PDA

View Full Version : Your team's Overrated/Underrated Starters



Vampirate
12-11-2009, 08:01 PM
Just state which starters on your team are overrated and underrated by PSD.

Mine is the Toronto Raptors.

(Keep in mind I haven't seen any games so i'm going by what people are posting)

Hedo Turkaglu: Probably just rated, noone in PSD including Raptor fans are rating him that high.

Chris Bosh: Overrated. He is in a contract year and from what I hear plays worse defence than Andrea. Still a great talent but overrated nontheless.

Jose Calderon: Underrated, even by me. He might be the worst defender in the NBA but I think he's better than people think, even Raptor fans. I don't know, just a feeling really.

Andrea Bargnani: Underrated. Now i'm not going to say he'sa a top 10 center. He is a better defender than Bosh is. He might be a below average rebounder for his position but I think he's an above average rebounder for what he actually does. Anyways the reason why he's here is because although he might be overrated by Raptor fans, he's really underrated by everyone else, which has far more people making him underrated.

Demar DeRozan: Eh I would say rated, it's really hard to judge a rookie when they haven't even played 1 season yet unless your someone like Lebron James.

Shady66
12-11-2009, 08:04 PM
Steve Nash - Underrated, people think hes too old, but from watching him, he looks just as ogod as his MVP years.

J rich - Overrated, extremely inconsistant. Can do a lot of things that scorers can, but not consistantly.

Grant Hill - Underrated, Does pretty much everything for this team, rebounds, defends best player on other team, scores, and finishes on the break.

Stoudemire - Overrated, His D has gotton better this year, but its still crap, as well as his rebounding. Offencively hes not as explosive as the highlights show lol

Channing Frye - Rated correctly, Great shooter whens hes hot, bad shooter when hes cold lol simple as that

Edit: I also wanna include Jared Dudley because hes pretty much played starter minutes this year. He is extremely underrated. Terrible athletism, but does everything else great, plays great D, pretty good rebounder, leave him open from three, and its in. He might be the suns 2nd or 3rd most important player

Vinny642
12-11-2009, 08:05 PM
CP- Normal
Brown- Over
Peja- Normal
West- Over
Okafor- Under/ Normal

King P
12-11-2009, 08:08 PM
Nets

Devin Harris - Rated
Courtney Lee - Rated
CDR - Underrated
Josh Boone - Rated
Brook Lopez - Underrated

ChiSox219
12-11-2009, 08:14 PM
Rose-Overrated
Salmons-Rated
Deng-Underrated (especially defensively)
Tyrus-Underrated amongst Bulls fans, sometimes overrated
Noah-Rated
Hinrich-Rated

drama1386
12-11-2009, 08:21 PM
jennings: rated
redd: overrated
delfino: rated
ilyasova: underrated
bogut: underrated

AIMelo=KillaDUO
12-11-2009, 08:26 PM
Chauncey-Rated
Aaron Afflalo-Underrated (consistantly knocks down open shots)
Melo-Rated.... finally gettin some respect
Kenyon- Underrated (If our D is on its cuz of K if its off its cuz of K)
Nene- Underrated (arguably the best Center in the West)

-Kobe24-TJ19-
12-11-2009, 08:27 PM
Fisher - normal
Kobe - normal
Artest - underrated
Pau - underrated
Bynum - underrated

-Kobe24-TJ19-
12-11-2009, 08:28 PM
Chauncey-Rated
Aaron Afflalo-Underrated (consistantly knocks down open shots)
Melo-Rated.... finally gettin some respect
Kenyon- Underrated (If our D is on its cuz of K if its off its cuz of K)
Nene- Underrated (arguably the best Center in the West)

you gotta be kidding:facepalm:

Shahrose
12-11-2009, 08:31 PM
Noah-underrated

FlakeyFool
12-11-2009, 08:32 PM
jose - overrated
derozan - underrated
hedo - overrated
bosh - rated
bargnani - :confused:

Vinny642
12-11-2009, 08:34 PM
Fisher - normal
Kobe - normal
Artest - underrated
Pau - underrated
Bynum - underrated

No and NO!!
People compared Pau to Dirk, and everybody knows what Artest is.

