PDA

View Full Version : Which Star Player do you take in each instance?



JordansBulls
02-27-2014, 04:21 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

NYKnickFanatic
02-27-2014, 04:23 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)
Bold.

GunFactor187
02-27-2014, 04:33 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

...

abe_froman
02-27-2014, 04:35 PM
1) Magic Johnson

2) Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem

4) Wilt Chamberlain

5) Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler

7) Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul

9)Scottie Pippen

10) David Robinson

11)Charles Barkley

12)Kobe Bryant(because longevity)

13) Oscar Robertson

14) Jerry West

15) Julius Erving (ABA)

sixers247
02-27-2014, 04:39 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen- Bad to compare

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

Heediot
02-27-2014, 05:48 PM
Do people get perks for regurgitating threads?

HeatBBall
02-27-2014, 05:51 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

bold

Kaner
02-27-2014, 05:59 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

.

IKnowHoops
02-27-2014, 06:06 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

I'm going like this

jerellh528
02-27-2014, 06:30 PM
1) Lebron James

2) Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem

4) Wilt Chamberlain

5) Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler

7) Dominique Wilkins

8) Chris Paul

9) Scottie Pippen

10) David Robinson

11) Charles Barkley

12) Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson

14) Jerry West

15) Kevin Durant

ohreally
02-27-2014, 08:56 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett. Tough one

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant another tough one

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

That's mine

TorontoHuskies
02-27-2014, 09:04 PM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

Game has changed too much to be able to compare some of these guys properly

DreamShaker
02-28-2014, 03:18 AM
1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James- That is super tough. I REALLY want to say Magic, but I think Lebron is probably better. I dunno. I feel like Magic was better at willing his team. Gonna go with Lebron, though. Tough one.

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal- Hakeem. I'm completely biased, but it's close.

3) Kareem or Bill Russell- Kareem with zero hesitation.

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan- Wilt on pure talent, but Duncan is by all accounts a better team player.

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett- Malone.

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry- Clyde.

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas- Zeke. He was one of the great floor generals and leaders ever.

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd- Toughie. I feel like CP3 still has some stuff to prove. Let's revisit this in a few years.

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen- Pippen with ease.

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson- Mr. Robinson.

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley - Chuck.

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant- Bird all day.

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier- Big O.

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade- West.

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)- KD

DreamShaker
02-28-2014, 03:25 AM
Interesting that there was no one, complete agreement.

Deadpool
02-28-2014, 03:26 AM
1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

PhillyFaninLA
02-28-2014, 05:57 AM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James - Today Magic, I have him at number 2 all time, when its all said and done this could be Lebron

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal - Hakeem, Shaq did bad against Matt Geiger, Shaq is great but he had so much more mass then anyone else and when he had someone with a bigger body he was less dominant

3) Kareem or Bill Russell - Kareem, Russell is great but Kareem and Wilt I'd put ahead of Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan - Wilt

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett - Garnett, you don't win titles with selfish me first offensive minded guys, Malone is why Stockton doesn't have a ring

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry - Drexler, not sure if this is the right choice because I don't know a whole lot about Rick Barry and Clyde the Glyde was so fun to watch

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas - Isiah, Dominique is more of a highlight reel type and Isiah is the 2nd best player pound for pound in NBA history

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd - Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen - Nash, Pippen with Jordan was great, Pippen without Jordan was not to far above average

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson - Robinson by a large margin, Dirk is great but the Admiral was special

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley - Barkley, I'm a Sixers fan

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant - I would not pick Kobe on any list and I think Bird is considerably better

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier - tough, I guess I'll go with Oscar

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade - Wade but I have never seen West play so I could have this wrong

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA) - today Dr J when its all said and done it certainly could be Durant

PhillyFaninLA
02-28-2014, 05:58 AM
Do people get perks for regurgitating threads?

or for meaningless replies like yours

Goose17
02-28-2014, 08:59 AM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

Really difficult to compare some of these guys due to the way the game has changed.

JasonJohnHorn
02-28-2014, 09:26 AM
1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan (just because I don't know how Wilt's game would translate today).

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett (this one is hard.... I LOVE Malone)

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry (This one is tough, but I'll go with CLyde because I'm not sure Barry's numbers would translate today)

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas Can I swap Thomas for Barry?)

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson This is the easiest one of the lot)

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant Just because his career was longer, but Bird' prime is better than Kobe's

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier (Correction: this was the easiest one)

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA) This one is also very tough. I might be wrong here.

DTownSkitzo
02-28-2014, 10:24 AM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas Homer pick

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

Bolded names.

Raps08-09 Champ
02-28-2014, 10:25 AM
Which Star Player do you take in each instance?

1) Magic Johnson or Lebron James

2) Hakeem Olajuwon or Shaquille O'neal

3) Kareem or Bill Russell

4) Wilt Chamberlain or Tim Duncan

5) Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

6) Clyde Drexler or Rick Barry

7) Dominique Wilkins or Isiah Thomas

8) Chris Paul or Jason Kidd

9) Steve Nash or Scottie Pippen

10) Dirk Nowitzki or David Robinson

11) Patrick Ewing or Charles Barkley

12) Larry Bird or Kobe Bryant

13) Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier

14) Jerry West or Dwyane Wade

15) Kevin Durant or Julius Erving (ABA)

.

DTownSkitzo
02-28-2014, 11:01 AM
I chose Magic over Lebron, but that decision could change depending on what LBJ does from now until the end of his career. One of a few hard decisions I had to make!

beyourself
02-28-2014, 12:05 PM
I never saw Bird and Magic play. Though LeBron plays a more premium position than Magic.

Also, people who are taking Kobe over Bird should note than Bird is considered by many to be top 3-5. I can't really refute their opinion because I never saw Bird, but let's remember his rep.