2290)

Washington Senators - Andrei00 (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?249507-Andrei00)

Baltimore Colts - StriveGreatness (http://forums.prosportsdaily.com/member.php?79667-StriveGreatness)

[richiesaurus310]

San Francisco 49ers

[SteelCurtain]

Excited for this thing to get rolling! Still pissed i missed last year....

[killthesux]

It will be up to you to decide if we draft them or not? You can also discuss what impact drafting a HC would have on your roster

[killthesux]

Please try to refrain yourself from naming Undrafteds in the chatzy

http://us20.chatzy.com/29350796117097

[The Jokemaker]

From the discussions, looks like most are in favor of no limits except on 90s, 00s, 10s?

Or would it be a minimum for each decade outside 90s,00s,10s (who have a maximum #).

[killthesux]

Reserved

[SteelCurtain]

Pittsburgh Steelers

Head Coach: Jimmy Johnson

Offense

* QB Peyton Manning(#8 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 5-Time NFL MVP, Sure-fire future 1st Ballot Hall of Famer, 14-time Pro Bowler, 7-time 1st Team All Pro, #1 in NFL history in Passing Yards and Passing TDs)
* RB Jim Brown(#1 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #2 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 1st Ballot Hall of Famer, 2000 All-Time NFL Team, NFL 75th Anniversary Team, SI All Century Team, 1960s All Decade Team, 9-Time Pro Bowler, 8-Time 1st Team All Pro, 8 Rushing titles in 9 seasons played, Averaged over 1600 Rush/Rec Yds and 14 TDs per season over course of career despite playing 12 and 14 game seasons, Career YPC of 5.2 Yds)
FB Bronko Nagurski(#35 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #19 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, Inaugural Class Hall of Fame, 1930s All Decade Team, 4-time All Pro, Noted as "A bulldozing runner on offense, a bone-crushing linebacker on defense" by HOF site)
Back-up TB Hugh "The King" McElhenny(1st Ballot Hall of Famer, 1952 Rookie of the Year, 1950s All Decade Team, SI All Century Team, 6-time Pro Bowler, 2-time 1st Team All Pro, per HOF site "Considered the greatest thrill runner of his day,...His breakaway speed and unique ability to change direction at will left defenders dazed and confused", Career YPC of 4.7 Yds)
* FL Mark "Super" Duper(3-time Pro Bowler, Member of the Miami Dolphins' Honor Roll, Former track star whose career 17.4 YPC is good for 40th highest All Time)
* Slot WR Marvin Harrison(3rd Ballot Hall of Famer, 2000s All Decade Team, 8-time Pro Bowler, 3-time 1st Team All Pro, 3rd All Time in Career receptions, 5th All Time in receiving TDs, 7th All Time in receiving yards)
* LT Jonathan Ogden(#72 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 1st Ballot Hall of Famer, 2000s All Decade Team, 11-time Pro Bowler, 4-time 1st Team All Pro, 2002 NFL Alumni Offensive Lineman of the Year)
* LG Billy Shaw(1st Hall of Famer to play his entire career in the AFL, AFL All Time Team, 8-time Pro Bowler, 5-time 1st Team All Pro, per HOF site Shaw was "equally adept at pass blocking and run blocking,...speed, strength, and natural ability made him the driving force of the offensive unit")
* C Dermontti Dawson(7th Ballot Hall of Famer, 1990s All Decade Team, 7-time Pro Bowler, 6-time 1st Team All Pro, 1996 NFL Alumni Offensive Lineman of the Year, Per Bill Belichick "He was one of the best players that we have ever played against at that position...Dawson had great leverage and quickness with his hands and feet)
* RG Alan Faneca(2000s All Decade Team, 2004 & 2008 NFL Alumni Offensive Lineman of the Year, HOF Finalist in his 1st year of eligibility, 9-time Pro Bowler, 6-time 1st Team All Pro, Steelers' 75th Anniversary All Time Team)
* RT Art Shell(#55 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #76 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 2nd Ballot Hall of Famer, SI All Century Team, 1970s All Decade Team, 8-time Pro Bowler, 2-time 1st Team All Pro)
* TE "Iron" Mike Ditka(#90 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #59 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 1st TE elected to the Hall of Fame, NFL 75th Anniversary Team, 1961 NFL Rookie of the Year, 5-time Pro Bowler, 2-time 1st Team All Pro)
* SE Andre Reed(9th Ballot Hall of Famer, 7-time Pro Bowler, 14th All Time in career receiving TDs, 16th All Time receptions, 16th All Time receiving yards, per HOF site "he was considered one of the greatest yards after catch receivers)
TE2 Pete Retzlaff(1965 Bert Bell Award(Player of the Year) winner, 5-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro, Despite splitting his career between HB, WR, and TE, still ranks 107th All Time in receving yards)

