View Full Version : Tmac's first year in Houston (2005) or Current Harden (2015)

03-01-2015, 08:20 PM
Basically 2005 Tmac or Current Harden, who is the better player?

03-01-2015, 08:57 PM
I think Harden has been a bit more consistent this year. Tmac had an off game now and then. But tmac was the better defender. I remember a couple of games they put him on the other team's best player (Kobe), I could imagine doing that with Harden. So I would give it to tmac, but just barely. I think Harden will have more success in the playoffs tho.

03-04-2015, 03:21 AM
Tmac was at a different stage in his career. He had already had multiple All-NBA seasons, had dealt with significant injuries and was on a brand new team that was learning how to play together. By playoffs, Tmac was at a level I've rarely seen, particularly given his defensive versatility.

The playoffs will determine this.