PDA

View Full Version : What your all time Penguins lineup?



Sbank
08-10-2008, 02:06 PM
What your all time Penguins lineup?

Mine would be Crosby- Mario Lemieux-Jagr.

Steelinks
08-11-2008, 12:33 PM
What your all time Penguins lineup?

Mine would be Crosby- Mario Lemieux-Jagr.

You pretty much said it. How about Malkin Lemieux Jagr just to be different.

Sbank
08-11-2008, 09:38 PM
You pretty much said it. How about Malkin Lemieux Jagr just to be different.

Either line up is deadly. I wouldn't want to face off with either line up. Both line up would be amazing to see them play if it were possiable.

bartlett2266
08-12-2008, 09:17 AM
how about full line up

lemieux crosby stevens barrasso wregget/fleury
malkin francis jagr
tochett straka kovalev
errey trottier rechhi coach scotty bowman

Murphy Samulasson
zubov carlyle
gonchar coffey

mostly modern day guys but not to bad of a team

sao123
08-12-2008, 12:42 PM
Lemieux - Jagr - Nedved
Crosby - Hossa - Malkin
Kovalev - Straka - Recchi
Tocchet - Barnaby - G Roberts

Murphy - Gonchar
Coffee - U Samuelsson
Kasparaitus - Orpik

Fleury
Wregget
Barasso


healthy scratches:
Marcus Nasland
Ron Francis
Robert Lang
Luc Robatille

Sergei Zubov
K Samuelsson
Kevin Hatcher



ALTHOUGH... I would have liked to see Ziggy Palfy play for the pens in his prime...not his last ditch effort to save his career.

bartlett2266
08-12-2008, 02:18 PM
Lemieux - Jagr - Nedved
Crosby - Hossa - Malkin
Kovalev - Straka - Recchi
Tocchet - Barnaby - G Roberts

Murphy - Gonchar
Coffee - U Samuelsson
Kasparaitus - Orpik

Fleury
Wregget
Barasso


healthy scratches:
Marcus Nasland
Ron Francis
Robert Lang
Luc Robatille

Sergei Zubov
K Samuelsson
Kevin Hatcher



ALTHOUGH... I would have liked to see Ziggy Palfy play for the pens in his prime...not his last ditch effort to save his career.

WOW I know its ur opinion but how is ron francis a healthy scratch hes SECOND ALL TIME IN ASSIST in NHL history he was unbelievable and we probably dont win those cups without him. but the rest seemed alright

sao123
08-12-2008, 05:28 PM
WOW I know its ur opinion but how is ron francis a healthy scratch hes SECOND ALL TIME IN ASSIST in NHL history he was unbelievable and we probably dont win those cups without him. but the rest seemed alright



the reason I made him a scratch is quite simple...
Lemieux > Francis
Crosby > Francis
Straka > Francis
and Francis isnt that great of a checker.

I'd love to have francis on the ice... but Francis is a center. Not a winger.

bartlett2266
08-13-2008, 10:43 AM
the reason I made him a scratch is quite simple...
Lemieux > Francis
Crosby > Francis
Straka > Francis
and Francis isnt that great of a checker.

I'd love to have francis on the ice... but Francis is a center. Not a winger.

Straka plays wing aswell and hes not better then Francis check the numbers stats, rings, in everyway and also Francis played center and Mario played the wing when they played together.
check it out http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/records/minor_record.php3

bartlett2266
08-13-2008, 10:50 AM
i dont mean to keep pickin on u buddy, but its just mind boggling u must be born in the 90's one year nhl scoring Lemieux Jagr Francis were 1-2-3 in league scoring and were one line. definitely my favourite pens line ever

MG3
08-13-2008, 05:37 PM
Francis > Straka

sao123
08-14-2008, 08:39 AM
Straka plays wing aswell and hes not better then Francis check the numbers stats, rings, in everyway and also Francis played center and Mario played the wing when they played together.
check it out http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/records/minor_record.php3

The numbers suggest that after Francis left the pens his stats plummeted. His annual assists dropped by 20 from 70 to 50. His goals dropped from an average of 27 to 15, and his +- dropped from his all time high of 25 & 30 to -15 & -22. Francis was a produc of his linemates, and not necessarily a superstar himself. He was an assist king, suggesting, that his only good skill was passing the puck.

Francis might be a better passer, but Straka is a better face off winner, a much better checker, a better goal scorer, and has more speed/agility than Francis. I consider Straka, Kovalev, Lang to be the 2nd best Pens line ever, and Lang, so i considered heavily leaving them together.

bartlett2266
08-14-2008, 09:05 AM
Francis is hall of famer straka isnt close straka is not in francis league.

sao123
08-14-2008, 04:32 PM
Francis is hall of famer straka isnt close straka is not in francis league.

way to back up your statement with facts...
:thumbsup:

bartlett2266
08-15-2008, 09:03 AM
that is a fact Francis is in the hall of fame already and straka wont make it. this is nuts. First ballot HOFer Francis has 2 cups Captain of two different teams
strakas stats
Season Team GP G A P
NHL Totals: 954 257 460 717
Francis stats
Season Team GP G A P
NHL Totals: 1,731 549 1,249 1,798
Francis is over a point per game straka isnt even close any more facts u need

ShaunRiching9
08-19-2008, 11:26 PM
Lemieux-Crosby-Jagr
Malkin-Francis-Robitaille
Kovalev-Nedved-Naslund
Tocchet-Staal-Straka

Coffey-Murphy
Zubov-Gonchar
Hatcher-U Samuelsson