Defense

* LDE Gino Marchetti(#15 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #39 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 1st Ballot Hall of Famer, NFL 75th Anniversary Team, 1950s All Decade Team, 11-time Pro Bowler, 7-time 1st Team All Pro, Per Forrest Gregg "Marchetti was the best all-around player I ever played against. Great pass rusher. Great against the run.")
* UT Bill Willis(Hall of Famer, 1940s All Decade Team, 3-time Pro Bowler, 7-time 1st Team All Pro, Per Pro Football HOF site, "Bill's charge was so quick that the coaches felt he had to be offside...made a personal check and found that his recruit hadn't been offside at all, just exceptionally fast and agile")
* NT Fred Smerlas(5-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro, PFR 80s All Decade Team)
* RDE Andy Robustelli(2nd Ballot Hall of Famer, 1962 NFL Bert Bell Player of the Year, 7-time Pro Bowler, 6-time 1st Team All Pro, Per Pro Football HOF site, he was "a natural leader as well as an outstanding player....clearly on of the finest pass rushers the game has seen")
Run Stuffing sub DT Houston Antwine(AFL All Time Team, 6-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro)
* SLB Greg Lloyd(5-time Pro Bowler, 3-time 1st Team All Pro, 10th most Forced Fumbles in a career(35) since the statistic became official, PFR 90s All Decade Team)
* MLB Bronko Nagurski(#35 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #19 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, Inaugural Class Hall of Fame, 1930s All Decade Team, 4-time All Pro, Noted as "A bulldozing runner on offense, a bone-crushing linebacker on defense" by HOF site)
* WLB Willie Lanier(#42 TSN 100 Greatest Players of All Time, #53 NFL Network 100 Greatest Players of All Time, 3rd Ballot Hall of Famer, NFL 75th Anniversary Team, SI All Century Team, 8-time Pro Bowler, 3-time 1st Team All Pro)
Back-up LB Tommy Nobis(1960s All Decade Team, 1966 Defensive Rookie of the Year, 5-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro, per Larry Csonka "I'd rather play against Dick Butkus than Nobis")
* LCB Jimmy Johnson(SI All Century Team, Hall of Famer, 1970s All Decade Team, 5-time Pro Bowler, 4-time 1st Team All Pro, 47 career INTs)
* FS Johnny Robinson(AFL All Time Team, 6-time Hall of Fame Finalist, 7-time Pro Bowler, 6-time 1st Team All Pro, 57 career INTs, per Lance Alworth "He was the best defensive back I ever played against")
* SS Dick Anderson(1973 AP Defensive Player of the Year, 1970s All Decade Team, 3-time Pro Bowler, 2-time 1st Team All Pro, 34 career INTs, Member of Dolphins' Honor Roll)
* RCB Everson Walls(3-time NFL INT leader -- only other player to ever do this was Ed Reed, 57 career INTs, 4-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro)
Nickelback Carl Lee(3-time Pro Bowler, 1-time 1st Team All Pro, 31 career INTs)
Big Nickel Safety Johnny "Blood" McNally(Inaugural Class Hall of Fame, 1930s All Decade Team, per HOF site "On defense, he was a ballhawk and a deadly tackler")