_KB24_
12-11-2009, 08:59 PM
Kobe- Normal to underrated (Yes, the way some of you rate him is comical)
Fish- Normal to overrated (Clutch as hell, but is the worst defensive PG in the league)
Artest- Normal
Pau-Normal
Bynum- underrated (Best or Top 2 offensive center in the league)

black1605
12-11-2009, 09:12 PM
i dont think anyone on the Bobcats is significantly under or overrated

IRUAM #21
12-11-2009, 09:14 PM
Chalmers - Overrated, he sucks
Wade - Rated
Richardson - Underrated, he's a good defender and helps this team a lot.
Beasley - Underrated, People just talk about his issues. This kid's a baller
O'Neal - Underrated, People say he's done. He can still average 13 & 6 with good defense.

asandhu23
12-11-2009, 09:16 PM
Andris Biedrins: Underrated / Mikki Moore: Insanely overrated
Anthony Randolph: Underrated / Ronny Turiaf: Underrated
Corey Maggette: Overrated / Kelenna Azubuike: Underrated
Monta Ellis: underrated / Anthony Morrow: underrated
Stephen Curry: perfectly rated / CJ Watson: underrated

Hustla23
12-11-2009, 09:25 PM
Knicks:

Lee - Underrated. Hardly many people know about his elite level offensive efficiency and rebounding
Chandler - Rated justly I guess. Nobody's calling him a bum, or a good player.
Harrington - Sometimes he is overrated , and sometimes he's underrated lol. Funny how it works. Some games he'll take 8,000 shots and completely screw up the chemistry and play no defense. Other games he'll be unguardable and lead the team to victory. But most of the time he's overrated.
Hughes - Rated justly.
Duhon - Unbelievably overrated. Even if you call this guy a bum he is still overrated. By far one of the poorest NBA players I have seen in a while.

Gallinari - Underrated. He is the best shooter in the NBA bar none, and his defense is tremendously underrated.
Douglas - Rated justly.

Everyone else is a non-factor.

TheKing23
12-11-2009, 09:29 PM
Mo Williams - Overrated
Anthony Parker - Rated
LeBron James - Underrated (The way people talk about him on here, you'd be surprised he's a top 10 player)
JJ Hickson - Underrated
Shaquille O'Neal - Rated

Kakaroach
12-11-2009, 09:56 PM
Deron Williams - PSD he's rated fine, its all the retards that vote for the ASG that under-rate him.
Ronnie Brewer - Underrated
Wesley Matthews - Underrated simply because nobody has hard of him yet.
Carlos Boozer - Underrated, specifically by Heat and Bulls fans.
Mehmet Okur - Rated fine, he's good on offense and horrid on defense.

arkanian215
12-11-2009, 10:08 PM
Nets

Overrated: Lopez, Harris, Lee, Yi

Underrated: CDR, Hassell, Battie

jimbobjarree
12-11-2009, 10:13 PM
deron- underated
cj miles- underated
Brewer- rated
Boozer- rated
Memo- rated
ak47- overated
millsap- rated
wes matthews- underated

Mane
12-11-2009, 10:16 PM
Gil0 - Overrated
Miller/Foye/Young=Rated
Butler - Overrated
Jamison - Underrated
Haywood - Underrated

EaglesJackson10
12-11-2009, 10:23 PM
Mo Williams - Overrated
Anthony Parker - Rated
LeBron James - Underrated (The way people talk about him on here, you'd be surprised he's a top 10 player)
JJ Hickson - Underrated
Shaquille O'Neal - Rated

You must think Tim Tebow is underrated too.

