if they want the ball to be returned, they shouldnt allow the reciving team to give a huge penalty to the kicking team by stepping out of bounds on purpose. the penalty that cobb forced is kind of counterintuitive to the NFL wanting teams to return the ball. IF THIS RULE DOESNT EXIST, COBB RETURNS THE BALL LIKE THE NFL WANTS.
It should be changed now for sure but it's so rare....2004, 2008, 2012. I sense a pattern. But seriously. It's rare, I don't think they ever thought it mattered enough but I imagine the theory started on, well don't kick it over there and this doesn't happen.
Cobb also runs the risk of stepping out and coming back in suppose. Plus the rule of how OOB's works was already established so I suppose they saw no need to make special rules for KO's on something that literally should never happen.
PS. When I saw return the ball, it's more about field position. They don't want guys getting pinned at the 10 on kickoffs. The 40 is good field position. But also the KO return is exciting as well.
the obvious answer to the dumb rule quesiton is the retarded challenging rule
30 Team Stadium Checklist: 12 to go
1) Yankees 2) Orioles 3) Rays 4) Red Sox 5) Mets 6) Braves 7) Phillies 8) Nationals 9) Marlins 10) Pirates 11) Padres 12) Astros 13) Mariners 14) Twins 15) Cubs 16) White Sox 17) Cardinals 18) Indians 19) Tigers (June 8th 2013)
BRETT GARDNER HOME RUN METER
HOME RUN COUNT: 3
A WR must complete the process of the catch in the end zone, while RB don't have to maintain possession diving into the end zone....
The NFL has tons of dumb rules. Most of them contributing to the pussification of American football.
THE BUZZ IS BACK!
The play is reviewable because he threw the flag while the play was being reviewed.
All scoring and turnovers are automatically reviewed
I think that most of the penalties that have come up over the last 20 years that diminish the role of defense are making the game very boring. My top 3 being
Roughing the kicker
Roughing the passer
I guess I don't dislike the spirit of the roughing the kicker and roughing the passer rules, but it has made it almost pointless to try to for a sack or punt block for fear of these rules. To me, if the player makes an obvious attempt to pull away from the play, it should not be called. Also, if a player is pushed, or has unstoppable momentum going, it should also be reconsidered.
The 2 things that hate about PI are:
1. how it completely takes the defender out of the play
2. the ambiguous nature of the call...and I really hate the assessment of placement at the spot of the foul. Soooo many games that should not be decided by PI are because of it happening in the end zone. Once again, it is the ambiguous nature of the call that is frustrating
I think the perfect penalty is the way they do it in college. 15 yards and a first down. Or keep it the way it is, except, revert to the college version when in it happens in the red zone
I hate intentional grounding and forward progress because it, once again, eliminates the opportunity for very exciting defensive plays to happen.
Last edited by xpucksx; 01-01-2013 at 11:28 PM.