* Denotes starters

Draft Picks

1st RD(#4): (Traded from Duluth) FB Jim Brown(60s)
1st RD(#7):Traded to Duluth
2nd RD(#30): Traded to Duluth
2nd RD(#35): (Traded from Duluth) QB Peyton Manning(2000s)
3rd RD(#43): DE Gino Marchetti(50s)
4th RD(#66): LB Willie Lanier(70s)
5th RD(#79): WR Marvin Harrison(2000s)
6th RD(#102): TE "Iron" Mike Ditka(60s)
7th RD(#115): FB/LB Bronko Nagurski(30s)
8th RD(#137): (Traded from Maroons) CB Jimmy Johnson(60s)
8th RD(#138): OT Jonathan Ogden(2000s)
9th RD(#151): Traded to 49ers
10th RD(#170): (Traded from 49ers) OT Art Shell(70s)
10th RD(#174): Traded to Maroons
10th RD(#179): (Traded from Oilers) WR Andre Reed(90s)
11th RD(#187): LB Dave "The Intimidator" Wilcox(60s/70s)(Traded to Oilers)
12th RD(#210): Traded to Maroons
13th RD(#223): DE Andy Robustelli(50s)
13th RD(#227): (Traded from 49ers) DT Bill Willis(40s/50s)
14th RD(#246): C Demontti Dawson(90s)
15th RD(#259): Traded to 49ers
16th RD(#275): (Traded from Oilers) OG Billy Shaw(60s)
16th RD(#282): S Johnny Robinson(60s)
17th RD(#295): OG Alan Faneca(2000s)
18th RD(#311): (Traded from Oilers) CB Everson Walls(80s)
18th RD(#318): Traded to Oilers
19th RD(#331): LB Greg Lloyd(90s)
20th RD(#354): Traded to Duluth
21st RD(#367): DT Fred Smerlas(80s)
22nd RD(#390): S Dick Anderson(70s)
23rd RD(#403): WR Mark "Super" Duper(80s)
23rd RD(#407): (Traded from 49ers) Head Coach Jimmy Johnson
24th RD(#426): Traded to 49ers
25th RD(#434): (Traded from Duluth) CB Carl Lee(80s)
25th RD(#439): TE Pete Retzlaff(60s)
26th RD(#462): LB Tommy Nobis(70s)

Free Agent Adds

1. RB Hugh "The King" McElhenny(50s)
2. S Johnny "Blood" McNally(30s)
3. DT Houston Antwine(60s)

Trades

1. Steelers get:
1st RD(#4), 2nd RD(#35), 25th RD(#434)
Steelers give:
1st RD(#7), 2nd RD(#30), 20th RD(#354)
2. Steelers send 10th RD#174, 12th RD#210
Maroons send 8th RD#137, 15th RD#260
3. 49ers send:
Round 10, pick 170, Round 13, pick 227,Round 23, pick 407
Steelers send:
Round 9, pick 151, Round 15, pick 259, Round 24, pick 426
4. Steelers send: Dave Wilcox, 15th RD(260), and 18th RD(318)
Oilers send: Andre Reed, 16th RD(275), and 18th RD(311)

Decade Requirements

20s-50s(3 minimum): Gino Marchetti, Bronko Nagurski, Andy Robustelli, Bill Willis, Hugh McElhenny, Johnny McNally
60s(3 minimum): Jim Brown, Mike Ditka, Jimmy Johnson, Billy Shaw, Johnny Robinson, Pete Retzlaff, Houston Antwine
70s(3 minimum): Willie Lanier, Art Shell, Dick Anderson, Tommy Nobis
80s(3 minimum): Everson Walls, Fred Smerlas, Mark Duper, Carl Lee
90s(3-4): Andre Reed, Dermontti Dawson, Greg Lloyd
00s-current(3-4): Peyton Manning, Marvin Harrison, Jonathan Ogden, Alan Faneca

Starters in blue

[Norm]

Can't vote but yes. Why not

[Norm]

Man it's a shame we can't use franchises that tried to become franchises.
I did this elsewhere and you could use any pro team ever.

Everyone used Japanese x league names lol

We should try the college all time after this again. Did you do that? Holy **** that was interesting

[Norm]

From the discussions, looks like most are in favor of no limits except on 90s, 00s, 10s?

