Kildrive says he is the best o.c. In the nfl. Loll

[RolleWebster]

Why isn't Randle being used more...especially with ailing Nicks. Don't get me wrong Nicks is the ****... but he isn't 100%

Good to see Jernigin step up. Made a nice grab...

But Candle needs to be utlized more. He is a big boy give him the rock. Those little *** DBs for Washington. Pitiful!!

So TC needs to go

[RolleWebster]

Surprised giants ARENT using they're draft picks much this season. Must be not ready or something.

[Wrigheyes4MVP]

Our Redzone O needs to improve.

Tynes is gonna break records at this pace.

This is unacceptable.

[GGGGG-Men]

Why isn't Randle being used more...especially with ailing Nicks. Don't get me wrong Nicks is the ****... but he isn't 100%

Good to see Jernigin step up. Made a nice grab...

But Candle needs to be utlized more. He is a big boy give him the rock. Those little *** DBs for Washington. Pitiful!!

So TC needs to go

Randle got a lot of time, but 2 different times he was way off his route and Eli was frustrated. So Jernigan got some time and made the most of it.

[rwynyc]

Randle has not done anything this season and he is god awful at punt returns. I swear some of you just love to throw rookies into the starting line up for no good reason at all.

Is that like the cool message board thing to do?

[eeek78]

I actually like Gilbride, but I agree with most of what is written here. Does anyone remember when John Hufnagel was the OC here? The offense was terrible back then. That is what got Gilbride the OC job. The offense was way better from there on out. The biggest issue with Gilbride is his predictability. At times you know exactly what this offense is doing. That falls on Eli as well. That is probably the biggest thing going for BobG3 with all that option crap they run. No one knows who will be carrying the ball. That will end soon.

Was anyone waiting on Fewell to come over and punch Gilbride in the face (like our buddy, Buddy did?) after the 3 and out in our last offensive possession?

[brodgitt82]

Randle got a lot of time, but 2 different times he was way off his route and Eli was frustrated. So Jernigan got some time and made the most of it.

It's not that Randle ran the wrong route it's that Gilbride system is a bit too complicated to adjust to for some players. Is it a coincidence that Eli ALWAYS has issues with being on the same page with his receivers. Smith,Burress,M.Ham,Nicks and even Cruz have all been confused as to what route they should be running on multiple occassions. Gilbride just sucks so hard he swallows!!!

[uwish1127]

Jeez, I tried to give this guy some credit in the game thread but god damn did he call an awful game tonight. He's a pretty good coordinator (except for his shotgun run game scheming), but he is a pretty bad play caller.

We can say he called a bad game, but one guy did worse....Perry Fewell

[uwish1127]

Argue with me saying its hard to beat an offense like that, but we have and others have as well. We came out and destroyed the Packers, shut down there passing game, and I can tell you what I saw different WE WEREN'T BLITZING and when we did there was no containment, making RGiii look way better

[NY007]

I'm really tired of the Gilbride bashing.. No doubt he's predictable at times and makes bad calls but what o coordinator doesn't??? He's still solid and totally taken for granted..

[brodgitt82]

Giants never should've let S.Payton get away. As a head coach or offensive coordinator,Giants would not be having these issues if Payton was still here. Gilbride sucks and Caughlin is actually a good coach but just doesn't know how to choose his coordinators.

[GGGGG-Men]

Say what you want, Gilbride has 2 rings. He makes mistakes and some questionable calls, but in the long run he's managed Eli and this offense pretty well.

It's not that Randle ran the wrong route it's that Gilbride system is a bit too complicated to adjust to for some players.

One and the same. Until he learns that system as well as Cruz and Nicks and end up where Eli expects him to be, he won't get more snaps.

It's a tough system with all the options and reads, but that complexity is also the reason we see guys wide open fairly often. Instead of being committed to a route they can find space.

[NY007]

Say what you want, Gilbride has 2 rings. He makes mistakes and some questionable calls, but in the long run he's managed Eli and this offense pretty well.



One and the same. Until he learns that system as well as Cruz and Nicks and end up where Eli expects him to be, he won't get more snaps.

It's a tough system with all the options and reads, but that complexity is also the reason we see guys wide open fairly often. Instead of being committed to a route they can find space.

Exactly.. People should also take note of how the Giants offensive system gets the most out of a player. Just think about the Wrs and te's who moved on from the Giants and careers took a major down slide.. You think thats a coinidince?? This offense system was created by Gilbride. And again, every o coordinator makes bad or predictable calls. Ever consider if the players executed the right way it would be a good play??

[schuyler5237]

He needs a good punch in the face.

[GGGGG-Men]

Exactly.. People should also take note of how the Giants offensive system gets the most out of a player. Just think about the Wrs and te's who moved on from the Giants and careers took a major down slide.. You think thats a coinidince?? This offense system was created by Gilbride. And again, every o coordinator makes bad or predictable calls. Ever consider if the players executed the right way it would be a good play??

Great point. Sheming and system works wonders. His play-calling is what's frustrating at times, but again, Eli has full audible rights and Coughlin (offensive coach) says he has the final say on plays, so who knows where this really falls.

Pat Kirwan made a great point today. If Haslett was gonna keep showing all those creative looks, why didn't they just go no huddle in the 2nd half? That'll shut down that cute stuff real fast.

He needs a good punch in the face.

Already tried that: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPK3cDl7Ftw

You he loves beating Rex and Rob Ryan's *****....