Rose vs. Bynum vs. Granger: Which have the best and worst impact after recovery?

[beasted86]

None of the 3 have played a game this season. The Bulls are the current 3rd seed, the Pacers are the 5th seed, and the Sixers are on the outside looking in at 9th, but have the chance to overtake the Celtics due to their injuries.


All 3 teams have all-star players that have shined due to the injury of these starters.

Which of the three helps their team the most or hurt their team's record?

[Stunnerko123]

Rose then Bynum then Granger

[Kyben36]

Bynum probably the best becasue the 76ers have more room to improve, the bulls still have the 3rd seed without rose, cant get that much better I think. and Granger is good but not even the best player of those 3.

Rose however is the best player clearly, but bynum will have more impact on the team.

[2-ONE-5]

ill put Bynum first over Rose just bcuz the Bulls are playing much better without Rose compared to this Sixers without Bynum. Sixers havent had a post threat in a long time and Bynum is desperately needed right now. Also Rose relies on his superior athleticism and i doubt he gets it all back this year. as far as Granger I kno Indy needs scoring but Granger is/was pretty inefficient if i remember right? Not sure if he will help or hurt their D either.

[More-Than-Most]

Its Bynum...We built our team around him so we are gonna struggle bad without him

[Pacerlive]

ill put Bynum first over Rose just bcuz the Bulls are playing much better without Rose compared to this Sixers without Bynum. Sixers havent had a post threat in a long time and Bynum is desperately needed right now. Also Rose relies on his superior athleticism and i doubt he gets it all back this year. as far as Granger I kno Indy needs scoring but Granger is/was pretty inefficient if i remember right? Not sure if he will help or hurt their D either.

Last year with granger the pacers were a much better scoring offense. If he stays healthy he will make them a top 10 offense.

[2-ONE-5]

sorry no way will Granger make Indy a top 10 offense in 30 games. they are 29th in scoring and 27th in Fg% and 23rd in 3pt %. Granger is not that good to take a team that ranks that low and bring them to the top 10

[xxplayerxx23]

It's Bynum then rose then granger. Bynum is Philly. They built the team around him. Rosé is the best player out of them but he isn't really missed more then Bynum right now

[Guppyfighter]

I am going to say Granger because because he comes back first and he fills the Pacers biggest needd

[rlundi86]

Granger sucks.

[ILLUSIONIST^248]

None of the 3 have played a game this season. The Bulls are the current 3rd seed, the Pacers are the 5th seed, and the Sixers are on the outside looking in at 9th, but have the chance to overtake the Celtics due to their injuries.


All 3 teams have all-star players that have shined due to the injury of these starters.

Which of the three helps their team the most or hurt their team's record?

Bynum will come back and be a good player but will not last another 5 years in this league.

Drose will come back very strong and be about 90 percent of what he used to be for the rest of his career.

granger i don't know to much about.I didnt even know he was out this year lol.

[ManRamForPrez24]

Bynum. Philly has the most room for improvement. They've been terrible offensively and Bynum will help that out a bit. They're about league average defensively, and again, Bynum will help out with that.

Indy and Chicago have been getting by with tremendous defense, and both do need some offensive help. I think Rose obviously provides more of that, but Indy's offense has been worse. Both will give their teams a nice shot in the arm. Just not as potent of one as Bynum will be giving the 76ers.

[KnicksorBust]

The fact that the Bulls/Pacers are still respectable really skews this toward Bynum. That being said, I think Bynum's injury may end up being a good thing because now Jrue/Turner/Thad have chemistry and have all taken a step forward. Now with a healthy Bynum they can be a legit team. Who knows if they develop nearly this fast with Bynum starting the season.

[SeoulBeatz]

bynum, this team was BUILT around Bynum.

Bunch of 3 point specialists, 2 playmakers (Jrue and e.t), and a bunch of undersized big men who would be much better suited playing next to a behemoth like BYNUM rather than spencer ****ing hawes.

im counting the seconds until he comes back...

[Tmath]

I think Rose will have the best recovery. He's the youngest, seems like the hardest worker of the 3 and will do what ever it takes to get back to 100%

Granger & Bynum are equal imo. They both had bad knees since the day they were drafted.

Rose will have the biggest impact on the team

Bynum will never be completely heathy, neither will Granger which will limit their productiveness.