Or would it be a minimum for each decade outside 90s,00s,10s (who have a maximum #).
I want a max on 90s and post and minimum on before the 50s.that's all .

It's more fun when you're forced to research.

[Norm]

Hey butthole. Can I use old aafc team names? The answer is yes. Thank you


Los Angeles Dons
I love you kts

[dbroncos78087]

Checking in! Pittsburgh Steelers going for another Superbowl ring!

[Wrench]

I would like it better if you have to run a D or O that they ran, im neutral right now.

[Wrench]

I'm fine with anything but we do need to figure it out haha, maybe just keep the decades we have and merge the 20s-30s-40s-50s.

Three players minimum
20s-50s
60s
70s
80s
Seven players maximum (Only 1 can be from 2010s decade)
90s+

How does that sound?

[Wrench]

Canton Bulldogs

HC: Chuck Noll - HoF, 72' COFY, 70's-80s All-Decade Team, Won 4 Super Bowls and had a career record of 209–156–1, 16–8 in the post season

QB: Fran Tarkenton - HoF, 75' MVP, 9x Pro Bowler, 47,003 yards - 342 TDs where records at retirement, 34 GWD's are 9th most all time, #59 on The SN's list of the 100 Greatest Football Players
RB: Thurman Thomas - HoF, 91' MVP, 5x Pro Bowler, 5x All-Pro, 90s All-Decade Team, 12,074 rushing yards - 65 TDs, 4,458 receiving yards - 23 TDs
FB: Joe Perry - HoF, 54' MVP, 3x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro, 50's All-Decade Team, led the league in rushing and rush TDs three seasons, career of 9,723 yards, 71 TDs and 5.0 YPC
WR: Jerry Rice - HoF, 87' MVP, 13x Pro Bowler, 12x All-Pro, 75th Anniversary-80's-90's All-Decade Teams, NFL record 1,549 Rec, 22,895 yards and 197 TDs, #1 on NFLN and #2 on SN's list of the 100 Greatest Players
WR: Torry Holt - 7x Pro Bowler, 00s All-Decade Team, NFL Record 6 straight seasons of 90+ rec 1,300+ receiving yards, career totals of 920 rec, 13,382 receiving yards, 74 receiving TDs
WR: Wes Welker - 5x Pro Bowler, 4x All-Pro, NFL record 110+ rec in 5 seasons, career totals of 903 rec, 9,924 yards and 50 TDs
TE: Ozzie Newsome - HoF, 3x Pro Bowler, 5x All-Pro, 80s All-Decade Team, 662 rec, 7,980 receiving yards and 47 TDs, never missed a game in 13 seasons
TE: John David Crow - 4x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro, AFL All-Decade Team, 4,963 rushing yards - 38 TDs, 3,699 receiving yards - 35 TDs
LT: Orlando Pace - HoF, 7x Pro Bowler, 4x All-Pro, 00s All-Decade Team blocked for three stright NFL MVP's
LG: Mike Munchak - HoF, 9x Pro Bowler, 10x All-Pro, 80s All-Decade Team, equally effective as a run blocker and a pass blocker
OC: Mick Tingelhoff - HoF, 6x Pro Bowler, 5× First-Team All-Pro, opened holes for four different Pro Bowl Vikings RBs
RG: Walt Sweeney - 9x Pro Bowler, 2x First Team All-Pro, AFL All-Time Team, Merlin Olsen famously remarked he'd "rather sell used cars" than play against Sweeney
RT: Mike McCormack - HoF, 6x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro, Paul Brown: “I consider (Mike) McCormack the finest offensive tackle who ever played pro football." "Power combined with great intelligence and 4.8 speed"

