DJ where do you rank him?

[SJSF]

1 Calvin Johnson
2 Julio Jones
3 A.J. Green
4 Antonio Brown
5 Andre Johnson
6 Larry Fitzgerald
7 Victor Cruz
8 Brandon Marshall
9 Roddy White
10 Greg Jennings
11 Hakeem Nicks
12 Brandon Lloyd
13 Jordy Nelson
14 Wes Welker
15 Eric Decker
16 Dez Bryant
17 Steve Smith
18 Demaryius Thomas
19 Percy Harvin
20 Dwayne Bowe
21 Marques Colston
22 Vincent Jackson
23 Reggie Wayne
24 Pierre Garcon
25 Mike Wallace
26 Torrey Smith
27 DJ
28 Stevie Johnson
29 Miles Austin
30 Jeremy Maclin

[BDawk4Prez]

23-25 range, IF I'm judging him as ONLY a WR.

IF I'm going off of playmaking ability, 10-13.

[25YrsNcounting]

I'd take every single WR over him.

[25YrsNcounting]

23-25 range, IF I'm judging him as ONLY a WR.

IF I'm going off of playmaking ability, 10-13.

Agreed.

[EaglesRuleWorld]

1 Calvin Johnson
2 A.J. Green
3 Larry Fitzgerald
4 Julio Jones
5 Andre Johnson
6 Brandon Marshall
7 Victor Cruz
8 Roddy White
9 Hakeem Nicks
10 Greg Jennings
11 Wes Welker
12 Dez Bryant
13 Vincent Jackson
14 Percy Harvin
15 Demaryius Thomas
16 Marques Colston
17 Steve Smith
18 Mike Wallace
19 Jordy Nelson
20 Dwayne Bowe
21 Brandon Lloyd
22 Eric Decker
23 Reggie Wayne
24 Stevie Johnson
25 DJ
26 Miles Austin
27 Torrey Smith
28 Antonio Brown
29 Pierre Garcon
30 Jeremy Maclin

[monkeyboy]

1 Calvin Johnson
2 Julio Jones
3 A.J. Green
4 Antonio Brown
5 Andre Johnson
6 Larry Fitzgerald
7 Victor Cruz
8 Brandon Marshall
9 Roddy White
10 Greg Jennings
11 Hakeem Nicks
12 Brandon Lloyd
13 Jordy Nelson
14 Wes Welker
15 Eric Decker
16 Dez Bryant
17 Steve Smith
18 Demaryius Thomas
19 Percy Harvin
20 Dwayne Bowe
21 Marques Colston
22 Vincent Jackson
23 Reggie Wayne
24 Pierre Garcon
25 Mike Wallace
26 Torrey Smith
27 DJ
28 Stevie Johnson
29 Miles Austin
30 Jeremy Maclin

first of all your list is god awful brown #4, Thomas #18?

[SJSF]

the list was a copy and paste from a fantasy football website and then i made a few changes, But i just wanted a good group of Wr's to look at. All i know i would rank him about 25. He isn't a PR anymore so he is certainly in the 25 range.

[BDawk4Prez]

EB4L is going to have a coronary with this thread.

[Gangreenseason]

probably at number 18 on that list

[Burkey3472]

He's 20-25 in my book.

[papirico52]

We should have gone with Nicks

[BDawk4Prez]

We should have gone with Nicks

Well duh.

[BDawk4Prez]

1 Calvin Johnson
2 Julio Jones
3 A.J. Green
4 Antonio Brown
5 Andre Johnson
6 Larry Fitzgerald
7 Victor Cruz
8 Brandon Marshall
9 Roddy White
10 Greg Jennings
11 Hakeem Nicks
12 Brandon Lloyd
13 Jordy Nelson
14 Wes Welker
15 Eric Decker
16 Dez Bryant
17 Steve Smith
18 Demaryius Thomas
19 Percy Harvin
20 Dwayne Bowe
21 Marques Colston
22 Vincent Jackson
23 Reggie Wayne
24 Pierre Garcon
25 Mike Wallace
26 Torrey Smith
27 DJ
28 Stevie Johnson
29 Miles Austin
30 Jeremy Maclin

Players I would take over Jackson, IF the rest of the roster remained the same. I am not factoring in anything other than "WR". Of course, if Jackson was used differently, that would change the way I looked at the list.

Jackson is a top 15 playmaker, a top 25 WR.

[Dragonzord]

These are the only wide outs I wouldn't take ahead of Jackson. This is counting his playmaking skills and Wr skills together.

12 Brandon Lloyd

15 Eric Decker

17 Steve Smith

26 Torrey Smith

29 Miles Austin

30 Jeremy Maclin

[phillybirdblog]

These are the only wide outs I wouldn't take ahead of Jackson. This is counting his playmaking skills and Wr skills together.

12 Brandon Lloyd

15 Eric Decker

17 Steve Smith

26 Torrey Smith

29 Miles Austin

30 Jeremy Maclin

...wouldn't have to choose number 30 over Jackson anyway haha....we got em both.

I would take Decker though...I think he's a pretty solid receiver.