PDA

View Full Version : Which player do you take in each instance?



JordansBulls
11-02-2011, 01:53 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

beliges
11-02-2011, 01:57 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

(1) Barkley
(2) KG
(3) Isiah
(4) Pippen
(5) If both are healthy? Hill
(6) Melo
(7) Nique
(8) Toughest one yet but Ill go with Wilt
(9) Dumars
(10) Nash
(11) Oscar
(12) Rodman
(13) Pau
(14) Kemp
(15) Deron
(16) J Kidd

Ebbs
11-02-2011, 02:01 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki
Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett
Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade
John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen
Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady
David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony
Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King
Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain
Joe Dumars or Vince Carter
Walt Frazier or Steve Nash
Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving
Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman
Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol
Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber
Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams
Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

.

Chronz
11-02-2011, 02:11 PM
Charles Barkley
Kevin Garnett
Dwyane Wade
Scottie Pippen
Tracy Mcgrady
Carmelo Anthony
Dominique Wilkins
Tim Duncan
Vince Carter
Walt Frazier
Julius Erving
Dennis Rodman
Pau Gasol
Chris Webber
Deron Williams
Gary Payton

alencp3
11-02-2011, 02:28 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

Zefflin
11-02-2011, 02:42 PM
Charles Barkley

Kevin Garnett

Dwyane Wade

Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill

Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins

Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars

Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson

Dennis Rodman

Pau Gasol

Chris Webber

Deron Williams

Kidd

Hellcrooner
11-02-2011, 02:47 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

this

Avenged
11-02-2011, 02:58 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

PhillyFaninLA
11-02-2011, 03:20 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki - Barkley is one of the top 25 players all time and Dirk went from really good to top 10 in all of people's eyes (based on what I read on this site) because of a ring. He's one of the best European players ever but not an all time great. He is not better then is was the day before the last game of the finals and Barkley was always a monster.

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett - Garnett maybe the best ever at his position and I question how good Malone would have been without Stockton.

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade - Isiah is the second best little man ever, Wade is a great player and as I type this I wonder if I picked the right guy.

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen - Pippen proved he cannot get the job done without Jodan. Pippen is a top 50 player all time next to Jordan and barely an all star without him.

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady - McGrady was never special but some people seem to see him that way, his potential was special but not what he did on the court, Hill could have been a top 3 or 5 all time player.

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony - David Thompson could do more than let 4 seconds click off the clock in a clutch situation at the end of a playoff game. Thompson can spell and identify defense and clutch and Anthony despite being a better offensive player is overwhelmingly overrated by many and slightly underrated by others.

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King - Wasn't sure who to pick so I just took Wilkins

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain - I'm a huge Duncan fan but unless you say Russel, Kareem, Magic or Jordan and maybe Lebron in 10 years there is no one I'd take over Wilt.

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter - Vince Carter look I can dunk, Dumars look I can play basketball.

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash - I'm not a Nash fan so I really want to take Frazier but my feelings aside I think Nash may have been a hair better and took Amar'e as far as anyone possibly can.

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving - My heart wants to go with the Dr. but the Big O was to darn good.

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman - Laimbeer was special Rodman could do one thing as well as anyone ever.

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol - Daugherty over the overly soft Pau Gasol, don't like Pau Gasol at all and think he is highly overrated.

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber - Webber was more well rounded and Kemp was a better highlight reel.

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams - I suspect when D-Will retires I will pick him but as of now it KJ

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd - Kidd was a triple double machine and clutch, Gary Payton could steal the ball and guard you really well.

magicman333
11-02-2011, 08:00 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki: Dirk

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett: Malone

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade: Thomas

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen: Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady: Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony: Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King: Wilkins

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain: Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter: Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash: Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving: Robertson

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman: Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol: Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber: Kemp

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams: Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd: Kidd

Hawkeye15
11-02-2011, 08:08 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

Raps08-09 Champ
11-02-2011, 08:10 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

McKnight
11-02-2011, 08:35 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

:clap:

JordansBulls
11-04-2011, 05:21 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

My picks

sep11ie
11-04-2011, 05:44 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

Jay
11-04-2011, 06:52 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

TrueFan420
11-04-2011, 07:10 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki .... even tho i hate him he was a baller

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain... hardest one; one player is best pf ever and great team player the other one of the best ever but not great team player. timmy with the edge.