DE: Jack Youngblood - HoF, 7x Pro Bowler, 8x All-Pro, 2x NFC DPOY, 70s All-Decade Team, 151.5 sacks which is 5th all time
DT: John Randle - HoF, 7x Pro Bowler, 6x All-Pro, 90s All-Decade Team, 137.5 sacks (11th all time, 2nd most by a DT) and 556 tackles
DT: Steve McMichael - 2x Pro Bowler, 2x 1st-team All-Pro, 95 sacks which is 5th most by a DT and 838 tackles
DE: Claude Humphrey - HoF, 6x Pro Bowler, 4x All-Pro, 68' DROY, 132.5 sacks which is 17th all time
LB: Ted Hendricks - HoF, 8x Pro Bowler, 9x All-Pro, 75th Anniversary-70's-80's All-Decade Teams, 60.5 sacks with 26 INTs, #64 on The SN's and #82 on NFLN list of the 100 Greatest Football Players
LB: Joe Schmidt - HoF, 10x Pro Bowler, 9x All-Pro, 50s All-Decade Team, 24 INTs, #65 on The SN's list of the 100 Greatest Football Players
LB: Wilber Marshall - 3x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro, 92' NFC DPOY, 1,043 tackles, 45 sacks and 23 INTs
CB: Darrell Green - HoF, 7x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro, 90s All-Decade Team, 1,159 tackles with 54 INTs (NFL record 19 stright seasons with 1 INT)
CB: Jack Butler - HoF, 4x Pro Bowler, 4x All-Pro, 50s All-Decade Team, 52 Interceptions in just 9 seasons, league leading 10 INTs in 57'
CB: Miller Farr - 3x Pro Bowler, 3x All-Pro. AFL All-Decade Team, 35 career INTs, league leading 10 INTs in 67' NFL record two pick 6's in one game.
SS: Dennis Smith - 6x Pro Bowler, 1x All-Pro, 30 INTs, 1,152 tackles, established himself as one of the most feared and hardest hitting safeties in the NFL, a reputation later held by his protégé
FS: Paul Krause - HoF, 8x Pro Bowler, 9x All-Pro, NFL record 81 Interceptions



1st: Jerry Rice, WR (90's)
2nd: John Randle, DT (90's)
3rd: Darrell Green, CB (90's)
4th: Jack Youngblood, DE (70's)
5th: Paul Krause, FS (70's)
6th: Ted Hendricks, LB (70's)
7th: Ozzie Newsome, TE (80's)
8th: Jack Butler, CB (50's)
9th: Joe Schmidt, LB (50's)
10th: Torry Holt, WR (00's)
12th: Orlando Pace, LT (00's)
13th: Mike Munchak, OG (80's)
13th: Thurman Thomas, RB (90's)
14th: Mike McCormack, OT (50's)
15th: Mick Tingelhoff, OC (60's)
15th: Claude Humphrey, DE (70's)
16th: Walt Sweeney, OG (60's)
17th: Fran Tarkenton, QB (60's)
19th: Wilber Marshall, LB (80's)
20th: Chuck Noll, HC
21st: Wes Welker, WR (00's)
22nd: Steve McMichael, DT (80's)
23rd: Dennis Smith, SS (80's)
24th: Joe Perry, FB (50's)
25th: Miller Farr, CB (60's)
26th: John David Crow, TE (60's)

[richiesaurus310]

San Francisco 49ers

http://i.imgur.com/EAWEK6D.jpg

16 Hall of Famers
18 NFL All Decade Teams
41 Super Bowl, NFL, and AFL Championships
123 All Pro Teams

HC: George Seifert 90s- 5x Super Bowl champion (2 as Head Coach), 64.9 winning percentage

Offense

QB: John Elway 90s- HOF, 1990s All Decade Team, #23/100, 3x All Pro, 1x NFL MVP, SB MVP
RB: John Riggins 70s- HOF, 1980s All Decade Team, 1x All Pro, SB MVP
WR: Terrell Owens 00s- 2000s All Decade Team, 5x All Pro
WR: Calvin Johnson 00s- 4x All Pro
WR: Tommy McDonald 60s- HOF, 2x All Pro
TE: Shannon Sharpe 90s- HOF, 1990s All Decade Team, 5x All Pro
LT: Lou Creekmur 50s- HOF, 7x All Pro
LG: Tom Mack 70s- HOF, 8x All Pro
C: Bruce Bosley 60s- 4x All Pro
RG: Dick Stanfel 50s- HOF, 1950s All Decade Team, 5x All Pro
RT: Dan Dierdorf 70s- HOF, 1970s All Decade Team, 6x All Pro

