Who wins? Assuming everyone is at their prime. I'll give you the teams, feel free to change them...I'm putting them in the conference they won the award in...
PG- Oscar Robertson/Isiah Thomas
SG- Michael Jordan/Wade/Iverson
SF- Lebron James/Larry Bird/Dr. J
PF- Charles Barkley/Pippen
SF- Baylor/Durant/Rick Barry
PF- KG/Karl Malone
Note: I just could not leave Pippen off the East in favor of Cowens or Reed. So it's a bit smaller.