Which CB would you rather have?

[NormSizedMidget]

If you didn't you're stupid. Especially since I told you in the last thread who I would choose.

My whole point was that only SEA fans are going to pick Sherman. Which means........it's probably Revis and not Sherman.

If Revis was on your team. You would pick Revis. It's just reality.

It's like the MVP thread where Brady was DOMINATING conversation because of Pats fans. I made a thread where no Pats/Vikings/Den fans could vote. AP dominated and Brady wasn't even second.

[NormSizedMidget]

Can you really tell me that you would rather go into next season with Revis who missed 3/4 of the season with a major injury? I mean if you where seriously going to create a roster from todays NFL roster as it sits now, would you pick the guy coming back from a major injury vs a guy who is playing at a pro bowl form AND is younger?

I was thinking who's better NOW, like 2013 when they're both back. For one year, not the foreseeable future.

I mean I would take Luck over Brady forever. Brady over Luck right now. Brady is the better player obviously. That's different.

[c_reinert]

Don't get me wrong, he's done well for them and "assuming the PED thing works out ok and he able to perform at the same level once he's off them then they have every reason to be happy with him, but he's just not as good as Revis

Can you really tell me that you would rather go into next season with Revis who missed 3/4 of the season with a major injury? I mean if you where seriously going to create a roster from todays NFL roster as it sits now, would you pick the guy coming back from a major injury vs a guy who is playing at a pro bowl form AND is younger?

Yes. Because Revis is still young, projects to bounce back from injury well. ACLs also aren't nearly the major injury they use to be. More and more players who have that injury are coming back in top form.

And even if he didn't. Revis at 90% is still better than Sherman

[Austeezy]

This thread just got the death sentence. Moved to the graveyard

[kpak76]

I was thinking who's better NOW, like 2013 when they're both back. For one year, not the foreseeable future.

I mean I would take Luck over Brady forever. Brady over Luck right now. Brady is the better player obviously. That's different.

So am I. Look, if Revis remained healthy and played like he always does, I would choose Revis before Sherm also. But major knee injurys are really hard to come back from. He could come back and be only 80% of the player he once was. That is still starter material and good, but not at the level of Sherm is now. You just need to be a split second slower to not be as effective as a CB. He may not trust his knee's completely coming back and not play at full speed. It has happened many many times in the NFL. If he comes back next year and is the same Revis, I would change my mind and say he is the best still. But a major injury like he sustained is a concern and defiantely effects how he would perform next year. Especially at the start of the season. Better chance he is the old Revis by the end of the year than the beginning.

[NormSizedMidget]

Who cares. Sherman has ZERO votes from non SEA fans.

[NormSizedMidget]

So am I. Look, if Revis remained healthy and played like he always does, I would choose Revis before Sherm also. But major knee injurys are really hard to come back from. He could come back and be only 80% of the player he once was. That is still starter material and good, but not at the level of Sherm is now. You just need to be a split second slower to not be as effective as a CB. He may not trust his knee's completely coming back and not play at full speed. It has happened many many times in the NFL. If he comes back next year and is the same Revis, I would change my mind and say he is the best still. But a major injury like he sustained is a concern and defiantely effects how he would perform next year. Especially at the start of the season. Better chance he is the old Revis by the end of the year than the beginning.

Adrian Peterson

[B'sCeltsPatsSox]

Don't get me wrong, he's done well for them and "assuming the PED thing works out ok and he able to perform at the same level once he's off them then they have every reason to be happy with him, but he's just not as good as Revis

/thread.

Re-open thread, sorry Austeezy it's a bad comparison lol.

/thread.

[kpak76]

Adrian Peterson

Not the same type of injury but I cant think of a knee injury of the top of head. Ed Reed has not been the same player since his concussions.

[kpak76]

Who cares. Sherman has ZERO votes from non SEA fans.

Good thing fans don't build rosters too.

[YouCan'tBeatLA]

Revis

Sherman is overrated by Seahawks fans.

QB's have a 45.6 passer rating when throwing his direction (best for a CB), 23 PD (best in the league), 7 picks, 3 FF, 1 sack, and a couple of defensive TDs.

Say what now?

[NormSizedMidget]

Good thing fans don't build rosters too.

What?

[NormSizedMidget]

QB's have a 45.6 passer rating when throwing his direction (best for a CB), 23 PD (best in the league), 7 picks, 3 FF, 1 sack, and a couple of defensive TDs.

Say what now?

It's not Hayward anymore?

They said it was this last week on the radio

[kpak76]

QB's have a 45.6 passer rating when throwing his direction (best for a CB), 23 PD (best in the league), 7 picks, 3 FF, 1 sack, and a couple of defensive TDs.

Say what now?

And people are really saying they would take a broken guy over this one.

[NormSizedMidget]

And people are really saying they would take a broken guy over this one.

He's only broken in your eyes. The rest of us realize he will heal and be fine.