PDA

View Full Version : The Rose vs Mayo debate (Rookie Year) will be like which of the following:



JordansBulls
12-15-2008, 06:49 PM
The Rose vs Mayo debate (Rookie Year) will be like which of the following:


1) Yao vs Amare Debate (2002-2003)

2) Lebron vs Melo Debate (2003-2004)

3) Emeka Okafor vs Dwight vs Gordon Debate in (2004-2005)

4) Iverson vs Marbury Debate in (1996-1997)

5) Brand vs Francis Debate in (1999-2000)

6) Oscar vs Jerry West Debate in (1960-1961)

7) Glenn Robinson vs Kidd Debate in (1994-1995)

8) Mark Aguirre vs Isiah Thomas Debate in (1981-1982)

9) Terry Cummings vs James Worthy vs Dominique Wilkins Debate in (1982-1983)

10) Chris Webber vs Penny Hardaway Debate in (1993-1994)



Those were just some of the Close Rookie Races in the past.


If you had to pick which one do you think this year's rookie race will be most like as far as the ROY?

Lakers4ItAll
12-15-2008, 07:00 PM
Lebron vs Melo is the only 1 i have ever heard people talk about

Ansy
12-15-2008, 08:27 PM
I think it will be like LeBron/Melo.

It will be very close like those two were and I think the guy that gets the nod (Rose) will get it more because people expect him to have the better career than because he had the better rookie season, just like LeBron.

b_rad23
12-15-2008, 08:30 PM
The Rose vs Mayo debate (Rookie Year) will be like which of the following:


1) Yao vs Amare Debate (2002-2003)

2) Lebron vs Melo Debate (2003-2004)

3) Emeka Okafor vs Dwight vs Gordon Debate in (2004-2005)

4) Iverson vs Marbury Debate in (1996-1997)

5) Brand vs Francis Debate in (1999-2000)

6) Oscar vs Jerry West Debate in (1960-1961)

7) Glenn Robinson vs Kidd Debate in (1994-1995)

8) Mark Aguirre vs Isiah Thomas Debate in (1981-1982)

9) Terry Cummings vs James Worthy vs Dominique Wilkins Debate in (1982-1983)

10) Chris Webber vs Penny Hardaway Debate in (1993-1994)



Those were just some of the Close Rookie Races in the past.


If you had to pick which one do you think this year's rookie race will be most like as far as the ROY?

I'm thinking Robinson vs Kidd. Good immediate scorer vs better playmaker/ team player

superkegger
12-15-2008, 08:32 PM
I don't think its going to be like any of those. They're two unique players in their own right. It doesn't have to compare to a past race and I don't think it does, at all.

pauljames
12-15-2008, 08:40 PM
i say marbury vs. iverson. rose's closest comparison is probably marbury, and like iverson, o.j. is a flat out scorer.

JordansBulls
12-15-2008, 09:21 PM
i say marbury vs. iverson. rose's closest comparison is probably marbury, and like iverson, o.j. is a flat out scorer.

I think Rose compares more to Francis than Marbury.