Miller is not a bad pick because as I said, a sixth round pick usually does not stick. Therefore it does not matter. How can Thomas be a bad move when he was traded for the pick he was taken with? That makes it a wash. Dillard was a bad pick, but only because of injuries.
How was Holt a bad move? He brought veteran leadership to this team. I don't get how it could be a bad move especially since he came relatively cheap. Brewster an Bradfield were UDFA pickups that are now starters. How are they not good moves? Shorts is on his way to 1,000 yards, the first 1,000 yard WR for the Jags in a long time.
He's not the greatest, but not the worst like sme of you make him out to be. I don't think you people realize how hard it is to get guys to come to Jacksonville unless you throw a truckload of money at them. The next GM will go through the same cycle until everyone wants his head off in two years. It's a viscous cycle in Jacksonville. Not many GMs could do a better job. You will realize that when Gene is gone. One thing is certain though......Gene >>>>>>>>Shack
Last edited by kingjaymes23; 11-26-2012 at 10:10 PM.
disagree... its weird shacks record is much better than genes. genes record has gotten worse every year in office..
genes only good draft pick in first is monroe. blackmon was khan and gabbert and alualu are bust
you can look at schacks reggie's, byron, rj, but look at the rest, tony b, freddy t, DD, big john, marcus, hardy, etc.
shack made the team a playoff contender 1 year after starting from NOTHING
To say Gene is better than Shack is a joke. Even if you think he is better than Harris picks that dont mean ****, Harris wasnt very good either but his teams were competitive every year and did go to the playoffs a few times.
Last edited by kingjaymes23; 11-26-2012 at 11:00 PM.
ok so shack and gene both suck dick. whoever was the gm/pro personal from 95-03 should be rehired
it was probably coughlin. never shouldve fired him
well the only stat that matter
playoff appearences -2 shack
Yeah Tom Coughlin was drafting the players before Shack got here.
Really happy that Henne is succeeding and showing that maybe, just maybe he could be a solid QB for us. I just hope this isn't saving Gene Smith's job. If we finish with 5 wins or so, does he still get fired? In my mind, he should without a doubt. I just am not sold on it if we continue to win down the stretch.
I love Blackmon
Rookie of the year , Nobody saw it coming.