The Official 2012-2013 New York Yankees Offseason Thread III

[rrzubnyy]

David Price is the best SP in the division.
Cano probably the best hitter.
Jim Johnson is the best closer.
O's may have the best bullpen.
Rays pitching staff blows ours away.

The Rays staff took a major hit.

[LeoYankee]

Is this the same Leo who has bashed CC the last 3 years, "Fake Ace" blah blah. Now you say CC is better than Price. Wow dude, bi polar much? Drink another one buddy!

Yes, that's in all of baseball. I'm talking our division. I think CC is a fake ace at times against certain teams, but Price is even worse in big games. Just look at his playoff log.

Hence, if I'm taking a guy for one year, which was the original argument.....I'm taking Fatty.

If its in real life for a trade, I'd take Price any day over the $125 million for Fatty.

[LeoYankee]

I think it all comes down to Price being young and still learning. This past year was a great one for him. Perhaps he is becoming the best pitcher in the east, but for now, CC still is.

Exactly.

[JobaRules26]

Doesn't Fatty have a Cy young? I think his stats over the last 3-4 years are pretty strong, no?

RA Dickey won a Cy young. He better than CC?

CC's stats over the last 3-4 years are great, no question. Dicky doesnt pitch in the AL East, so yeah no point. The point is, David Price, RIGHT NOW, is the better pitcher.

[LeoYankee]

CC's stats over the last 3-4 years are great, no question. Dicky doesnt pitch in the AL East, so yeah no point. The point is, David Price, RIGHT NOW, is the better pitcher.

Dickey might be in the AL east by tonight. Just ask rzzzzzzzzzzubbbbnyyyyy.

[Decimotox]

CC's stats over the last 3-4 years are great, no question. Dicky doesnt pitch in the AL East, so yeah no point. The point is, David Price, RIGHT NOW, is the better pitcher.

See my most recent post ^ which was confirmed by Leo. Then we can drop all this.

[LeoYankee]

CC's stats over the last 3-4 years are great, no question. Dicky doesnt pitch in the AL East, so yeah no point. The point is, David Price, RIGHT NOW, is the better pitcher.

At worst, it's a tie.

But u need to relinquish ur argument on Mo. One year wonder closers don't count for jack ***.

[JobaRules26]

I love you guys but we'll just have to agree to disagree.

[JobaRules26]

At worst, it's a tie.

But u need to relinquish ur argument on Mo. One year wonder closers don't count for jack ***.

Until I see how Mo comes back I'll assume JJ has a better chance at the better year. I hope I'm wrong with this, I want Mo to ****ing dominate
.

btw yeah i botched Price's postseason stats lol

[LeoYankee]

Word. It's all good. Hence fun to debate without belittling each other like the 'know it alls'.

[LeoYankee]

Ps- You guys should all play lotto since you may never see me defend Fatty like that again!

[JobaRules26]

Word. It's all good. Hence fun to debate without belittling each other like the 'know it alls'.

I usually apologize in advance before a debate cuz I can get crabby lol all good.

[Thump]

Ps- You guys should all play lotto since you may never see me defend Fatty like that again!

Oddly I just won $10 on a scratch off..

[LeoYankee]

Oddly I just won $10 on a scratch off..

See what I do for this forum? I make u beaaatches loot!

[Yankee Clipper]

David Price is the best SP in the division.
Cano probably the best hitter.
Jim Johnson is the best closer.
O's may have the best bullpen.
Rays pitching staff blows ours away.

Bullpens and closers are very fluky (except for Mo of course). I mean, most of the Orioles relievers that thrived last year had done nothing productive previously. I wouldn't be surprised if their bullpen comes back to Earth next season after outperforming themselves last season.