Good post, but I believe Tanny needs to go. I agree with your assessment of the Jets roster, But that still does not excuse the decisions that Tanny has made.
Most Gm's would not have given Sanchez an extension. Take away the playoff's and what does Sanchez body of work show? Did other Gm's extend Tebow or Rex Grossman based on playoff records or results?
Tanny in his years has traded draft picks away like they were going out of style. Most pick ups have not panned out. Now the Jets are void of talent in key areas.
Was Tebow really a Woody pick? Most stories I read say it was a Tanny and Rex decision. Tanny and Rex hatched the idea of this unstoppable "wild cat" attack and sold Woody the idea. Woody loved it saw the buisness side of it and became obsessed.
Jets in the offseason had a chance to upgrade the Wr position. Knowing they had a bad QB why wasnt this adressed? If you know you have a limited QB why wouldnt you help that QB by getting him more weps? During the preseason the Jets and Sanchez struggled why did they stand pat? A GM should recognize the issues and pick up players to help.
Tanny needs to go and the Jets need to bring in a proven GM who knows talent. They need to remove Rex from any talent evaluation. Rex can be a good HC but he needs help. At this time Rex has far too much on his plate. A good GM can help Rex with that aspect.
The only way I see Tanny comming back is if Mcelroy is able to lead the Jets offense into the endzone. If The Mcelroy lead offense can score some points then the Tanny moves/non moves look a little better.
I have a feeling Mcelroy will do ok . Lets just hope the Jets havent given up.