Trade #59: Penguins-Oilers

[The Top Shelfer]

This is a TC fail. The TC's job isn't to micromanage trades. Not every trade is going to be even (I think this is much more even than credit is given). These aren't your teams, the TC is constantly influencing a draft. You have to think of yourselves as refs, the less you're seen the better.

This isn't even remotely close to a rape and therefore the TC shouldn't even comment.

Haha yeah we all have an agenda here.

Lay down before you hurt yourself hahaha

If any of the TC wanted your opinion we would have asked for it

[elate]

That is funny, I don't remember giving a ****.

[The Top Shelfer]

That is funny, I don't remember giving a ****.

Grow up, its a game. No need for another computer tough guy on here haha

[elate]

You said something first!

[The Top Shelfer]

I am going to Pass this one. While I do think this trade is won by one team, the team in return is still getting a fair amount of value.

On a side note, I don't think this trade really benefits either of you but in terms of fairness, needs, and any other factor. I would say it is fair enough. If anyone wants me to explain any further I will

[The Top Shelfer]

You said something first!

Is this grade school? "I started it"?

Again, grow up

[elate]

Dude I don't understand. You insulted me online. Then told me to not be an internet tough guy and grow up. Then you agreed with me and passed the trade.

Wow.

[jrice9]

Dude I don't understand. You insulted me online. Then told me to not be an internet tough guy and grow up. Then you agreed with me and passed the trade.

Wow.

While I don't agree with him, he actually seems nuanced while you don't seem to have really thought about it. You called Karlsson a 1 year wonder when comparing him to Seguin for Gods sake.

[The Top Shelfer]

Dude I don't understand. You insulted me online. Then told me to not be an internet tough guy and grow up. Then you agreed with me and passed the trade.

Wow.

Hahaha only a mental case would spin it like that. You came on here saying the TC was all about ruining the draft and keeping control through micromanaging.

I said that this was a game and you should grow up. If that is an insult to you than stay safely behind that computer buddy, it is a lot scarier outside

[elate]

See. You did it again. You drop little remarks that make you seem like the internet tough guy. I called the validity of the TC into question (something I do every redraft), not the individual members.

I didn't spin it. That is how it played out. And when I do venture outside, I'm going to get my big brother to beat you up.

[RedWings13]

You came in here first and insulted the TC. Don't expect us not to fire back

[elate]

That is because I think the TC, as a body, is flawed.

Furthermore my opening post wasn't an insult in any way. It was much more a critique than anything.

[i am bob]

I feel like Edmonton traded the 1st and third valued player for the second and 4th lol

[boilerguy2412]

thats why there is 5 people, everyone is going to think different. I am not a fan of Andy Greene and that is where this trade is lost for me. Like i said this can be reworked fairly easily.

[TO Rapz]

I see exactly where Elate is coming from, which is why I passed it.