I'll respond to these silly posts now. Not going to quote any since there were so many.
Heyward had a career year last year. In 2011, he was awful! He needs to show consistency before he suddenly becomes better than Granderson. No way do I just go off of his most recent year. If we go off of last year than Heyward is their best outfielder. If you think
BJ Upton He's a decent player but always inconsistent. Another guy with a career year last year so he was able to boost his value (to some fans and GM's apparently. He's not better than Granderson, not even in his league. BJ and Ichiro are similar players at this point. Ichiro playing in Yankees stadium helps a lot. He always hit to what ballpark he was in and that's what he got a lot of groundball singles. I'd say even him and Heyward are similar and Ichiro is still as good a defensive OF as any of them.
Justin Upton is another player that thinks baseball is just a hobby that he gets paid millions of dollars to do. His last year wasn't great. At his best, he is better than the Yankees OF, but at his worst he's not as good as Granderson.
I'd rather have the Yankees OF personally, I don't like the Uptons at all. Heyward will need to stay healthy and remain consistent. It is close though. People are overvaluing BJ off of his last year and same with Heyward and J Upton. People are expecting a lot...