Who Has the Best "Combined" Roster: LA or NY?

[DoMeFavors]

Lopez should start team NY, Tyson is a role player

[Raps08-09 Champ]

He never had Steve Nash either. A blind monkey could win 55 games with a prime Steve Nash. D'Antoni is an awful coach. Period.

Coaches have failed to make impact in the playoffs before with a Nash barely removed prime Nash.

Also, prove he's an awful coach.

[Raps08-09 Champ]

So were just going to assume his team would of beaten a prime Duncan, Parker and Ginobili had they not been suspended? Long shot.

Well it is common sense to assume that the team with the better advantage would've won.

Antoni's PHX were regular season champs and postseason chumps

He's had the most playoff wins out of the 4 coaches.

[AsfanSince99]

Lopez should start team NY, Tyson is a role player

I started Tyson bc I don't think Lopez can guard Howard, I'd rather have Lopez's offense off the bench.

[strahan92osi72]

Coaches have failed to make impact in the playoffs before with a Nash barely removed prime Nash.

Also, prove he's an awful coach.

Look at his defensive stats his whole career, even when he road on Nash's coattails for his PHX success. Look at his NYK record the last 4 years while you're at it.

[strahan92osi72]

Lopez should start team NY, Tyson is a role player

So is Lopez.

[waveycrockett]

Well it is common sense to assume that the team with the better advantage would've won.



He's had the most playoff wins out of the 4 coaches.

He also had the most talent to work with out the 4

Prime Nash, prime Amare, prime Joe Johnson, Prime Marion and his teams were a perenial 2nd round exit team almost every year.

[strahan92osi72]

I agree that the LA team has this one by a lot, but I have to disagree with you in the coaching category. I dont think any of the 4 coaches have a distinct advantage over the other.

D'Antoni's offense is superb but his defensive is non-existent

Woodson is a great D coach, but his offense lacks creativity

Avery just isnt my cup of tea

And I personally dont think VDN is that good of coach, but thats just me

Notice he can't even answer a valid point?

[DoMeFavors]

I started Tyson bc I don't think Lopez can guard Howard, I'd rather have Lopez's offense off the bench.

Lopez is a low post scorer, that can score and open up the floor for the shooters of Melo,Deron,Joe

[DoMeFavors]

So is Lopez.

Lopez is the best player on the Nets

[AsfanSince99]

Lopez is the best player on the Nets

Gotta be a joke.

Jwill?

[strahan92osi72]

Lopez is the best player on the Nets

All he does is score, he plays no defense, can't rebound, and has no athleticism. Jamal Crawford can score too, I guess he's a star too and not a role player.

[Sactown]

LA and it's not even close

LA has a better back court
and front court.

BG and D12 would abuse the NY front court

and with CP3 controlling the pace, it just wouldn't be fair lol.. Melo is good, but he's the best player for NY and he isn't even top 3 for LA

CP3
Dwight
Kobe
BG

all are better players.

plus if you consider defense LA is just so much better it's not close

CP3
Dwight
Kobe
MWP

are all top notch defenders

While
D-will
Lopez
Melo
JJ
and
Amare are not.

a more comparable scenario is like SAC/GSW lol

Curry
Reke
Barnes
Lee
Cousins

[DoMeFavors]

All he does is score, he plays no defense, can't rebound, and has no athleticism. Jamal Crawford can score too, I guess he's a star too and not a role player.

Lopez is a great post player, there is a difference between a scorer like Crawford and a talented scorer like Brook. He is playing good d this year almost 3 blocks a game and Nets are a top defensive team. And he does have athleticism he dunks all the time.

[waveycrockett]

All he does is score, he plays no defense, can't rebound, and has no athleticism. Jamal Crawford can score too, I guess he's a star too and not a role player.

He averages almost 3 blocks a game. For guy with no athleticism scoring 20 and averaging 3 blocks is pretty impressive. I didn't realize Jamal Crawford shoots 55% from the field and wasn't a chucker.