With the Yankees struggling to score, is it time to get rid of Cashman? The Yankees currently have one of the weakest farm systems and offenses in the league. Sure, Tanaka, Pineda, Prado, and McCarthy all seem to be good pickups. But what about not paying 10 years 200 million to Robinson Cano? What about signing Brian McCann and Carlos Beltran? Both of these players are having terrible seasons.
Do you think George would have put up with 2 seasons missing the playoffs? I don't think so. Neither should Hal. We have a good manager but the problem is he doesn't have enough talent. Who's fault is that? No other than Brian Cashman.
The Yankee fan is losing interest in the team. The team doesn't hit. They're boring. And it's time for a change in leadership.
If you are looking a replacement, I would have to say let's steal Theo Epstein from the Cubs, maybe even Billy Beane from the As or John Mozeliak of the Cardinals. It's time for Cashman to go. I want the Yankees to be the Yankees again.