PDA

View Full Version : My top 30 list..



NYstateofMinD
12-15-2008, 10:52 AM
I just downloaded the roster updates for my 2k9 video game and I feel some of the top players have messed up ratings. These are my top 30 players. I know not everyone will agree with them generally but what I want to know is if the list is outrageous and if I'm missing anyone or have them in the wrong spots.

1.kobe
2.lebron
3.cp3
4.dwade
5.td
6.kg
7.dwill
8.d12
9.bosh
10.yao
11.amare
12.melo
13.dirk
14nash
15.pierce
16.arenas
17.vc
18.butler
19.roy
20.boozer
21.bdiddy
22.manu
23.joe johnson
24.billups
25.iverson
26.al jefferson
27.tony parker
28.devin harris
29.gasol
30.brand

fredv
12-15-2008, 11:40 AM
You forgot Tmac. And Harris shouldn't be there IMO.

EDIT: Yao should be over D12 as well. (no homer)

JordansBulls
12-15-2008, 12:42 PM
I just downloaded the roster updates for my 2k9 video game and I feel some of the top players have messed up ratings. These are my top 30 players. I know not everyone will agree with them generally but what I want to know is if the list is outrageous and if I'm missing anyone or have them in the wrong spots.

1.kobe
2.lebron
3.cp3
4.dwade
5.td
6.kg
7.dwill
8.d12
9.bosh
10.yao
11.amare
12.melo
13.dirk
14nash
15.pierce
16.arenas
17.vc
18.butler
19.roy
20.boozer
21.bdiddy
22.manu
23.joe johnson
24.billups
25.iverson
26.al jefferson
27.tony parker
28.devin harris
29.gasol
30.brand

Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

Er1c
12-15-2008, 01:43 PM
Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

how about kobe? 5?

Lakers4ItAll
12-15-2008, 01:46 PM
Bosh shouldn't be in top 4 you are crazy and Kobe is #1 forsure.

Also Pierce should be higher


Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

Squad13
12-15-2008, 02:48 PM
Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

:laugh: in the words of Clayton Bigsby "If there is hate in your hear, let it out!"

JIDsanity
12-15-2008, 03:02 PM
Works for me.

JIDsanity
12-15-2008, 03:03 PM
You forgot Tmac. And Harris shouldn't be there IMO.

EDIT: Yao should be over D12 as well. (no homer)

Are you sure

juggla53
12-15-2008, 03:29 PM
Peirce should deffinatley be higher and this is comeing from somone who hates him. D12 should be higher 21 points 14 rebs 4blks a game the guy is a freak and deffinatley the best center in the NBA. Other then that the list looks pretty on par with the exceptions of wether some people are one spot to high or two low but otherwise it looks pretty good.

juggla53
12-15-2008, 03:32 PM
[QUOTE=fredv;7672247]You forgot Tmac. And Harris shouldn't be there IMO.

EDIT: Yao should be over D12 as well. No homer



Haha yeah sure

rhino17
12-15-2008, 03:33 PM
Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

Bosh is nowhere near top 4 in the game.

unwantedplayer
12-15-2008, 03:48 PM
LeBron owns #1, Kobe #2, and Pierce is better than Melo.

JJ81
12-15-2008, 04:13 PM
Pretty much agree. Melo > Pierce.

JordansBulls
12-15-2008, 04:20 PM
Bosh shouldn't be in top 4 you are crazy and Kobe is #1 forsure.

Also Pierce should be higher

No way is Kobe #1 in it. He is shooting worse than those other guys, averaging less and is less efficient.

Sixerlover
12-15-2008, 04:24 PM
LeBron #1
Pierce > Melo

I agree with both of these

oshea225
12-15-2008, 04:27 PM
top 5 (based solely on individual play this season)
1. wade
2. lebron
3. cp3
4. kobe
5. dwight

fredv
12-15-2008, 04:46 PM
Are you sure

Just watch Yao dominate D12 each time they play against each other.

When I play ball against my brother, we can decide who is the best player by playing 1 on 1.
We are looking at who is the best player, so who plays the best against each other. Yao dominates Howard each and everytime...

ugafan
12-15-2008, 05:00 PM
I'm a huge Hawks fan, but I don't think JJ is better than Tony Parker.

The Answer3
12-15-2008, 05:30 PM
Here's my top 5

1. Dwyane Wade
2. LeBron James
3. Kobe Bryant
4. Chris Paul
5. Tim Duncan


Lebron Wade and CP3 and then Bosh should be rated the top 4 in the game. Nash shouldn't be anywhere near that high neither should Biddy or Arenas.

You've got to be kidding me. How is Bosh better than Kobe? The fact is, put Kobe on the Raps, Kobe'd be putting up better stats than Bosh and the team record would be pretty much the same if not better. Kobe doesn't need to average 30 points this season. His team's stacked. He has loads of talent around. He doesn't need to step his game up. I believe the reason his FG % is bit lower from last season has to something with his finger.

shatty
12-15-2008, 05:35 PM
u gave my man bosh his top 10 dues good on ya:clap:

Lakers4ItAll
12-15-2008, 05:36 PM
How the hell do u guys say Melo is better than Pierce??

MiamiHeat
12-15-2008, 05:39 PM
Just watch Yao dominate D12 each time they play against each other.

