Last edited by trueblue83; 01-15-2013 at 11:53 AM.
Of those three, RGIII. Kaep is second, Russell third.
It's tough because of the hits RGIII takes...who's to say he doesn't miss a ton of time in his career due to injuries? But I'm still taking him.
I would take Newton and Luck over all three, but I guess I see why they aren't included (Newton a two year starter, Luck's a different type of QB than the rest).
Wilson is small, I don't know how long he can take a beating going forward, but he's a damn good player. He's actually more of a pocket passer with good scrambling ability. If he was a bit bigger, I'd take him.
RGIII is just not big enough to take the punishment. If he were to play like Aaron Rodgers, I would take him over about any other Qb in the league. But the athlete side of him takes over and he takes hits he shouldn't, and he doesn't know how to slide.
Kappy is huge. He's about as big as Cam Newton, and faster than Cam Newton. He has an absolute cannon for an arm, and his accuracy is actually pretty decent. He needs to develop touch on his passes and know when to throw a bullet pass and when not to. He's actually a little smarter than people think scoring a 37 on the wonderlic (not that it means a whole lot)...But if Kap keeps playing well, and keeps progressing I'd take him.
But as of right now, I'd have to take Wilson...but it should be put on hold for another year for Kap
RG3 is the best pocket passer of the three so I'd take him. His injury is an issue definitely, but I think he'll bounce back.
Chicago Bears #23
Kyle "Cheetah" Fuller
Kaep has already peaked. I see no upside in him and I don't think he is anywhere near the other two in skill level, or long-term potential. Give me either RGIII or Wilson, I really don't care, just keep Kaep off my team.
I would take RGIII. He was put in position by his coach to get hurt. They ran the read option almost 100% of the time, you have to mix it up. The Niners ran it some through the year and in some games they didn't run it at all. The games against the Bears, Saints, and Pats, the Niners had Kaep passing out of the pocket and it worked. The Greenbay game was the most we ran the read option all year and Im sure it was because the coaching staff knew Greenbay didn't have much tape on the Niners running it and they wouldn't do well against it. I think they will mix it up more for ATL because they should be ready for it.
The same thing with Wilson, the Seahawks were not only a read option team and Wilson always looks to pass first. Shanahan is a smart guy and I am sure they will work in different aspects of the WC offense going forward.
It's a tie between wilson and kap imo. Kaps the better runner and has a stronger arm but i think wilson reads defenses better and is extremely poised. Both will be around for awhile and making people like this wade guy angry because they are so enjoyable to watch and will dominate for years to come. While he watches complete trash from his awful choke artist qb Romo.