
Originally Posted by
MrX27
Let's see:
Has Vick proven that he can win games in Atlanta? Yes, he did.
The current Vick is not anywhere near as explosive as he used to be
Has Vick proven he can win games in Philly? Yes, he did.
Way more talent at the skilled positions. Plus, all of Reid's QBs play well in his system. Remember A.J. Feeley?
Is Vick going to demand big money? No he won't, because the market for him would only be one of a team looking to transition to another QB.
He wants big money, but I agree that he won't get anything close to his asking price.
Is Vick serviceable for a year or 2? Yes, he is.
Agree
Are the Jets going to find a Brady, Manning or Rodgers in FA to QB the Jets for the next 10 years? No, they won't.
Stupid question. QBs of this caliber won't hit Free Agency.
Do the Jets need a QB that could potentially carry the team with his ability to win games, until they find a franchise QB? Yes, they do.
Agree
Is Vick, even with less explosiveness, a better athlete than anyone else available in FA? Yes, he is.
Agree.
Since the Jets need an experienced QB to temporarily guide the team (until a franchise QB is attained and ready), should the Jets look at the best FA QBs available and work the list from the top? Yes, they should.
Of course they should start with the top. Why wouldn't you?
Is the name at the top of that list Michael Vick? Yes, it is.
The name at the top of the list is Joe Flacco, but he will probably end up back with the Ravens. I would rather the Jets bring in Matt Moore over Vick. Although Vick is a much better athlete, he isn't going to win many games with his legs any more. If someone sneezes in Vick's direction, he goes down with a concussion. I also think Moore is the better passer and will come at a cheaper price tag.
Now what makes you think your suggestion of not signing him is better, when he is clearly the best FA QB that's available, AND he won't demand a big money contract, AND it would only be until the Jets have a franchise QB groomed and ready to go, AND the team would still be competitive, AND you already saw with Sanchez what could happen when you immediately start a rookie who isn't mentally ready long-term, AND is your only alternative Alex Smith, because if that's your only counter then how is what he offers more than Michael Vick, when Alex Smith is not a franchise QB either.