New Stat: Norm+ QB Rankings

[NormSizedMidget]

Since FortDetroit hates QB rating because it adds arbitrary weighting to statistics I took the 4 main stat to me that show QB prowess. And made my own system. No number like 93.6 is equated, purely a ranking based off just this year.

Therefore it's not good comparing to other years since it will only show where a QB ranks that season among his peers.

Here's what I got.

1. Robert Griffin III ---------- Passer Rating-Rodgers
2. Peyton Manning ---------- Passer Rating-Brady
3. Aaron Rodgers ---------- Passer Rating-Peyton
4. Alex Smith ---------- Passer Rating-RGIII
5. Tom Brady ---------- Passer Rating-Alex Smith
6. Ben Roethlisberger ---------- Passer Rating-Ben
7. Drew Brees ---------- Passer Rating-Brees
8. Matt Schaub ---------- Passer Rating-Ryan
9. Matt Ryan ---------- Passer Rating-Schaub
10. Josh Freeman ---------- Passer Rating-Freeman
11. Andy Dalton
12. Russell Wilson
13. Joe Flacco
14. Philip Rivers
15. Kevin Kolb
16. Tony Romo
17. Eli Manning
18. Carson Palmer
19. Jake Locker
20. Matthew Stafford
21. Sam Bradford
22. Christian Ponder
23. Cam Newton
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick
25. Matt Hasselbeck
26. Jay Cutler
27. Michael Vick
28. Blaine Gabbert
29. Andrew Luck
30. Mark Sanchez
31. Ryan Tannehill
32. Brandon Weeden
33. John Skelton
34. Matt Cassel

So using TD% INT% Comp% and YPA UNWEIGHTED seems to produce pretty similar results....top 5 all the same but in a different order. Nobody top 10 off by more than one spot. Seems to only produce a number and not really add weight to any one stat.

Proof that Fort's whining over the weighting of it means nothing. Just like I said.