PSD Lakers Forum: Mid-season Grades for Laker Players

[shep33]

What are your grades for the roster?

Kobe
Nash
Metta
Clark
Jamison
Dwight
Pauzer
Duhon
Blake
Meeks
Ebanks
Hill
Morris
Sacre

D'antoni

[Decimotox]

Kobe - B+
Nash - B
Metta - C+
Clark - C+
Jamison - C
Dwight - B
Pauzer - B-
Duhon - C
Blake - F
Meeks - C-
Ebanks - F
Hill - C+
Morris - C
Sacre - C+

D'antoni - D

[duane v]

Kobe = A-
Nash = C
Metta = B-
Clark = B-
Jamison = C-
Dwight = C
Pauzer = C
Duhon = D+
Blake = N/A
Meeks = D+
Ebanks = F
Hill = C
Morris = C-
Sacre = F

D'antoni = FFF---

[shep33]

Kobe = A-
Nash = C
Metta = B-
Clark = B-
Jamison = C-
Dwight = C
Pauzer = C
Duhon = D+
Blake = N/A
Meeks = D+
Ebanks = F
Hill = C
Morris = C-
Sacre = F

D'antoni = FFF---

Yeah, I'd agree with this. Nash and Dwight have been flops. The only good thing D'antoni has done is discover Earl Clark. Even then it was by pure chance due to injuries

[DanG]

Kobe = A-
Nash = B-
Metta = B+
Clark = B-
Jamison = C
Dwight = C+
Pauzer = C-
Duhon = D+
Blake = -
Meeks = C
Ebanks = -
Hill = B-
Morris = C-
Sacre = -

D'Antoni D+

[Zefflin]

Kobe B+
Nash C
Metta C
Clark B-
Jamison C-
Dwight B
Pauzer C-
Duhon C
Blake N/A
Meeks C
Ebanks F
Hill F/injured
Morris C-
Sacre D

D'antoni D

[DanG]

C for Metta? Did you guys really expect him to be better than 14-6-2?

[Hellcrooner]

Kobe C+
Nash c-
Metta C
Clark C+
Jamison F
Dwight D+
Pauzer C-
Duhon C
Blake------------has not played
Meeks D
Ebanks D
Hill C+
Morris C-
Sacre D

D'antoni Z

[Pluvious]

Kobe C+
Nash c-
Metta C
Clark C+
Jamison F
Dwight D+
Pauzer C-
Duhon C
Blake------------has not played
Meeks D
Ebanks D
Hill C+
Morris C-
Sacre D

D'antoni Z

This is the most accurate to me. Everyone has been average to below average. Maybe give Artest a B- but those stupid dribbles he does when he should give the ball up. Kobe has played well scoring but was so inconsistent on defense and leadership early on its hard to give him a good grade. C+ or B- for him.

[shep33]

I'd say Kobe and Metta surprisingly have been our best/most consistent players this year

[J4KOP99]

Why is it surprising that Kobe has been our best/ most consistent player this year haha?

[Decimotox]

Why is it surprising that Kobe has been our best/ most consistent player this year haha?

I think he meant just Metta was surprising. Kobe was always gonna be somewhat consistent.

Can't believe crooner gave him a C+ though

[Decimotox]

Although, at least crooner didn't give Pau an A or some **** lol

[J4KOP99]

As for grades (and this is based off of what i expected from them)

Kobe: A-
Ron:B
Nash:B-
Pau: C
Dwight: d+
Jamison: C-
Earl: B+
Hill: B
Meeks: C-

who cares about the rest

[Tymathee]

I grade on a scale. Compared to what their perceived contribution would be. a B is right on.

Kobe - A
Nash - B-
Metta - A
Clark - A
Jamison - C+
Dwight - B-
Pau - C+
Duhon - B+ (didn't expect anything)
Blake - n/a
Meeks - B
Ebanks - B
Hill - B+
Morris - B+
Sacre - A-

D'antoni - TBD