Ranking the QBs

[raiderposting]

Rank them in terms of their projected success in their nfl career in your opinion, not where they'll be picked

1. Mike Glennon
2. Zac Dysert
3. Ryan Nassib
4. Tyler Wilson
5. Matt Barkley
6. Geno smith
7. Ej Manuel

[Nymfan87]

Geno>Tyler Wilson=Barkley

Followed by a whole lot of poo.

[wissportsfan]

Rank them in terms of their projected success in their nfl career in your opinion, not where they'll be picked

1. Mike Glennon
2. Zac Dysert
3. Ryan Nassib
4. Tyler Wilson
5. Matt Barkley
6. Geno smith
7. Ej Manuel

Interesting. I like the theory but not a huge fan of the list.

[Robbw241]

Glennon's pocket presence could be his downfall in the NFL.

[iam brett favre]

Looks like a rough QB draft.

[DavidR]

Looks like a rough QB draft.

I know, the Jags picked a bad year to suck this badly.

[alexander_37]

Geno at 6? Barkley at 4?

[Alpha Dog]

I know, the Jags picked a bad year to suck this badly.

Jags won't draft a QB high. Gabbert is the same age or younger than most of those guys on the list. Better than all of them.

[alexander_37]

Jags won't draft a QB high. Gabbert is the same age or younger than most of those guys on the list. Better than all of them.

1st part is true! Second is the most wrong thing I have seen since the movie Jesus Christ Serial Rapist.

[Alpha Dog]

1st part is true! Second is the most wrong thing I have seen since the movie Jesus Christ Serial Rapist.

Gabbert has a better passer rating and completion rate than eight or nine starting quarterbacks in the league to this point in the season. He is younger than all of them, and still younger than most of the guys coming out of college this year. Why would you think it makes sense for the Jags to draft a quarterback? Won't happen.

[alexander_37]

Gabbert has a better passer rating and completion rate than eight or nine starting quarterbacks in the league to this point in the season. He is younger than all of them, and still younger than most of the guys coming out of college this year. Why would you think it makes sense for the Jags to draft a quarterback? Won't happen.

His only stat line that isn't HORRIBLE is TD:INT ratio which is merely mediocre.

[Alpha Dog]

Well, like I said, over a quarter of the league's starters at the moment have worse stats. With generally more to work with in terms of offensive talent around them. Everyone talking about Luck as the second coming, but I think Gabbert has a better passer rating and completion percentage. He is also a bit younger. Why is one guy with the same stats a future star and the other guy a writeoff? Other than blind stupid bias. But that is your problem not Gabbert's.

[NCBoSoxfan21]

WHAT THE HELL is with all the delusional Jags fans? Gabbert... sucks.

Who is Gabbert younger than?

Blaine is 23.

Barkley, Geno, Glennon, Dysert, Nassib, Manuel are all 22.

Wilson is 23 and a month older...

GABBERT IS CRAP whether he's 20 or 28, he still sucks.

[homestarunner93]

1. Geno Smith
2. Tyler Wilson
3. Matt Barkley
4. Ryan Nassib
5. Landry Jones
6. Mike Glennon
7. EJ Manuel
8. Colin Klein

Need to see more of before I make a determination: Zac Dysert
Not ranked due to draft status: Aaron Murray, Tajh Boyd, Tyler Bray, Derek Carr

[BCB mwat15]

1. Tyler Wilson
2. Matt Barkley
3. Geno Smith
4. Ryan Nassib
5. EJ Manuel

I think Bray will declare with the the coaching change but I'm going to leave him off until he does.