I don't think he's a good defensive catcher, but the guy can hit, just not last year apparently. Even though he still hit for power. I have to be honest though, I really don't want another .230 type hitter with 30+ HRs like Grandy. However, if he could hit like .275 with 25 bombs, you guys have to admit he'd be (EDIT: infinitely better) better than Stewart or Cervelli.
I mean come on, we lived with Posada for years. Don't you guys think he was more of an offensive catcher?