Considering we almost voted Freddy Sanchez into the all star game, i think Buster Posey will be the MLB13 cover athlete.
Eh, there was a lot of marketing done by the Giants organization that made that happen. Personally, I think most people that aren't Giant fans are going to be bitter that the Giants won 2 world series in 3 years. People don't like winners if they're not their winners. I'm going to say McCutchen wins it, because he is the most likable.