PDA

View Full Version : Superstar Combo's Prime/Peak - Who gets more credit if together and they win title.



JordansBulls
06-03-2015, 02:10 PM
Let's say these superstar combo's are together when they win the title. In the end based on how they play there style, etc, who would get more credit for winning at the end of things.

Example: 2001 Shaq and 2001 Kobe.
2001 Shaq gets most of the credit.


Here are some of the combo's.

First the Consensus Top 10 all time using select seasons and a season in there prime/peak

1.) 1965 Russell with 2008 Kobe
2.) 1994 Hakeem with 1987 Magic
3.) 1971 Kareem with 1992 MJ
4.) 1967 Wilt with 1986 Bird
5.) 2001 Shaq with 2013 Lebron
6.) 2003 Duncan with 1964 Oscar

Others that could maybe perhaps make a case

6.) 1998 K.Malone with 1973 Walt Frazier
7.) 1983 Moses Malone with 1976 Dr J
8.) 2011 Dirk with 1981 Dr J
9.) 1993 Barkley with 1989 Isiah
10.) 2004 KG with 2015 Steph Curry
11.) 1995 D.Robinson with 2014 Durant

Minimal
06-03-2015, 03:02 PM
The ones that played better.

Jamiecballer
06-03-2015, 03:38 PM
what headspace do i need to be in for this question to make sense

KnicksorBust
06-03-2015, 04:59 PM
I wish you hadn't done so many but I will bite.

KnicksorBust
06-03-2015, 05:00 PM
Let's say these superstar combo's are together when they win the title. In the end based on how they play there style, etc, who would get more credit for winning at the end of things.

Example: 2001 Shaq and 2001 Kobe.
2001 Shaq gets most of the credit.


Here are some of the combo's.

First the Consensus Top 10 all time using select seasons and a season in there prime/peak

1.) 1965 Russell with 2008 Kobe
2.) 1994 Hakeem with 1987 Magic
3.) 1971 Kareem with 1992 MJ
4.) 1967 Wilt with 1986 Bird
5.) 2001 Shaq with 2013 Lebron
6.) 2003 Duncan with 1964 Oscar

Others that could maybe perhaps make a case

6.) 1998 K.Malone with 1973 Walt Frazier
7.) 1983 Moses Malone with 1976 Dr J
8.) 2011 Dirk with 1981 Dr J
9.) 1993 Barkley with 1989 Isiah
10.) 2004 KG with 2015 Steph Curry
11.) 1995 D.Robinson with 2014 Durant

Kobe
Magic
MJ
Wilt
Shaq
Oscar
Malone
Moses
Dirk
Barkley
Curry
Durant

Raps18-19 Champ
06-03-2015, 06:16 PM
Let's say these superstar combo's are together when they win the title. In the end based on how they play there style, etc, who would get more credit for winning at the end of things.

Example: 2001 Shaq and 2001 Kobe.
2001 Shaq gets most of the credit.


Here are some of the combo's.

First the Consensus Top 10 all time using select seasons and a season in there prime/peak

1.) 1965 Russell with 2008 Kobe
2.) 1994 Hakeem with 1987 Magic
3.) 1971 Kareem with 1992 MJ
4.) 1967 Wilt with 1986 Bird
5.) 2001 Shaq with 2013 Lebron
6.) 2003 Duncan with 1964 Oscar

Others that could maybe perhaps make a case

6.) 1998 K.Malone with 1973 Walt Frazier
7.) 1983 Moses Malone with 1976 Dr J
8.) 2011 Dirk with 1981 Dr J
9.) 1993 Barkley with 1989 Isiah
10.) 2004 KG with 2015 Steph Curry
11.) 1995 D.Robinson with 2014 Durant

?

PowerHouse
06-03-2015, 06:51 PM
I realize there are a lot of threads coming out lately that are imagination based such as imagine this player replaced with that player or what not but this goes beyond imagination. It goes into confusing absurdity, how can anybody judge performances and then divide the credit on said performances that never took place?