Offensive Rookie of the Year: Luck or RG3?

[alexander_37]

20 TD's for Trillson.

[r.i.p.taylor21]

I hope RGIII wins just because I can't imagine having to listen to the outcry from Skins fans.

They really want this and spend far too much time trying to discredit Andrew Luck.

discredit Luck isnt the agenda. stating the obvious is.

[IHateTheSkins]

"And down goes RG3"

Until next week.

When he starts.

[mattcribbin]

discredit Luck isnt the agenda. stating the obvious is.

Fact. No one is crying. I don't care if RGIII wins or not. He just deserves and i'm making that point. I mean, look at Luck's stats. And the soft schedule the Colts have had.

[NormSizedMidget]

discredit Luck isnt the agenda. stating the obvious is.

You aren't an impartial party. Yet all Skins fans talk like they don't have a bias. It's a complete joke.

[BullsFan_1]

**** ROY, we gunnin' for dat superb owl *****

[NormSizedMidget]

Fact. No one is crying. I don't care if RGIII wins or not. He just deserves and i'm making that point. I mean, look at Luck's stats. And the soft schedule the Colts have had.

Who gives a **** about SOS?

We're comparing players.

I'd love to see Luck's numbers with a top 5 rusher. Instead of barely having a top 30 one.

I mean I could easily to back and forth all day on this.


You can go SOS and I can go run game.

You can go stats, and I can point out how much they're asking of him and his deep ball percentage. Etc etc.

[JNA17]

At this point, its RGIII or Wilson's award.

[mattcribbin]

Who gives a **** about SOS?

We're comparing players.

I'd love to see Luck's numbers with a top 5 rusher. Instead of barely having a top 30 one.

I mean I could easily to back and forth all day on this.


You can go SOS and I can go run game.

You can go stats, and I can point out how much they're asking of him and his deep ball percentage. Etc etc.

And I can go, a big part of Morriss' success is related to RGIII. And I can go your defense isn't nearly as sorry as ours. And I can go. I don't give a damn about your system. Get a better one if you want your QB to do better.

[IHateTheSkins]

Any player that can put up 45 on the once 4-0 Cardinals gets the ROY award, end of discussion.

[NormSizedMidget]

And I can go, a big part of Morriss' success is related to RGIII. And I can go your defense isn't nearly as sorry as ours. And I can go. I don't give a damn about your system. Get a better one if you want your QB to do better.

What's wrong with their system? The stats aren't good? Oh noes. They're 8 and 4.

But exactly. I'm saying it's endless.

And it's not MY defense lol. I'm not a Colts and and I would vote RGIII OROY.

BTW if I say Morris' success is the system and RGIII I get killed for underrating him.

[OldStyleCubbies]

The SOS argument always makes me laugh. Ya Luck can really control that... and as a Colts fan I'd much prefer to have a player that can lead us to the playoffs, which it looks like Luck has pretty much wrapped up. Skins will be out after faltering next week against a tough CLE team on the road.

[JNA17]

What's wrong with their system? The stats aren't good? Oh noes. They're 8 and 4.

except team success has nothing to do with OROY. Andrew Luck individually, has had a sub-par year, with NOW as many INTs as he does TDs when their are two other rookie QBs doing much better than that.

[NormSizedMidget]

except team success has nothing to do with OROY. Andrew Luck individually, has had a sub-par year, with NOW as many INTs as he does TDs when their are two other rookie QBs doing much better than that.

Doing better statistically.

Well not having to play at near the level of difficulty because of their system and surrounding run game talent.


But nobody understands that. We're all baseball fans who run to google and look at the stats and make their decision purely off that.


If before this year you told me the Colts would be 8-4 and someone else would win the OROY I would have died ****ing laughing. It's insane it might happen.

[IHateTheSkins]

the sos argument always makes me laugh. Ya luck can really control that... And as a colts fan i'd much prefer to have a player that can lead us to the playoffs, which it looks like luck has pretty much wrapped up. Skins will be out after faltering next week against a tough cle team on the road.

lol.