I like Luck and all but no way no how he should be ROY, lets talk specifically numbers here... they are quite bad... one of the worst passer ratings, his TD-INT ratio is horrible, while on the other hand, RG3 and Wilson's numbers are actually very good
Luck td int ratio is due to playing with a bunch of rookies and quite a few tip balls. A moron would have to assume that wilson and rg3 are better passers when they face third and short more often. They hardly pass the ball and have a great play action game. Luck has turned the colts offense into a top 5 passing offense as a rookie. That can't be said of rg3 and wilson.