You can read the details at Pirates Prospects
Joel Hanrahan, Brock Holt
Mark Melancon, Jerry Sands, Stolmy Pimentel, Ivan De Jesus
I like it more than I thought I would. Losing Holt isn't a huge loss. I figured De Jesus had a decent shot to get some playing time with the Sox this year, and he can probably be as solid of a utility man as Holt.
I convinced myself, and it really wasn't hard to do so, that Joel was in for some serious regression this year. Some of his peripherals were a bit unsettling to say the least.
Sands I'm on the fence about, and Pimentel hasn't been a formidable prospect in a while. But I'm excited about Melancon. Hopefully he can regain his Astro's form. He's much more than a throw in here. Melancon in 2011 was as good, probably better even, than Hanrahan was last year. I don't think, watching him somewhat regularly last year, that it's unreasonable to think he'll rebound well again.
I really truly have no idea what to expect from Sands. I guess we'll find out.
I no longer care about anything here except for the Entertainment Forum, which sucks; the Music forum, which sucks; and the Magic forum, which does NOT suck.
Except for all of y'all.
Based on years of control, Melancon for Hanrahan straight up is a win for the Pirates. I think Melancon might be a little bit of a head case that was intimidated by being in the AL East. Getting back to the NL Central could lead to some great numbers. Holt might have a little better bat than De Jesus, but his range prevents him from playing an adequate SS like De Jesus.
I think this is a clear win for the Bucs. Sands and Pimental are just gravy. Only question now is, who saves and who sets up?
Melancon really didn't pitch bad for the Red Sox. He had a HR problem for his first few outings and then settled in and performed rather well. His numbers other than ERA were either similar or better than Hanrahan's.
Pimentel is really just a throw in though he does give me an interesting arm to watch in Altoona besides Taillon and Sadler. Holt for De Jesus was just a move to clear a 40 man spot I think and as you said Holt has the better bat but De Jesus is the better fielder and can play a little SS. Sands is the wild card for me as I'm not really sure where he fits. A platoon of Snider/Sands in RF could be intriguing but then Tabata is out and if the Pirates were to trade him now they would be selling him extremely low.
Love the trade kinda in a vacuum, but who know's what Hanrahan would have fetched 6, 12, or 18 months ago. Still, considering the current context, very good trade in my book.
This is probably not the correct place to do it Cutch but what are your thoughts about Tabata? I seem to be in a rather small minority here (basically just me) in that I really like him and I think trading him now would be a big mistake. I mean I've probably written this 100 times on this forum but he had a .362 OBP from June on. The Pirates just can't simply ignore something like that no matter what his other numbers were.
Also even further off topic but I hope you participate in our 2nd annual PSD Pirates fan of the Season contest this year. It pretty much is just a predicition challenge where you guess how the Pirates players are going to perform over the course of the season and on a monthly basis. Tomahawk27 is our defending champ as he beat me in Game 162 with Travis Snider's 9th inning single.
Edit: In case you are interesting here is a link to the final results
Last edited by burgh_fan66; 01-03-2013 at 04:18 PM.
Yeah and don't you forget it mwahahah