EaglesJackson10
12-11-2009, 10:25 PM
Allen Iverson-Slightly Overrated
Igoudala-Underrated
Thaddeus Young-Is what he is
Brand-Overrated
Dalembert-Overrated (by non sixers fans, sixers fan dont overrate him at all, they hate him.)

tsb77
12-11-2009, 10:40 PM
Rondo - underrated (the amount of hate he gets on here is unbelievable)
Allen - overrated
Pierce - rated
Garnett - rated
Perkins - underrated

gfixer33
12-11-2009, 10:41 PM
wizards arenas overrated
haywood underrated

Toenail Clipper
12-11-2009, 10:58 PM
PG - Baron Davis: Overrated, he should be more efficient with that basketball.
SG - Eric Gordon: Extremely underrated, do NBA fans know who he even is?
SF - Al Thornton: Check Eric Gordon
PF - Blake Griffin: Undefinable, hasn't played in the NBA
C - Chris Kaman: Underrated, he wasn't even in the ballot and he can be argued as the best offensive center in the west although he plays no DEFENSE.

sp1derm00
12-11-2009, 11:17 PM
Kobe: Rated at 1 or 2 in the league, so rated well.
Pau: Rated well also
Artest: Rated well as a player, underrated as a team mate.
Bynum: Underrated by some, overrated by some... I guess it depends on this guy.
Fisher: Overrated. Might be clutch as hell, but is sometimes the reason we're in such a deep hole.

-Kobe24-TJ19-
12-12-2009, 12:08 AM
PG - Baron Davis: Overrated, he should be more efficient with that basketball.
SG - Eric Gordon: Extremely underrated, do NBA fans know who he even is?
SF - Al Thornton: Check Eric Gordon
PF - Blake Griffin: Undefinable, hasn't played in the NBA
C - Chris Kaman: Underrated, he wasn't even in the ballot and he can be argued as the best offensive center in the west although he plays no DEFENSE.

read the title of the thread!

daisuke4cy
12-12-2009, 12:40 AM
Rondo - Underrated top 4-5 pg in the nba
Allen - Overrated not consistent enough
Pierce - Rated Almost underrated he dose so much for the team
Garnett - Rated when he is healthy
Perkins - Underrated the man is a beast on d and offensive game is getting alot better

mikantsass
12-12-2009, 12:53 AM
Rondo - underrated (the amount of hate he gets on here is unbelievable)
Allen - overrated
Pierce - rated
Garnett - rated
Perkins - underrated

Rondo does get a ton of hate on here I agree, but I still think he is overrated. Other than that I agree with you

ldc62
12-12-2009, 02:21 AM
Houston Rockets:
PG- Aaron Brooks: Underrated
SG- Shane Battier: Underrated
SF- Trevor Ariza: Rated
PF- L. Scola: Underrated
C- Chuck Hayes: Rated

Whole Rockets team was Underrated since the beginning of the season!

YankeeLove2
12-12-2009, 02:57 PM
raymond felton- rated about right
stephen jackson- rated about right, great fit with the cats though
gerald wallace- underrated
boris diaw- underrated
tyson chandler- overrated POS

bigsams50
12-12-2009, 03:00 PM
raymond felton- rated about right
stephen jackson- rated about right, great fit with the cats though
gerald wallace- underrated
boris diaw- underrated
tyson chandler- overrated POS

:nod::cry:

YankeeLove2
12-12-2009, 03:02 PM
:nod::cry:

at the time of the trade i figured it could work out in our favor, god was i wrong, he cant even rebound, thats why gwall is leading the league in boards!

bobcats would be an above 500 team easy with okafor, since the sjax trade weve been playing much better

bigsams50
12-12-2009, 03:05 PM
at the time of the trade i figured it could work out in our favor, god was i wrong, he cant even rebound, thats why gwall is leading the league in boards!

bobcats would be an above 500 team easy with okafor, since the sjax trade weve been playing much better

I thought Chandler would be an UPGRADE over Okafor. Now i just feel like a fool. Chandler is garbage. Nazr is outplaying him for ****s sake