Bench:

RB: Ottis Anderson 80s- 2x All Pro, SB MVP
RB: Paul Hornung 60s- HOF, 1960s All Decade Team, 2x All Pro, 1x NFL MVP
TE: Raymond Chester 70s- 4x Pro Bowl

Defense

LE: Lee Roy Selmon 80s- HOF, 1980s All Decade Team, #98/100, 5x All Pro, 1x DPoY, 78.5 Sk
NT: Michael Carter 80s- 4x All Pro, Olympic Silver Medalist in Shot Put, 22.5 Sk
RE: Bruce Smith 90s- HOF, 1980s+1990s All Decade Team #31/100, 11x All Pro, 3x DPoY, 200 Sk
LOLB: Andre Tippett 80s- HOF, 1980s All Decade Team, 4x All Pro, 1x DPoY, 100 Sk
MLB: Les Richter 50s- HOF, 5x All Pro
MLB: Levon Kirkland 90s- 1990s All Decade Team, 2x All Pro
ROLB: DeMarcus Ware 00s- 2000s All Decade Team, 7x All Pro, 134.5 Sk
CB: Herb Adderley 60s- HOF, 1960s All Decade Team, #64/100, 7x All Pro, 48 Int
CB: Emmitt Thomas 70s- HOF, 4x All Pro, 58 Int
NCB: Gary Green 80s- 5x All Pro, 33 Int
FS: Emlen Tunnel 50s- HOF, 1950s All Decade Team, #79/100, 8x All Pro, 79 Int
SS: Nolan Cromwell 80s- 1980s All Decade Team, 4x All Pro, 37 Int

Bench:

CB: Eric Wright 80s- 2x All Pro, 18 Int
LOLB: John Anderson 80s- 1980s All Decade Team, 25 Int
LOLB: Carl Banks 80s- 1980s All Decade Team, 1x All Pro

[killthesux]

OP updated regarding decade requirements

[killthesux]

Tennessee Titans

HC: Bill Walsh

Offense

QB: Joe Montana, 1980s

RB: LaDainian Tomlinson, 2000s
FB: Ernie Nevers, 1920s
WR: Steve Largent, 1980s
WR: Charlie Joiner, 1970s
WR: Henry Ellard, 1990s
TE: Tony Gonzalez, 2000s
TE: Russ Francis, TE

LT: Forrestt Gregg, 1960s
LG: Bob Talamini, 1960s
C: Dwight Stephenson, 1980s
RG: Jay Hilgenberg, 1980s
RT: Stan Jones, 1950s

Defense

DE: Julius Peppers, 2000s
DT: William Perry, 1980s
DT: Stan Jones, 1950s Jumpy Geathers 1980s
DE: Lesile O'Neal, 1990s

OLB: Mike Curtis, 1970s
MLB: Jack Lambert, 1970s
OLB: Mike Cofer, 1980s

CB: Ty Law, 2000s
FS: Gary Fencik, 1980s
SS: John Lynch, 1990s
CB: Dave Brown, 1980s
CB: Dave Whitsell, 1960s

Round 1 Pick 5- Joe Montana, QB
Round 2 Pick 32- Jack Lambert, LB
Round 3 Pick 41- Tony Gonzalez, TE
Round 4 Pick 68- Steve Largent, WR
Round 5 Pick 77- LaDainian Tomlinson, RB
Round 6 Pick 104- Forrestt Gregg, OT
Round 7 Pick 113- Ty Law, CB
Round 8 Pick 140- Julius Peppers, DE
Round 9 Pick 149- Lesile O'Neal, DE
Round 10 Pick 176- John Lynch, SS
Round 11 Pick 185- Charlie Joiner, WR
Round 11 Pick 190- Dwight Stephenson, OC
Round 12 Pick 212- Bill Walsh, HC
Round 13 Pick 221- Henry Ellard, WR
Round 15 Pick 257- Stan Jones, OG
Round 17 Pick 293- Dave Brown, CB
Round 18 Pick 320- Ernie nevers, FB
Round 19 Pick 329- Mike Curtis, LB
Round 20 Pick 356- Jay Hilgenberg, OG
Round 22 Pick 387- William Perry, DT
Round 22 Pick 392- Dave Whitsell, CB
Round 23 Pick 401- Bob Talamini, OG
Round 24 Pick 428- Gary Fencik, FS
Round 25 Pick 437- Mike Cofer, LB
Round 25 Pick 442- Jumpy Geathers, DT
Round 26 Pick FFA- Russ Francis, TE

