Schaub or Cutler

[Benaforce]

A friend and I were debating this question. Who is the better QB?

Matt Schaub or Jay Cutler

[Benaforce]

Stats through last week

Jay Cutler

Completion % 59.8
Yds 2,495
Touchdowns 16
Ints 13
Passer Rating 80.9

Matt Schaub

Completion % 64.4
Yds 3,062
Touchdowns 21
Ints 9
Passer Rating 94.5

[FortDetroit]

hard to compare really.

[BcEuAbRsS]

Cutler has better skills, but Shaub has played better in a better offensive system.

[haggis]

Do I also get the Texans OL?

[Benaforce]

Do I also get the Texans OL?

Are you saying Cutler would be better with Schaubs OL? I'm not arguing. I think Cutler has a better set of skills, but Schaub makes less mistakes and dumb throws.

[Pinstripe power]

schaub

[DavidR]

As much as I hate him, Schaub.

[haggis]

Are you saying Cutler would be better with Schaubs OL? I'm not arguing. I think Cutler has a better set of skills, but Schaub makes less mistakes and dumb throws.

Well, I think if you switched both from the start of their tenures with both teams respectively, Cutler would be a much better QB right now. Schaub is very immobile and would have been completely murdered playing behind the Bears OL. Schaub has also had the benefit of playing behind a top OL, a top WR, and recently one of the best running games in the league since he's been a Texan.

I think Cutler has the better raw tools, and I think paired with a great offensive mind like Kubiak he would have more success than Schaub has had so far IMO. I think Schaub is a "safer" pick than Cutler, but I think he has had much more surrounding talent to work with. I think in a vacuum that Cutler is a better QB than Schaub.

[Max Power]

Cutler has better skills, but Shaub has played better in a better offensive system.

With a MUCH better coaching staff.

[j11430]

Schaub is pretty good, but is made better by an awesome supporting cast. Cutler is pretty good but is made worse by a horrible o-line.

I kind of like Schaub better because I think he's more accurate and Cutler has had some serious accuracy issues lately. But they're really pretty equal if you don't take supporting cast into account

[j11430]

It's hard to compare Cutler to anyone really because of that o-line. We haven't seen him with a good line since 2008, we don't really know if he's playing up to his ability or not

[FWBrodie]

Schaub and it isn't close.

[SenecaValley46]

It's deff Schaub. Without question

[mikebrez bears/]

Last two answers not even close eh... Well guess that's speaks to how little knowledge of football you have. Well done.


Cutler with a top 20 o line, he is a top 8 plus QB easy. Top 5 o line, top 5 QB. The bears o line is ranked 31st. Put Schaumburg behind that last 3 years and this is not a thread because he's not alive anymore.