Who Has the Best "Combined" Roster: LA or NY?

[AsfanSince99]

melo is not close to a superstar, unless your a knicks homer.

First of all, I hate the Knicks, 2nd of all, I think Melo would abuse MWP.

And just like the LAL can't play together with their team of stars, I think having Melo as your go-to guy wins it for NY/BKN in a 7-game series.

[Raps08-09 Champ]

It's a stupid question. If the Kings have enough to beat

Nash
Kobe
MWP
Gasol
Dwight

that NY team certainly has wayyyyyy more than enough especially if LA has Dantoni/VDN as its coaches.

D'Antoni is probably the best coach out of the 4.

[strahan92osi72]

Anyway I'll take the LA team by a slim margain.

[strahan92osi72]

D'Antoni is probably the best coach out of the 4.

You're joking right?

[ball4reel]

Melo and D-Will Are not superstars??? I'm not a Knick homer and i can't stand the Nets. I would give the edge to L.a, but not by a landslide.. Call me a homer but they are both superstars. Not every1 can be a Lebron or cp3..

[AsfanSince99]

D'Antoni is probably the best coach out of the 4.

Is that why they fired his *** in NY?

[Raps08-09 Champ]

Is that why they fired his *** in NY?

No. They fired him because he wasn't a good fit.

[Raps08-09 Champ]

You're joking right?

No. I state facts.

[strahan92osi72]

No. They fired him because he wasn't a good fit.

Woodson is still a much better coach than Dumb'toni. I actually think Avery is a better coach than that buffoon.

[C-Style]

Paul/Nash
Kobe/Crawford
Butler/Metta
Griffin/Gasol
Dwight/Jordan

How is this even close?

[strahan92osi72]

No. I state facts.

You state opinions, and wrong ones in this case.

[lvlheaded]

melo is not close to a superstar, unless your a knicks homer.

First, I pick LA, and for me it isnt that close.

But I have to ask, what is with your hate of the Knicks? Im not saying Melo is the greatest thing since sliced bread or anything but he is a very very good player and he is having a very good start to the year on a team that is having an equally impressive start. This is the third thread ive gone into today that you are just out of no where going out of your way to discount the Knicks. I have teams I hate in every sport but I still try to be impartial when discussing them. Im just curious who inside the Knicks organization pissed in your cheerios?

UNRELATED NOTE: I was pulling for your Dolphins today. They are close

[Raps08-09 Champ]

Woodson is still a much better coach than Dumb'toni. I actually think Avery is a better coach than that buffoon.

You can make a case for Woodson, but Avery is definitely not better than him.

[Raps08-09 Champ]

You state opinions, and wrong ones in this case.

It's a fact D'Antoni is the best coach. Just because you can't see it doesn't mean it's not fact.

[waveycrockett]

D'Antoni is probably the best coach out of the 4.

yeaaaaaaaaaaa righttttttttttttttt. He really proved he was a better coach than Mike Woodson last season...