[Wrench]

KTS new decades work for me but Id remove the minimum requirements for the 90s+ decades. Or reword it. Sounds like you want 3 for 90s 00s and 10s, three for 90s-thru-10s would be fine.

Also need to put in there about a players decade is the one they played the most in, unless its a dead tie at 5/5 or 6/6 etc. If they played 6 years in 70s and 5 years in 60s they should be a 70s, IMO.

[The Jokemaker]

Official Home of the Duluth Eskimos

Draft Selections
1.7 - QB Dan "King of Asgard" Marino, 90s
2.30 - CB Mel "Bring it on" Blount, 70s -HOF, physical corner who don't take no ****
3.50 - WR Lance "Bambi" Alworth, 60s - guy with the ability to always get open, HOF, one of best AFL players ever
4.71 - TE Kellen "Ride or Die"Winslow Sr, 80s
5.74 - OLB Bobby "Whatever you can do I can do better" Bell, 60s - tall, fast, athletic. arguably best all around LB and capable of covering, run defense, pass rushing
6.95 - RB Emmitt "Gator" Smith, 90s
7.110 - DT/OT Leo "The Lion" Nomellini, 50s
8.131 - DE Jason "Hercules" Taylor, 00s
8.143 - CB Aeneas "Solid Snake" Williams, 90s - HOF
9.146 - S "Weapon X" Brian Dawkins, 00s
11.182 - OC/OLB Clyde "Bulldog" Turner, 40s - HOF, great blocker, lot of speed, versatile LB. led league in INTs once
12.215 - WR Charley "Cash Money" Taylor, 60s OR 70s - HOF versatile and one of the best WRs of all time at time of his retirement
13.218 - MLB Nick "Champagne" Buoniconti, 60s OR 70s
14.251 - OT Bob "Boomer" Brown, 60s - fierce OT who made it his job to stop anybody
15.254 - S Donnie "Torpedo" Shell, 80s
16.287 - G Dan "Method Man" Fortmann, 50s or something old
17.290 - G Bill "Ghostface Killah" Fralic, 80s - all-decade guard of 80s, huge size
*draft rights acquired* - DE L.C. "Ain't Yo MC" Greenwood, 70s - probably in the HOF if so many players from the 70s steelers not already there
18.323 - WR Hines "Notorious B.I.G." Ward, 00s
20.354 - HC Tom "Doomsday" Landry
20.359 - HB Jerome "The Bus" Bettis
21.362 - DT Keith "Big Poppa Pump" Millard - has most sacks in a season for a DT, knee injury kept his career numbers low
- CB Pat "Mighty Mouse" Fischer - able to defend much taller WRs like Harold Carmichael
- TE Billy Joe "Hulk" Dupree - one of better TEs of his era, dependable weapon for Staubach, great blocker
- WR Dante "Mr. Clutch" Lavelli - DROPPED
- FB Tom "Tank" Rathman - versatile FB who helped guys like Roger Craig have success with the 49ers
Free agency: HB George "One-Cut" McAfee - HOF, member of 75th anniversary NFL team, known for his ability to take any play for a TD

http://orig07.deviantart.net/7aef/f/2008/208/a/5/brian_dawkins___weapon_x___by_hatlaczkiadam.jpg

Depth Chart
HC - Tom Landry
QB - Dan Marino
RB - Emmitt Smith, Jerome Bettis, George McAfee
FB - Tom Rathman
WR - Lance Alworth, Charley Taylor, Hines Ward
TE - Kellen Winslow, Billy Joe Dupree
O-line - Leo Nomellini (OT), Bill Fralic (OG), Bulldog Turner (OC), Dan Fortmann (OG), Boomer Brown (OT)
D-line - Jason Taylor (DE), Leo Nomellini (DT), Keith Millard (DT) LC Greenwood (DE)
Linebackers - Bobby Bell (OLB), Nick Buoniconti (MLB), Bulldog Turner (OLB)
CB - Mel Blount, Aeneas Williams
S - Brian Dawkins, Donnie Shell

