A non elite QB has won 2 Super Bowls in 5 years. I guess Eli has been top 7ish for a season or two in his career but nothing elite
Eli had a really good 4 year run from 2008-2011, averaging 4000+ yards, 7.7 YPA and 27 TD per season. I'll grant you his numbers prior to that run weren't very good, even during that 2007 run where his numbers were fairly comparable to the numbers Grossman put up in 2006, and then he got really hot in the playoffs. But he's still in consideration for HOF status, even if he's not a lock to make it. And his numbers the last 5 years have been better than any 5 year run Cutler has had.
OOTP TKO League Milwaukee Brewers 2010-2032: 2011-1655, .549 Win % 10 NL Central Titles, 2 Wild Card 12 Total Playoff Appearances 1 World Series Title (2021)
Now you can luxuriate in a nice jail cell, but if your hand touches metal, I swear by my pretty floral bonnet: I will end you.