Offensive Rookie of the Year: Luck or RG3?

[jpro611]

In before the squawks fans try to say Wilson should win

[Hitman21]

RG3 isnt making rookie mistakes.

[odiz]

This is a stats based award. Team performance should not be much of a factor. RGIII should win it but both Wilson and Morris have been better then Luck.

[Shareeb_omac2]

RG3 is playing better than everyone but Brady and Manning.

[FortDetroit]

RG3 is playing better than everyone but Brady and Manning.

ha, no.

[Pinstripe power]

rg3

[FWBrodie]

Which QB trails only Brady since Week 5
2012 Total QBR After Week 5
Rank QB Total QBR
1 Tom Brady 85.1
2 Russell Wilson 82.4
3 Peyton Manning 78.8
4 Robert Griffin III 77.7
5 Aaron Rodgers 76.0

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcwest/post...y-since-week-5

[raiderposting]

if RG3 had reggie wayne he would have a couple more wins, there were many close games where the redskins receivers had multiple big time drops.

[FWBrodie]

BTW, it's currently Griffin. Russell Wilson is coming in hot though.

[Hitman21]

BTW, it's currently Griffin. Russell Wilson is coming in hot though.

Just wondering how you think seahawks would be doing with RG3 instead of Wilson. I like wilson, and i like your team, so this has no under lying intentions. Just something ive always been wondering myself. I believe if RG3 was a seahawk, they would be locks for the playoffs. That defense, along with lynch, rice, and company would make a legit squad.

[Gibby23]

BTW, it's currently Griffin. Russell Wilson is coming in hot though.

The seahawks are last in pass attempts. If he passes more his numbers are due to come down a bit, the same with Alex smith, the niners don't throw much either.

[FWBrodie]

The seahawks are last in pass attempts. If he passes more his numbers are due to come down a bit, the same with Alex smith, the niners don't throw much either.

That's one opinion.

His TD's and yards would fly up.

[OldStyleCubbies]

Andrew Luck.

[bwallstreet]

Guys try and be neutral for a second.

RG3 and Luck are both playing very good and you could make an argument for or against either.

Let me ask you this

If Doug Martin leads the NFL in yards from scrimmage how does he not win the award?

Winning and playing good as a rookie is nothing out of the ordinary. Leading the league in rushing yards and recieving yards combined is unheard of. Doug is on pace to hit 2000 yards(rushing+recieving). I feel like hes getting shafted.

[Stamina]

RGIII easy. Luck turned out to be better than I expected. But Griff is on top.