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

.

ohreally
11-04-2011, 10:49 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

BronxBomber300
11-06-2011, 09:26 AM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade 2006 NBA Finals Wade...'Nuff Said

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

I'm assuming comparing all players at their most dominant stages of there careers.

PhillyFaninLA
11-06-2011, 10:19 AM
deleted - not worth posting because person I was quoting is to arrogant to except a valid counter point.

KnicksorBust
11-06-2011, 10:22 AM
I like these but there are too many players. There's no actual debate it's just people bolding names.

Heediot
11-06-2011, 10:28 AM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

boomshakalaka

PhillyFaninLA
11-06-2011, 10:47 AM
I like these but there are too many players. There's no actual debate it's just people bolding names.


That's why I put in my thinking when I picked, I've noticed a few other people making a comment about a player or 2 but I put in my thoughts so people can at least understand where I am coming from.

Raph12
11-06-2011, 06:12 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony (never saw Thompson play)

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain (need to see Wilt play in a more modern era)

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving (need to see Oscar play in a more modern era)

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

.

daleja424
11-06-2011, 06:42 PM
The only thing funnier than you comparing Wade and Isiah is that a couple people have actually picked Isiah.

Can anyone actually present any kind of actual argument for that decision besides (In my best caveman voice), "HEAT bad"?

Meaze_Gibson
11-06-2011, 06:51 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki Barkley was a better overall player

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett Garnett had more skills than malone

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade Tough Call. Umm..

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen Never got to see Havlicek so can't call it

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady Shouldve played on same team but Grant had more skill

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony Never got to see Thompson play cant call

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter Dumars for longevity reasons

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber Chris webber had post plus could pass

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd Kidd

Bishnoff
11-06-2011, 07:04 PM
Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

THE MTL
11-06-2011, 08:04 PM
Which player do you take in each instance?

Charles Barkley or Dirk Nowitzki

Karl Malone or Kevin Garnett

Isiah Thomas or Dwyane Wade

John Havlicek or Scottie Pippen

Grant Hill or Tracy Mcgrady

David Thompson or Carmelo Anthony

Dominique Wilkins or Bernard King

Tim Duncan or Wilt Chamberlain

Joe Dumars or Vince Carter

Walt Frazier or Steve Nash

Oscar Robertson or Julius Erving

Bill Laimbeer or Dennis Rodman

Brad Daugherty or Pau Gasol

Shawn Kemp or Chris Webber

Kevin Johnson or Deron Williams

Gary Payton or Jason Kidd

bolded

Kashmir13579
11-06-2011, 08:19 PM
Dirk Nowitzki
Kevin Garnett
Dwyane Wade
Scottie Pippen
Tracy Mcgrady
Carmelo Anthony
Bernard King
Tim Duncan
Vince Carter
Steve Nash
Oscar Robertson
Dennis Rodman
Pau Gasol
Chris Webber
Deron Williams
Jason Kidd

Kashmir13579
11-06-2011, 08:19 PM
Can anyone actually present any kind of actual argument for that decision

I guess you COULD say that Wade wouldn't get away with traveling as much back in the 80s.

JordansBulls
11-07-2011, 02:39 PM
The only thing funnier than you comparing Wade and Isiah is that a couple people have actually picked Isiah.

Can anyone actually present any kind of actual argument for that decision besides (In my best caveman voice), "HEAT bad"?

Not sure really.

PhillyFaninLA
11-07-2011, 02:49 PM
Not sure really.

See my post on page 1, I am after all the only person supporting all of my picks and I picked Isiah.