When I play ball against my brother, we can decide who is the best player by playing 1 on 1.
We are looking at who is the best player, so who plays the best against each other. Yao dominates Howard each and everytime...

umm so....
I take Howard any day over Yao
they play like 2 or 3 games against each other what about all the other games??


1.Howard
2.Yao

:)

Lakers4ItAll
12-15-2008, 05:45 PM
Me too


umm so....
I take Howard any day over Yao

juggla53
12-15-2008, 06:06 PM
umm so....
I take Howard any day over Yao
they play like 2 or 3 games against each other what about all the other games??


1.Howard
2.Yao

:)

Haha yeah isnt yao usually hurt for those games? Dwight howard is the best center in the leauge hes already taken his team furthur then Yao has and Yao is always hurt. 21 Pts 14 Rebs 4 Blk. Those numbers are off the charts as opposed to Yaos 19pts 10 lbs 1.5 blk.

JordansBulls
12-15-2008, 06:15 PM
Here's my top 5

1. Dwyane Wade
2. LeBron James
3. Kobe Bryant
4. Chris Paul
5. Tim Duncan



You've got to be kidding me. How is Bosh better than Kobe? The fact is, put Kobe on the Raps, Kobe'd be putting up better stats than Bosh and the team record would be pretty much the same if not better. Kobe doesn't need to average 30 points this season. His team's stacked. He has loads of talent around. He doesn't need to step his game up. I believe the reason his FG % is bit lower from last season has to something with his finger.

We are basing things on what is actually happening on the court. THE OP mentioned he downloaded the updated rosters on NBA 2k9. I said that those guys are playing the best. Also I meant to put Dwight not Bosh on the list.

NYMetros
12-15-2008, 06:27 PM
I just downloaded the roster updates for my 2k9 video game and I feel some of the top players have messed up ratings. These are my top 30 players. I know not everyone will agree with them generally but what I want to know is if the list is outrageous and if I'm missing anyone or have them in the wrong spots.

1.kobe
2.lebron
3.cp3
4.dwade
5.td
6.kg
7.dwill
8.d12
9.bosh
10.yao
11.amare
12.melo
13.dirk
14nash
15.pierce
16.arenas
17.vc
18.butler
19.roy
20.boozer
21.bdiddy
22.manu
23.joe johnson
24.billups
25.iverson
26.al jefferson
27.tony parker
28.devin harris
29.gasol
30.brand

IMO Kobe should be down on that list. LeBron should be #1. Also Pierce should be higher and Carter much lower.

Lakers4ItAll
12-15-2008, 06:28 PM
I agree w/ that


IMO Kobe should be down on that list. LeBron should be #1. Also Pierce should be higher and Carter much lower.

CB30
12-15-2008, 06:41 PM
Lebron is number 1 for sure

G-Funk
12-15-2008, 07:03 PM
wade is number one.

kingjanjic
12-15-2008, 07:05 PM
wow r u serious? how the *** isnt allen iverson top 10? that is a joke, he is one of the best scorer in the game by far, n as scorer i mean, if he wants to drop 50 points, he will do it any day he wants, he choices not 2 as detroit is more of a balanced offence

top 5 looks more like this

kobe
kg (any day over lebron, only full complete player in the nba)
lebron
wade
iverson/bosh


duncan top 5? LMFAO, dont make me laugh, he was always overated n should barly make the top 10

to miss tmac is also a joke, even tho he gets hurt, he has proven many nights that he can destory any defence in the NBA any time he wants, its not his fault his teams suck n cant get passed the first round, thats just bad luck, put him on a great team n hell get pasted the first round any time

juggla53
12-15-2008, 08:18 PM
wow r u serious? how the *** isnt allen iverson top 10? that is a joke, he is one of the best scorer in the game by far, n as scorer i mean, if he wants to drop 50 points, he will do it any day he wants, he choices not 2 as detroit is more of a balanced offence

top 5 looks more like this

kobe
kg (any day over lebron, only full complete player in the nba)
lebron
wade
iverson/bosh


duncan top 5? LMFAO, dont make me laugh, he was always overated n should barly make the top 10

to miss tmac is also a joke, even tho he gets hurt, he has proven many nights that he can destory any defence in the NBA any time he wants, its not his fault his teams suck n cant get passed the first round, thats just bad luck, put him on a great team n hell get pasted the first round any time


Haha so your one of those guys who all about scoreing, Iverson is no way a top ten player in this leauge anymore and i dont recall him putting up 50 whenever he wanted when he was with denver. 2-3 years ago iversons deffinatley up there but not anymore. Duncan overrated? im sorry but are you ********? Im not to sure how your overrated if you've been the foundation of four championship teams, won 3 finals mvps, 2 regular season mvps and have had countless 30+ point and 15+ rebound games in huge playoff seris and are considered by most knowledgeable basketball fans/experts as the best PF of alltime. And yeah Tmacs great if you want injury prone ball hogs who talk about the second round even tho theyre still in the first (only to blow a 3-1 seris lead). I find it funny how the magic got past the second round AFTER he was traded.

Master Mind
12-15-2008, 08:22 PM
Wade is #1

BullsNumber1Fan
12-15-2008, 08:49 PM
Wade in numero UNO!
Rose is numbero DOS!

That's how it should be!:p