Playoff Voting: AL CENTRAL DIVISION - BEACON HILL

[AI4]

AL CENTRAL
Key West Manatees
Santiago Putas
Montgomery Biscuits
Beacon Hill Warriors

[AI4]

Can't decide between 2 teams here, will take a closer look at them later.

[rcs15]

Really tough choice for me between Beacon and Montgomery

[hammerinhank]

Meant to vote Beacon Hill, Montgomery is a close 2nd.

[Green_Monster]

As others have said, Beacon and Montgomery are head to head. But I feel Beacon is slighty better.

[Yankee Clipper]

Just curious why you guys think Beacon is slightly better?

[hammerinhank]

I think Beacon/Montgomery comes down to the pitching depth and I feel Beacon has the slight edge there.

[GrkGawdofWalkz]

Better starting pitching 1-5, better pen, while your offense is slightly better IMHO. (I am the Beacon GM).

[TheRuckus]

Meant to vote Beacon Hill, Montgomery is a close 2nd.

Edited the poll to reflect this.

[Yankee Clipper]

Better starting pitching 1-5, better pen, while your offense is slightly better IMHO. (I am the Beacon GM).

I think slightly is a bit of an understatement. But that may just be me.

[GrkGawdofWalkz]

I think slightly is a bit of an understatement. But that may just be me.

You have more power in Morse, Fielder, Cruz and Ortiz. I have much more balance in my line up. I'm not discounting your team at all. I just think my team will be fine.

[Yankee Clipper]

You have more power in Morse, Fielder, Cruz and Ortiz. I have much more balance in my line up. I'm not discounting your team at all. I just think my team will be fine.

Yes more power but the middle of my order also gets on base at a higher clip.

[Nomar]

I think slightly is a bit of an understatement. But that may just be me.

For me:

Your back end of the order is ugly, but the heart of the order is loaded. Roberts, Callaspo, and Rodriguez are pretty weak, and Cruz is declining. It was close but i think the gap between the two pitching staffs was bigger than the gaps between the lineups. Definitely a close one though. Also I think your team is more of an injury risk, but didn't take that into much consideration.

[j-bay]

Bh