Not wanting to hijack the other HOF thread
As we all know there are far far too many in all these HOFs, with the Rock & Roll one being ridiculous, trust me Robert Johnson was not Rock & Roll (love his stuff but it's blues)
What if this HOF thing was just starting? Yep, the first class will to be inducted next season, we can only have 8 a year. Who belongs on the very first ballot? Do we go with guys like "The Galloping Ghost" knowing full well he played against small slow white guys? How about the AFLers like Lance Alworth? How about the CFL and George Reed? This is the "Pro Football Hall of Fame" not the NFL.
So who is in the very first Pro Football Hall of Fame class? Just 8 allowed.