Trades
#1 - Duluth Eskimos send:
1.2, 26.467
St. Louis All-Stars send:
1.4, 20.357

#2 - Duluth Eskimos send:
1.4, 2.35, 25.434
Pittsburgh Steelers send:
1.7, 2.30, 20.354

#3 - Duluth Eskimos send
3.38, 6.107, 10.179
Houston Oilers send
3.50, 6.95, 8.131

#4 - Duluth Eskimos send:
19.326, 20.257

St. Louis All Stars send:
LC Greenwood, 22.293

Decades Requirements met
20s-50s = 4
60s = 3
70s = 3
80s = 3
90s = 3
00s = 4

[The Jokemaker]

I'm neutral right now too.

[The Jokemaker]

I'm fine with anything but we do need to figure it out haha, maybe just keep the decades we have and merge the 20s-30s-40s-50s.

Three players minimum
20s-50s
60s
70s
80s
Seven players maximum (Only 1 can be from 2010s decade)
90s+

How does that sound?

I'm cool with this.

[The Jokemaker]

I did this elsewhere and you could use any pro team ever.

Everyone used Japanese x league names lol

We should try the college all time after this again. Did you do that? Holy **** that was interesting

That would be insane.

I never did the college draft but one can imagine the crazy names.

[Norm]

That would be insane.

I never did the college draft but one can imagine the crazy names.
I just meant in general it was fun. We drafted guys from the 1800s and pimped them lol. It was great. I think Strive won that iirc

[cubbybear2290]

Cubby here with Decatur Staleys

[TDjacksonville]

Saint Louis All Stars

[TDjacksonville]

All Stars

HC: Don Shula
Offensive Scheme: Ground and Pound. If Facing a Good Passing team we will scorch you with a spread offense ;)

QB: Sonny Jurgensen(80)
FB: Franco Harris(70s)
RB/WR: Frank Gifford(50s)
RB/WR: Lenny Moore(60s)
RB: Ollie Matson(50s)
WR: Tim Brown(90s)
WR: Raymond Berry(60s)
WR: Dante Lavelli(50s)
TE: Jackie Smith(70s)
TE: Jay Novacek(80s)
LT: Lou Groza(50s)
LG: MIKE MICHALSKE(50s)
C: Jeff Bostic(80s)
RG: Howard Mudd(60s)
RT: Ralph Neely(70s)

Defense 3-4
Self-explainatory.
Nickle defense Washington and Alzado check out for Pugh and Thorpe. Thomas and Taylor on the Edge with Ngata and Pugh in the interior.

RDE: Lyle Alzado(70s)
NT: Ted Washington(90s)
LDE: Haloti Nagata(90s)
DT: Jethro Pugh(1970s)
OLB lawrence taylor(80s)
ILB: Patrick Willis(00s)
ILB: Luke Kuechly(00s)
OLB: Derrick Thomas(90s)
CB: Willie Brown(70s)
FS: Ed Reed(00s)
SS: Jack Christi​ansen(50s)
CB: Lester Hayes(80s)
NB: Jim Thorpe(50s)

20-50s(3) 4 3 Starters
60s(3)2 3 starters
70s(3) 6 Starters
80s(3) 3 Starters
90s(3) 3 Starters
00-10(3) 4 starters

[SteelCurtain]

Actually, i think simpson and i won. Could be wrong though. It's been awhile though...

[Ebbs]

Meh.

Detroit Wolverines

[QB_Eagles]

Kenosha Maroons

[Norm]

Actually, i think simpson and i won. Could be wrong though. It's been awhile though...

I have no clue. You could be right.

[QB_Eagles]

So do the decade requirements have to be starters?

The rule thread was unclear on that.

[richiesaurus310]

When's the draft order going up, or is it up already?