Trout and Harper 1 and 2 in Keith Law's TOP 25 under 25 rankings

[northsider]

Would someone be able to post the list? I'm at work.

Thanks

?

Page 1 has it I think last post.

[northsider]

Trout
Harper
Heyward
Stanton
Strasburg
Kershaw
Machado
Castro
Bumgarner
Andrus
Lawrie
Salvador Perez
Chapman
M. Moore
Parker
Sale
Harvey
Rizzo
Freeman
Grandal
Simmons
Middlebrooks
Kimbrell
Hosmer
Tillman

[Driven]

?

Page 1 has it I think last post.

Yeah, at first I thought that was his own list.

I think there's a big drop off after Machado, although to be fair the consensus has Castro is up there. I'm just not sold on him.

[LakersA's49ers]

How the **** is kershaw number 6? He should be number 2 or 3

[rickshaw]

I'd go Trout, Kershaw, Stanton. Can't see anyone being in front of those 3 realistically.

[DodgerB24]

I'd flip Strasburg and Kershaw, but that's just nitpicking.

[Rush]

I totally forgot Kershaw is still only 24. That's ridiculous. One of the best pitchers in baseball and some top prospects are just starting their careers at that age. I Kershaw (but not the Dodgers, Scully ).

[beldugo]

Maybe not before Heyward but, it's not laughable.

Castro is a stud.

That's exactly why i laugh, there's no way he is going to be a better player than Heyward.

[Rio40]

I had no Idea Kershaw was only 24. It feels like he has been around for a long time.

[Nomar]

Maybe not before Heyward but, it's not laughable.

Castro is a stud.

Define stud.

He doesn't walk enough. His hitting needs to improve a lot if he's going to be a stud. His defense doesn't look too promising. He may have to move off of SS later in his career at which point he better hope hes a much better hitter. IMO how good he is will be tied to the power he develops and how much he can get on base, because his defense won't be a strong point at short.

[VRP723]

I'd love to know how many people here would trade Matt Moore for Chapman? I'd bet none.

[Jeffy25]

Define stud.

He doesn't walk enough. His hitting needs to improve a lot if he's going to be a stud. His defense doesn't look too promising. He may have to move off of SS later in his career at which point he better hope hes a much better hitter. IMO how good he is will be tied to the power he develops and how much he can get on base, because his defense won't be a strong point at short.

Castro?

Because his defense was pretty good this year, and significantly better than it was last year.

Offensively, yes. He will need to either produce more power or develop some discipline. But he should at least be an average offensive shortstop, with a decent potential because of his age.

[Jeffy25]

Cards with nobody

But a top 5 farm system and a good 'team' is enough


/we didn't have anyone that would belong, I wasn't saying anyone deserved to be on here.

[Nomar]

Trout
Harper
Heyward
Stanton
Strasburg
Kershaw
Maybe Sale

These are the only people on the list I would trade Matt Moore for.

[VRP723]

Trout
Harper
Heyward
Stanton
Strasburg
Kershaw
Maybe Sale

These are the only people on the list I would trade Matt Moore for.

I'd probably deal him for Machado, but yeah, it's a select few.