Toby Hyde looked at a comparable deal between the Mets and Diamondbacks. He came up with:
Closest Met: Dillon Gee
Closest Met: SS Wilfredo Tovar
Closest Met: Cory Mazzoni
Closest Met: Pick your favorite non-prospect outside of the Mets top-50 to match here.
Closest Met: The problem would be matching Prado who posted a 5.4 WAR for the Braves in 2012. Who do the Mets have that is comparable? David Wright, Niese, Wheeler, Harvey would be at the top of Arizona's list. The Braves did not deal Prado willingly. They were very reluctant, but hard for the Mets to match in terms of productivity.
Last edited by Dugmet; 01-27-2013 at 07:32 PM.
If we packaged a deal around Wright before the extension, that would have been interesting. I'm sure he would have returned to the Mets anyway after FA so we would have had Wright and Upton.
I, for one, am glad Sandy chose not to chase a deal for Upton. I don't think he is worth anything near what they were asking for him. We would be much better off to sign Bourn and lose the pick, then to give up Wheeler or Harvey to get Upton.
Now I want to say what I logged onto this thread to say. The name of this thread should be changed to "Free Agent Outfielder Left to Consider" (Singular) since there is no one left available, other than Bourn, worth signing.
Edit: Upon further thinking, it seems to me that Murphy plus another prospect like Darrell Ceciliani or Gilbert Gomez is a better comparable to Prado than Wright. So, if I could get Upton (plus a prospect, not necessarily Chris Johnson) for Murphy, Gee, Tovar, Mazzoni, Ceciliani and Marte, I guess I'd pull the trigger.
Last edited by dunbummin; 01-28-2013 at 01:02 AM.
Former B'klyn Dodger fan. Mets Maniac since 1962.
Wright and Sandy could have had a shady agreement, remember that Cliff Lee returned to the Phillies. That would have been awesome lol.
The difference is the Twins waited so long they forced the Sox and Yanks to move on leaving us at the table. Arizona jumped on the better offers early.
People need to stop acting like out GM ****ing lies to us all the time. Grow up and realize every GM in every sport is never direct because they don't play their hand to the media or fans.
Arizona needed a third baseman and in earlier posts figured he and a prospect not named harvey wheeler tda or davis or wright would be available for trade for upton. While upton is talented its not that hard to find outfielders who hit 17 75 .280...while he could hit 30 homers and drive in 90 he hasn't done it consistently. Id rather have bourn and build from there. Juan Rivera is still a FA I think...he would improve our depth at low cost. Duda Bourn Nieuwenhuis with Rivera Cowgill and Valdespin in reserve/platoon roles could be productive enough...Baxter and Brown are fifth or sixth outfielders at best.
Met fan since 1969