The ROY discussion thread

[FWBrodie]

Just quote one of the posts I've already made.

You lost me at #2. You took stats and created your own system. I don't necessarily disagree as much as expect there to be serious flaws involved.

[WadeKobe]

Just quote one of the posts I've already made.

You lost me at #2. You took stats and created your own system. I don't necessarily disagree as much as expect there to be serious flaws involved.

I'm glad you haven't even offered a methodology yet, but you're convinced someone else's methodology contains flaws.

So, try me. Deal critically with my methodology. Where are the flaws. How can they be improved?

[NormSizedMidget]

I'm glad you haven't even offered a methodology yet, but you're convinced someone else's methodology contains flaws.

So, try me. Deal critically with my methodology. Where are the flaws. How can they be improved?

One of my neighbors has a methodology lab in their garage.

[FWBrodie]

I'm glad you haven't even offered a methodology yet, but you're convinced someone else's methodology contains flaws.

So, try me. Deal critically with my methodology. Where are the flaws. How can they be improved?

Look man, I've offered plenty of evidence. I'm kind of over it at the moment, interested in other topics and headed to the bar for the Nat'l Chip. Maybe I'll talk about it later.

[WadeKobe]

Look man, I've offered plenty of evidence. I'm kind of over it at the moment, interested in other topics and headed to the bar for the Nat'l Chip. Maybe I'll talk about it later.

Again, evidence without a methodology is just baseless opinions built from arbitrary endpoints. You have to have a methodology. I don't know why you refuse to set out a methodology.

[FWBrodie]

In 17 starts as a rookie, Wilson led four fourth quarter comebacks against teams with a combined record of 43-21. Three of those teams (Green Bay, New England, Washington) qualified for the postseason. Wilson came back to beat all of them, as well as the Chicago Bears, while amassing 903 passing yards, 173 rushing yards, eight touchdown passes and zero interceptions in the process. That’s clutch. That’s how you close out football games.

http://www.nationalfootballpost.com/...nd-a-miss.html

[sfgiants5518]

One additional rookie of the year perspective. Colts OL surrendered 246 total pressures this year. Most of any OL in past 5 years (by 25)

https://twitter.com/PFF/status/288395486099034113

[NateyB24]

They were this bad before the season. People just didn't notice.

Earl Thomas started as the best SAF in the NFL.

Russell was great after the preseason.

Sherman was better than Revis by like week 4.

Wagner is DPOY

Lynch is the 2nd best RB

IDK, I'm sure there's more.

I don't get why they need to fight for their players so hard. Who cares what we think? They need this vindication from all of us or something.

I fail to see how Wagner can't be DPOY i doubt he will win it though thats the problem for playing for Seattle you don't get the hype.

The only two i find as homerish comments are the two i bolded rest i don't think are really that homerish.

[NormSizedMidget]

I fail to see how Wagner can't be DPOY i doubt he will win it though thats the problem for playing for Seattle you don't get the hype.

The only two i find as homerish comments are the two i bolded rest i don't think are really that homerish.

All of them are somewhat reasonable. I just don't want to hear them 50 times a day from 50 different people.

As far as DPOY I have no idea. I never once saw TB play for example.

[alexander_37]

One of my neighbors has a methodology lab in their garage.

[NormSizedMidget]

I was so sad when nobody laughed at that.

[alexander_37]

I was so sad when nobody laughed at that.

I honestly laughed out loud for 5 minutes.